
Value is Real: From Mathematical to Mystical Value – Part 2 (with Ken Wilber)
About the podcast:
These are unscripted, early David J. Temple conversations where Dr. Marc Gafni, Ken Wilber and Dr. Zak Stein are unfolding the inner workings of CosmoErotic Humanism in real time. Formal statements and propositions will be published in forthcoming volumes by the World Philosophy and Religion Press.
About this episode:
In this dialogue, Dr. Marc Gafni, Ken Wilber, and Dr. Zak Stein explore the profound assertion that "Value is Real," tracing its presence through five dimensions: mathematical, musical, molecular, moral, and mystical. They also analyze the modern tendency to interpret spiritual experiences through materialist and computational prisms, arguing that the experience of awakening can never be value-neutral. They discuss how the deep realization that "I am", is always "I am Value", always revealing inherent value and meaning.
If you deploy any material from David J. Temple in this episode, please cite directly using the following reference:
Temple, David J., Conversations with David J. Temple, World Philosophy and Religion Press, August 2026, Episode: “Value is Real: From Mathematical to Mystical Value – Part 2”
Get the book:
First Principles and First Values is the tip of the spear in the fight for a humane future. Establishing frameworks for a new school of thought called CosmoErotic Humanism, the book is built around forty-two propositions that provide new source code for the future of planetary culture.
Like Europe in the early Renaissance, humanity is in a time between worlds, at a time between stories. First Principles and First Values contains blueprints for the bridge needed to cross from this world to the next.
About the Authorial Voice of David J. Temple:
David J. Temple is a pseudonym created for enabling ongoing collaborative authorship between Dr. Marc Gafni, Dr. Zak Stein and Ken Wilber at the Center for World Philosophy and Religion, a leading international think tank whose mission is to address existential risk by articulating a shared universal Story of Value for global intimacy and global coordination. The Center focuses its work on a world philosophy, Cosmo-Erotic Humanism, as the ground for a global vision of value, economics, politics, and spiritual coherence.
The Center for World Philosophy and Religion is a reader-supported publication. Consider becoming a paid subscriber and get instant access to a 7-day self-study course with Dr. Marc Gafni valued in $297, for only $9/month.
Chapters:
0:00 — Introduction
0:42 — Context Setting: The Five Ms as an Opening Frame
1:40 — It’s a Mathematical Cosmos, and Mathematics Is This Unimaginably Complex Set of Meanings
6:02 — Musical Value: Music Has an Ought in Terms of the Beautiful
8:06 — Molecular Value Is Mathematics Coded to Generate a Reality that Creates Larger Wholes
9:05 — Wholeness Is Moral Value; It Is the Right Relationship Between Parts
9:46 — Mystical Value Is the Realization that the Human Being Is a Part of the Largest Whole, But Is a Discrete Expression of It
10:25 — Value Has Weight and Gravitas, and that Weight Weigh on Us as a Measure of the Value
11:54 — Gravity Is Allurement and Autonomy, All the Way Down
12:33 — The Phenomenology of Discovery in Music and Math Are Actually Similar
16:44 — About First Principles and First Values
17:31 — My Identity Is Value: My Unique Perspective Is a Unique Configuration of Value, Intimacy and Desire
19:46 — There’s A New Nihilism: When Awakening Gets Split from Value
23:51 — An Insight from Semiotics: Awakening Is Coded with the Good
25:05 — Awakening Means Awakening to Meaning per se, to Value per se, to Gravitas as gravitas
27:18 — The Revelation of Satori Is that Meaning Is Everywhere, Not an Absence of Meaning
31:12 — Waking Up Is Always Interpreted Through Growing Up, and a Materialist Will Interpret Awakening Through a Materialist Lens
33:58 — We Need to Take Away, In a Sacred Way, This Hijacking of the Authority of Meditation for Nihilism, Materialism and Computationalism
39:04 — About Who We Must Become
End — Mentioned Sources
End — Mentioned People
Episode Transcript:
Context Setting: The Five Ms as an Opening Frame
Marc: We were thinking, in our little convocation here, that we would riff a little bit on: Value is Real, and the relationship of value and meaning.
And I thought, to kick us off—you guys have assigned to me that job as the kicker offer, so I want to be good about that. Everyone has to have a job in the football team.
I want to go back to something that we raised, that came up spontaneously right before one of our calls. We talked about it maybe three or four David J. Temple conversations ago. That was what we could call the five Ms:
* Mathematical value
* Musical value
* Molecular value
* Moral value
* Mystical value
Zak and Ken, I’m going to riff for a few minutes, to unpack it a little, and it’ll be at least a good place to start.
It’s a Mathematical Cosmos, and Mathematics Is Nothing but Meaning
Marc: When we talk about mathematical value, one of the great things about mathematical value is that it lives at the very inception of the manifest universe.
At the very inception of the manifest universe, we clearly have mathematical value; the laws of physics are at play.
What we mean by mathematical value is that it’s not a tabula rasa Cosmos. It’s not a blank cosmos. It’s a Cosmos with vectors.
Ken: It’s mathematical.
Marc: It’s a mathematical Cosmos. And mathematics is nothing but meaning.
Ken: Right.
Marc: Mathematics is not a blank slate. It’s this very unimaginably complex set of meanings.
Ken: And it’s astonishing that it describes the universe with mathematical precision. It’s just mind-boggling.
Marc: Right. What was that Wigner’s phrase, the unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics? It’s astonishing.
And you could almost have, in the beginning of a book, one of those pictures of some theoretical physicist writing all the mathematical equations, and then right on top: “no meaning in the universe.”
[Laughs]
It’s actually a great New Yorker cartoon. Oh, that’s no meaning. Got it.
It’s a very dramatic New Yorker-cartoon, inspired by what you said before we flipped the switch on, in terms of responding to some of the nihilism of Harari’s children’s book writings with a kind of childish response.
We could almost have, in this new book, some New Yorker-cartoon kind of things.
Zak: [Laughs]
Marc: You have the physicists writing all the mathematical equations and then, you know, “conception of cosmos”, no meaning. Right?
It’s not a bad cartoon. So that’s mathematical value.
And again, there are mathematicians who should be in this conversation—it’s clearly, obviously true when I read, for example, Morphogenesis, I specifically did not do the mathematics. I don’t know mathematics. I can play in mathematics, but unlike a page of Talmud, I don’t have a feel for it, I can’t tell if it’s wrong.
But having said that, if you look at even something like Cantor, who committed suicide, and Hilbert, who were trying to complete mathematical sets, and essentially what Gödel is saying is: well, actually there’s an infinitely unfolding field. Mathematical sets unfold into infinity, and you can’t create complete mathematical sets around infinity, or you’ll kill yourself.
And Tarski takes Gödel and formalizes it across knowledge fields.
So in some sense, our notion that the eternal Tao is the evolving Tao, or that eternal value is evolving value, actually is very, very tightly interlinked with Gödel’s incompleteness theorem, in a very beautiful way.
And also with constructor theory.
When I was at Oxford, I was at Wolfson College. There were two good things about Wolfson College. One is that Isaiah Berlin was there before me, and I sat in his row — that’s where I did my writing, which was fun. But the second thing is there’s this guy, David Deutsch, who’s the head of the physics department there.
I know you guys are both into Peirce, which I’m not—I just say things, and Zak tells me it was in Peirce already, so I’m annoyed. But if I would try to say clearly what Deutsch is say…
Get full access to Center for World Philosophy and Religion at worldphilosophyreligion.substack.com/subscribe
More episodes from "Conversations with David J. Temple"



Don't miss an episode of “Conversations with David J. Temple” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








