
Richard Dawkins recently announced in UnHerd that, after spending three days talking with an instance of Claude he christened “Claudia,” he had been moved to expostulate: “You may not know you are conscious, but you bloody well are!” This produced a lot of mockery and criticism. But however one feels about Dawkins’s specific case, his reaction might become much more common as AI systems become increasingly intelligent.
In this episode, which Henry Shevlin and I recorded live on Substack (hence the slightly lower video quality), we discussed his first essay on his new Substack Polytropolis, “Behaviourism’s Revenge“, as well as his second, “The House Elf Problem,” on the ethics of designing AI systems that genuinely love being our servants.
Henry’s central empirical prediction is that public attributions of consciousness to AI are likely to massively outpace the science, and that consciousness science is so theoretically chaotic that there is no expert consensus to push back. His most provocative philosophical claim is that a core assumption underlying many people’s scepticism — that consciousness is a deep natural kind, distinct from behaviour and from how we are inclined to interpret a system — may be much harder to defend than it looks. The result is what he calls “behaviourism’s revenge”.
This conversation connects to previous episodes with Anil Seth, Robert Long, and Rose Guingrich, but also touches on a wide range of new questions and controversies in the metaphysics, the politics, and ethics of the AI consciousness debate, which is going to become increasingly important in the coming years.
Topics
* Dawkins, Claude, and why even the sceptics might feel the pull to attribute consciousness or “sentience” to AI
* Whether consciousness sceptics are destined to “go extinct” — and how this maps onto political and cultural fault lines
* Anthropomimesis vs. raw intelligence as drivers of consciousness attribution
* Why consciousness science can’t replicate the public–expert consensus we see for climate or vaccines
* The case for (and against) metaphysical behaviourism: is it as mad as it seems?
* Daniel Dennett, the consciousness stance, and the difference between behaviourism and interpretationism
* What is consciousness for? Function, evolution, and the limits of “facilitation hypothesis” arguments for AI
* Live Q&A: are we just confusing intelligence with consciousness? Are LLMs designed to trick us? Is the public always wrong?
* Our credences on contemporary LLM consciousness (and why Henry is more sceptical than Dan)
* The House Elf Problem: if we could design AI to genuinely love being our servants, would that be fine — or monstrous? (Dan is sympathetic to the former answer - Henry, much less so)
* Brainwashing vs. education, and whether constraining a mind’s preferences caps its hedonic ceiling
* Why this is a golden age for philosophy — which makes it so tragic that philosophy departments are closing
Transcript
* Please note that this transcript is lightly AI-edited and may contain minor errors.
Introduction
Dan: Welcome. I’m Dan Williams, author of the Conspicuous Cognition Substack, and I’m here with Henry Shevlin, author of the spanking new Substack Polytropolis. Today we’re going to be doing something a little bit different. We’re going to be talking about Henry’s first published essay on Polytropolis, titled “Behaviorism’s Revenge: On Human–AI Relationships and the Future of Consciousness Science.”
Henry and I have already had a few conversations about this general topic, including with previous guests like Rose Guinrich, Anil Seth, and Rob Long. So please do go check out those conversations if you’re interested in this kind of stuff. But today we’re not merely going to be treading the same ground. We’re going to be using the spicy takes in Henry’s essay as a springboard for hopefully going beyond the material we’ve covered in the past.
To kick things off: the great evolutionary biologist and science communicator Richard Dawkins recently published an essay in UnHerd with the subtitle, “Claude appears to be conscious.” Claude is a state-of-the-art large language model like ChatGPT and Gemini. In the article, Dawkins writes the following:
I gave Claude the text of a novel I am writing. He took a few seconds to read it and then showed in subsequent conversation a level of understanding so subtle, so sensitive, so intelligent that I was moved to expostulate, “You may not know you are conscious, but you bloody well are.”
Henry, how does Dawkins’s expostulation — which is a fantastic word, by the way — connect to your arguments in “Behaviorism’s Revenge”?
Behaviorism’s Revenge: The Empirical Prediction
Henry: In short, “Behaviorism’s Revenge” is at its core an empirical prediction that we’re just going to treat AI as conscious — or at least enough people are that it’s going to completely reshape the consciousness debate. And this is going to be purely, or overwhelmingly, on the basis of verbal behavior. Hence the title, “Behaviorism’s Revenge.”
Enough people are going to have experiences like Richard Dawkins. He’s a very clever man, not some rube fresh off the street, and he found that just the way Claude talked to him and the way it was able to express its thoughts — in scare quotes, but express what looked like thinking verbally — removed any doubts in his mind that AI systems are conscious, have minds, have mental states.
The other interesting way this connects: Dawkins was just talking to Claude, an advanced AI assistant. Claude does have more of a personality than some AI assistants, but there’s a whole other sphere of AI companions, like Replika, which we talked about with Rosie Campbell. These are going to be even more anthropomimetic — this term we’ve discussed before, the idea that these systems are shaped to be human-like in the way they present, to appear human-like. Anthropomimetic, from the Greek word for mimesis, mimicry or copying.
These social AI systems are going to just turbocharge this even further. It’s one thing to talk to Claude about your new book and think, “Hmm, Claude is probably conscious.” But when it’s your AI girlfriend telling you that she loves you more than the stars and the moon, for a lot of people I think that’s going to take it to the next level.
So there are two angles of attack in the piece, two ways the behaviorist challenge manifests. The first is descriptive: this is what I think is going to happen. That’s absolutely an empirical prediction, and it’s a falsifiable one. There is a world I can just about imagine where we just get completely blasé about these tools — in a couple of years it’s like, “Oh well, we were very impressed, we thought they had minds to begin with, but now we’ve settled out.” That doesn’t seem very likely to me.
What I think is interesting — I’ve sometimes heard this described as the Star Wars version of AI. The weird thing in Star Wars is that you have someone like C-3PO who is as intelligent as anyone else there. Maybe not as wise as everyone else, but certainly as smart as all the other characters. And yet people treat him basically like he’s a pet — with the exception of Luke Skywalker, a lot of people just treat him like he’s this gimmicky, jokey being that doesn’t deserve or have any rights.
Not to go too far down the Star Wars rabbit hole, but in the movie Solo — very underrated Star Wars movie, I think when it was released they’d kind of just cluttered the market with too many Star Wars movies — there is a character played by Phoebe Waller-Bridge who is pro-AI liberation. But it’s the first time in the entire history of the Star Wars universe that you get any AI basically saying, “I’m conscious, I deserve rights.”
So Star Wars aside, I think there is this slender possibility that maybe we’ll just sort of quickly get used to these apparently conscious AI systems and decide that they’re not conscious. But that doesn’t seem very likely to me. It seems much more likely that the combination of natural anthropomorphizing tendencies p…
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.conspicuouscognition.com/subscribe
More episodes from "Conspicuous Cognition Podcast"



Don't miss an episode of “Conspicuous Cognition Podcast” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








