
#208: Why Grading Reform Creates Resistance (And What It Teaches Us About Change)
In Episode 208 of Coaching the Whole Educator, Becca Silver sits down with Dr. Shantha Smith, CEO of Crescendo Education Group, to explore why changing long-established grading practices can create significant pushback and what school leaders can learn from these challenges about navigating resistance and leading meaningful change.
Their conversation examines how grading practices reflect deeply held beliefs about teaching and learning, why teacher autonomy plays such a significant role in reactions to grading reform, and how grades often communicate much more than what students actually know and can do. From reassessment policies to the role of compliance and behavior in grading, Dr. Smith shares how rethinking these familiar practices can challenge educators' assumptions and create opportunities for deeper conversations about instruction and assessment.
But the conversation extends well beyond grading. Becca and Dr. Smith explore why top-down mandates can generate resistance, the importance of recognizing unmet needs beneath educator concerns, and how leaders can approach change differently by starting with willing educators, creating opportunities for experimentation, and using cycles of inquiry to guide implementation.
They also discuss how honoring teacher expertise, building trust, and creating collaborative relationships between teachers and leaders can transform the way school improvement initiatives unfold.
For instructional coaches, principals, and district leaders navigating resistance and leading school improvement, this episode offers a compelling perspective on how meaningful change can move from an initiative to a movement.
In This Episode
00:00 – Introduction: Grading Reform and School Leadership
01:48 – Why Schools Need to Rethink Grading Practices
04:21 – Student Learning vs. Performance: Rethinking Assessment
06:19 – Why Grading Reform Creates Teacher Resistance
09:23 – Teacher Beliefs, Autonomy, and Grading Practices
12:02 – What Grades Really Communicate About Student Learning
14:29 – Leading Change: Moving Beyond Top-Down Mandates
16:35 – Building Teacher Ownership by Starting With the Willing
18:35 – Collaborative Leadership and Sustainable School Improvement
Resistance Resources:
Resistance Solution Toolkit: https://www.thewholeeducator.com/resistance-solution-toolkit
Resistance Quiz: https://www.thewholeeducator.com/resistance-quiz
Resources Mentioned in This Episode
Connect with Dr. Shantha Smith and learn more about her work:
Crescendo Education Group:
https://crescendoedgroup.org/
Books mentioned:
- Grading for Equity by Joe Feldman
- The Performance Paradox by Eduardo Briceño
Let's Stay Connected!
www.thewholeeducator.com | [email protected]
More episodes from "Coaching the Whole Educator"



Don't miss an episode of “Coaching the Whole Educator” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








