Blazin' Grazin' And Other Wild Things podcast

Fire Management: Stop Chasing Fixed Seasons

0:00
59:29
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

The traditional spring burn window may be keeping land managers from accomplishing as much as they could with prescribed fire. University of Nebraska professor and rangeland ecologist Dirac Twidwell Ph.D. joins John Weir, Laura Goodman Ph.D. and Mark Turner Ph.D. to examine how fire behavior, burn-unit design, wind, drought, fuels and season interact—and why a calendar date or simple weather threshold does not tell the whole story about whether a burn can be safely and effectively completed.

The conversation also tackles eastern redcedar and woody encroachment from a different direction: manage the seed source before the pasture becomes a cedar problem. Twidwell explains why most new redcedar recruitment occurs relatively close to mature seed-producing trees, why mechanical removal without follow-up can quickly lose its value, and how prescribed fire can protect intact grasslands before restoration costs climb. It is a practical discussion about replacing one-size-fits-all fire rules with better planning, better risk management and earlier action.

Key takeaways for the episode description

  • Burn season does not have to mean spring. Growing-season and fall fire can provide additional opportunities when management objectives, fuels, weather and preparation align.
  • Burn-unit design changes risk. Twidwell argues that weather numbers alone cannot describe fire risk; fuel arrangement, firebreaks, volatile woody fuels and potential ember travel matter.
  • Wind deserves special attention. Wind can greatly increase ember transport, making it a critical factor in spot-fire potential.
  • Growing-season fire behaves differently. Green vegetation, precipitation and soil moisture can influence summer fire behavior in ways that dormant-season rules based heavily on relative humidity may not capture.
  • Prescribed fire prescriptions should evolve. The group questions whether guidelines developed decades ago should automatically define every acceptable burn today.
  • More available burn days can mean more fire accomplished. Expanding the calendar can help landowners work around cattle operations, labor demands and narrow spring weather windows.
  • Eastern redcedar prevention is cheaper than restoration. Protecting intact grasslands before dense encroachment develops can avoid much larger future treatment costs.
  • Manage the seed source, not just visible cedar cover. Mature seed-producing trees can influence surrounding grassland well before the landscape looks heavily invaded.
  • Cutting trees without follow-up is not a complete plan. Seedlings and surviving seed sources can rapidly reestablish woody cover after mechanical treatment.
  • Fire management needs long-term planning. Fire frequency, treatment follow-up and landscape-scale cooperation matter more than viewing a single burn as a finished project.

Detailed timestamped rundown

00:00-02:59 — Introduction and episode setup. Sponsors are recognized, the hosts are introduced, and Dirac Twidwell is framed as a rangeland and fire ecologist whose career has challenged assumptions about prescribed fire, wildfire risk and woody encroachment.
02:59-08:08 — Twidwell’s path into fire ecology. Twidwell explains how an engineering- and science-oriented undergraduate environment led him toward ecology, Missouri conservation work and eventually Oklahoma State University. He discusses early mentors and his transition into fire research across Oklahoma, Texas and Nebraska.
08:09-13:13 — Extreme fire experiments challenge an assumption. The conversation turns to research asking whether prescribed fire could kill larger cedar trees. Twidwell describes using fire behavior and ember-transport science to redesign experimental burn areas and safely study more intense fires.
13:15-15:33 — Old prescriptions meet changing conditions. Twidwell discusses low-wind burning, ember movement and why prescribed-fire practices developed decades ago deserve continued testing, especially as drought, atmospheric demand and weather extremes change.
15:34-20:40 — Expanding fire beyond spring. Weir and Goodman discuss growing-season fire and observations from Oklahoma and Texas. Late-summer and fall burning can accomplish management work at a time when ranch crews may have fewer competing livestock duties.
20:40-22:04 — Start the burn year earlier. Turner suggests psychologically treating late summer or fall as the beginning of the burn season, allowing managers to get ahead rather than scrambling to finish everything in spring. Strategic blacklines and preparation can also create opportunities for later burning.
22:05-28:36 — What actually makes a burn risky? Twidwell questions labels such as “good,” “bad” or “marginal” burn days. He explains how wind, drought, fuel characteristics, juniper and ember transport interact to create actual risk.
28:36-30:05 — Why prescribed fire resists simple recipes. Weir contrasts fire with practices that can be summarized on a product label. Every burn unit differs in personnel needs, equipment, containment and acceptable conditions.
30:06-34:50 — Fire research needs better fire measurements. Goodman and Twidwell discuss studies that compare “fire” with “no fire” while documenting relatively little about the fire itself. They argue for better information about intensity, consumption, fuels and fire behavior.
34:53-38:21 — Questioning hard thresholds. The hosts discuss rules such as waiting a fixed period after fire or avoiding burns above a specific temperature. Twidwell warns against turning broad assumptions into universal management rules.
38:22-42:22 — Why wildfire reactions differ. The group explores why some landowners see beneficial ecological results after wildfire while other communities view fire primarily through its destructive consequences. The landscape context and the problem being solved matter.
42:25-46:10 — Eastern redcedar becomes the case study. Goodman asks about spatial conservation planning. Twidwell explains why redcedar is particularly useful for thinking about woody encroachment: it does not resprout, is highly fire-sensitive and produces large quantities of seed.
46:11-49:44 — The “two football fields” concept. Twidwell describes research showing that about 95% of new redcedar recruitment in the Nebraska work occurred within roughly two football fields of a seed source. That creates a practical planning zone landowners can identify and manage.
49:44-52:07 — Prevention beats expensive restoration. The conversation focuses on the economics of treating intact grassland early instead of waiting for dense cedar. Mechanical removal without follow-up can allow the problem to return quickly.
52:07-55:15 — From “cedar control” to seed-source management. Twidwell explains how changing the language helped ranchers think about risk differently. A windbreak may have value, but it can also be a seed source requiring active management.
55:16-58:05 — Catching encroachment while it is small. The group discusses identifying scattered seedlings before they turn into a landscape-scale problem. The objective is not to dictate a single treatment but to help landowners recognize the risk and build a plan.
58:05-59:29 — Closing thoughts. The hosts acknowledge that woody encroachment will remain a major Great Plains challenge and close the episode with an invitation for Twidwell to return.

Find all resources at BlazinGrazinWildThings.com

More episodes from "Blazin' Grazin' And Other Wild Things"