
A missing newborn call at 2 a.m. sounds like a nightmare, until you realize it can get worse by the minute. We’re joined by Green County, Wisconsin Sheriff Cody to walk through the case of Baby Harper, starting with the first dispatch, the early assumption that the infant might have been surrendered, and the gut-level moment investigators knew the story wasn’t lining up. We talk plainly about what law enforcement does when the clock is ticking, the weather is dangerous, and the smallest lead might be the only chance to bring a baby home alive.
We also dig into the real-world gap between having a Safe Haven law and having a Safe Haven option that people actually use. Sheriff Cody explains how his team checked hospitals, fire stations, and every plausible lead, and how the investigation shifted after a confession. Monica and Sheriff Cody discuss why Safe Haven Baby Boxes matter, especially in rural areas where resources are spread out and public awareness is uneven. If you’ve ever searched for infant surrender law in Wisconsin, newborn abandonment prevention, or Safe Haven Baby Box locations, this conversation puts those terms into lived reality.
Then we stay with what comes after the arrest: years of court delays, the weight of replaying body-worn camera footage, and the kind of trauma that doesn’t end when the scene does. Sheriff Cody shares how this case changed his agency’s approach to police mental health, including a move toward annual wellness checks with law-enforcement-specific counselors. We close with the hopeful action his community took: raising funds to install a Safe Haven Baby Box at the sheriff’s office now, not later, so the next person in crisis has a clear, immediate option.
If this story hits you, please subscribe, share the episode with someone who needs to know Safe Haven exists, and leave a review so more people can find Beyond the Box. What should communities do to make the safe choice the easiest choice?
Find Safe Haven Baby Boxes on:
Find Monica Kelsey on:
TikTok
More episodes from "Beyond the Box"



Don't miss an episode of “Beyond the Box” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








