The Wave Finally Came. So Why Didn’t Trump See It?
A week ago Phil and I recorded an hour long conversation that I was genuinely proud of, and then Google Meet quietly swallowed it whole, despite my premium subscription and a record button I definitely pressed. Google support eventually told me the recording had probably been “abandoned at the server level,” which is a phrase I now plan to use for every project I never finish. So we did what any self respecting nerds would do and recorded the whole thing again, this time with a backup running on my phone, while Phil joked that this was our version of purgatory and that in ten years we might finally get one clean take.The second take turned out sharper than the first, partly because we had another week to digest the results and partly because, as you’ll see, Phil and I don’t agree on everything. If you’re new here, Philip Keisler is one of my favorite people to talk politics with, because he pairs a policy wonk’s command of the details with a stubborn optimism about what our politics could become. (He also just passed the bar, so the next time he tells you something violates international law, he’ll be doing it with credentials.)Here’s what we covered.1. This was a repudiation, not a flukePhil opened with a caution I appreciated, which is that after every election everyone rushes to declare that one kind of candidate is the perfect template forever, and that overreading any single cycle is how parties get themselves into trouble. Having said that, he didn’t hedge on the big picture.“I think it was the first time there was a true repudiation of Trump’s chaotic and corrupt style of government.”What struck him most was the type of Democrat who won in hard places. James Talarico in Texas, Adam Hamilton in Kansas, Rob Sand in Iowa and Scott Colom in Mississippi all ran campaigns that refused the mud fight and instead asked how Americans could see each other as fellow citizens rather than enemies. If that’s the direction our politics is heading for the next couple of years, Phil thinks it’s a genuinely positive change, and after years of waiting for an anti Trump wave that kept not quite arriving, he described the result as simply a relief.My own read is that Chuck Schumer summarized the mood about as well as anyone with his three Cs of corruption, chaos and costs, because people are still angry about gas prices and grocery bills, and none of those three things is fun to live through.2. Trump can’t make the leapI’ve watched several of Trump’s post election interviews, and he has been adamant that the results had nothing to do with him, since his name wasn’t on the ballot and his rallies were, of course, the biggest rallies ever. I asked Phil whether Trump knows deep down that this was about him.Phil’s answer was more psychologically interesting than I expected. He noticed that the “stolen election” chatter this time has been strangely low energy, which suggests Trump probably accepts that Republicans really lost, yet he still can’t get from there to the next step.“I think he can’t psychologically get at the idea that he is actually unpopular, that people actually came out to vote against him.”So instead the blame flows outward, to other Republicans, to Susie Wiles, and to anyone who didn’t defend him loudly enough, when in Phil’s view Trump created this outcome himself through the Iran war, tariffs and his immigration policy. It was within his control to have, if not great midterms, at least not a disaster.Would Democrats still have taken the Senate with Trump on the ballot? Phil thinks yes, given the crossover support and the youth, Hispanic and Black turnout, although reach states like Mississippi and South Carolina would have been much harder. The real test, he argues, comes in 2028 and 2032, when Democrats will have to hold places like Iowa, Kansas and Texas with a Republican presidential nominee driving turnout on the other side.3. Who actually won the fight inside the Democratic Party?With roughly 260 House seats, Phil pointed out, a five or ten member caucus on the left simply can’t hold the agenda hostage the way it could in a 51 or 52 seat Senate or a two seat House majority, which means moderate, center left Democrats will effectively be running the show for the next two years.The narrative fight is messier. Progressives like Abdul El-Sayed, Troy Jackson and Peggy Flanagan won their races, which spares the left the devastating story that its candidates can’t win even in a wave, yet they won by smaller margins than moderates who carried far redder states by double digits. As Phil put it, the result gives everyone something to talk about.“In a great environment anyone can win, but if we want to choose the best candidates, it will probably be moderate candidates who are making strategic choices about meeting their voters where they are.”I couldn’t resist pointing out how strange it is that we now describe winning a swing state by seven points as an underperformance. We also spent a minute agreeing that nobody, including John Fetterman’s own colleagues, quite knows what John Fetterman is anymore.4. Where we disagree: should Talarico stay put?This was my favorite stretch of the conversation, because Phil and I came at it from opposite directions.Phil’s view is that Democrats finally flipped a Texas Senate seat, and that Talarico jumping into a presidential race right away would burn the goodwill Texas Democrats just earned, even if the governor appointed a replacement.“It would be like if you hired someone for your company and then a week in they’re like, ‘I’m going to go to a better company and leverage my title.’”I see it differently. If you voted for Talarico because you liked who he is and how he thinks, then him wanting to serve the whole country shouldn’t make him less appealing, since Texans are Americans too. It’s like someone at your local subsidiary getting promoted to headquarters, where your reaction is pride that he’s our guy rather than resentment that he left. Phil, to his credit, granted the point while holding his ground on the broken promise problem, and I suspect many of you will land somewhere between us.We also talked about Jon Ossoff, whom we both think would be a terrific candidate. Phil has become more convinced that Ossoff genuinely doesn’t want to run, citing reporting that he even wavered on seeking reelection and the fact that he hasn’t done a victory lap on cable news after a huge win, and that he means it when he talks about wanting to be present for his young kids. I pushed back that Vance and plenty of others with young children run anyway, and honestly his reluctance makes me like him more, in the way that the person who doesn’t want the job is so often the one who should have it.5. The Kamala problem, Republican editionPhil made a comparison I hadn’t heard before. Kamala Harris was handed the border as her portfolio, the border became a political disaster, and then she ran for president carrying that albatross. JD Vance, he notes, has been handed Iran diplomacy and the administration’s anti corruption effort.“I cannot think of worse jobs under this administration than being the guy who’s supposed to root out corruption and the guy who ends the Iran war.”And just as Biden made it nearly impossible for Harris to create daylight between them, Phil expects Trump to make it even harder for Vance, because one critical post on Truth Social could end his campaign before it starts.So who in the administration is best positioned? Phil’s answer is Marco Rubio. Drawing on Sarah Longwell’s focus groups at The Bulwark, he observed that even Republican voters seem to get “the ick” from Vance while consistently praising Rubio as the one competent adult in the building, helped by the running meme that whenever someone resigns, Rubio picks up another job. Phil was quick to add that he considers Rubio’s record awful in important ways, pointing to the detention of Rümeysa Öztürk over an op ed she wrote, but he acknowledged that an aura… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit nerdsforhumanity.substack.com