0:00
48:35
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

This week the hosts are reviewing Nuremberg, the 2025 historical drama directed by James Vanderbilt and starring Russell Crowe as Hermann Göring and Rami Malek as Captain Douglas Kelly, the US Army psychiatrist assigned to evaluate the Nazi defendants ahead of trial. Based on a true story and the non-fiction book The Nazi and the Psychiatrist, the film follows the first time in history that leaders of a defeated nation were held personally accountable for crimes against humanity.   The podcast is out now on YouTube and also available on Spotify and Apple Podcasts. This is one of the more important episodes the show has done. Please share it. Hit subscribe or follow — it genuinely helps us keep going.   Before the film, the Scotsman opens with a question from the train — why does the same sentence sound beautiful in one language and faintly terrifying in another? He delivers a butterfly-through-flowers sentence in Italian, French, Russian, Irish, posh English, Trump and finally German. The Trump version is widely considered the best. The German version ends with the butterfly marching to its death.   The Scotsman was not a Russell Crowe fan going in — admits he was looking for reasons to dismiss the performance — and found he could not. Crowe is absolutely the film. Every scene commands full attention. The Aussie notes they had just reviewed American Gangster with a much younger Crowe, and the contrast makes this performance even more striking. Both agree Rami Malek was badly cast — the Aussie says he kept expecting him to start singing, the Scotsman says he plays the same character in every role — with one exception late in the film when the character finally breaks.   The film's central argument gets a serious airing. Göring's defense is that he was following orders — he never deviates, never apologises, and treats the trial as a stage. The Scotsman makes the A Few Good Men comparison: the prosecutor eventually stops trying to break the defense and simply asks, would you do it all again? Göring says yes. The Aussie initially thinks this is too convenient. The Scotsman points out it is a hundred percent fact. The Aussie concedes.   A serious conversation follows about the legal principle established — that following orders is not a defense — and both hosts connect it to the Essendon drugs saga and modern corporate law. The Scotsman raises the distinction between concentration camps and extermination camps, which bothered him throughout the film.   The Scotsman then plays something genuinely unexpected — original 1941 radio footage of the Scottish farmer who captured Rudolf Hess with a pitchfork when Hess crash-landed near Eaglesham. Five minutes from the Scotsman's house. His father pointed out the exact field every time they drove past it. The farmer's wife offered Hess a cup of tea. He declined and asked for water.   Rohan Reminisces goes somewhere different. The Aussie covers the purpose of the trials, the full scale of World War II deaths by nation, and the numbers that stay with you — 16.6 million Jewish people in 1939, 11 million by 1945, 15.8 million today. Eighty years on, the Jewish world population has still not returned to where it was before the war. The Scotsman says it was excellent. He means it.   The trivia covers the $7-8 million budget and $70 million worldwide, how Göring obtained the cyanide capsule — one of the great unsolved mysteries of the trials — and the real Douglas Kelly's fate. On New Year's Day 1958, Kelly swallowed a cyanide capsule of the same type confiscated from Göring, in front of his wife and children. He was 45. Most of the courtroom dialogue was taken verbatim from the trial record. And finally, as the film was released in 2025, the International Criminal Court had outstanding arrest warrants for sitting heads of government. None had been arrested. Göring would probably have considered that a vindication.   Aussie: 4.1. Scotsman: 3.8. A watch-once film that both hosts think matters.

More episodes from "Aussie and the Scotsman - Unfiltered Movie Podcast"