Associations NOW Presents podcast

Search Is Changing: Staying Visible in a Changing Digital World

0:00
37:11
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

In this episode of Associations NOW Presents, host Sharon Pare welcomes Josh Koenig, co-founder of Pantheon, for a conversation about how artificial intelligence is changing the way people discover information online and what that means for associations. Koenig explains the shift from traditional search engines to AI-powered tools that deliver direct answers, and why associations need to rethink how they make their content discoverable. He discusses the continued importance of website performance, search engine optimization, and authoritative content in an increasingly AI-driven environment. The conversation also explores the challenges of understanding how AI tools select and recommend sources, strategies for managing multiple websites, and how emerging technologies can simplify website operations. Koenig shares practical insights to help associations strengthen their digital presence, reach new audiences, and remain trusted sources of information as online search continues to evolve.

Check out the video podcast here:

https://youtu.be/0wfYJORFJQA

This episode is sponsored by Pantheon.

Associations NOW Presents is produced by Association Briefings.

 

Transcript

Sharon Pare: [00:00:00] Welcome to this episode of Associations NOW Presents, an original podcast series from the American Society of Association Executives. I'm Sharon Pare, partnerships director at High Road Solutions, a HubSpot agency, and your host of this series throughout the year. This episode today is sponsored by Pantheon.

Today, I am joined by Josh Koenig, co-founder of Pantheon. Josh, welcome to the show. 

Josh Koenig: Thank you, Sharon. I'm excited to be here. 

Sharon Pare: We're excited to have you, and I know you've been building for the web for more than two decades now, and I know lately you've been focused on a question that I think every association is asking.

And we're not gonna dig into it yet, but when people ask an AI tool instead of typing it into a search bar, how do you make sure expertise is exactly what they find, right? And I know we're gonna dig into that today, and it's really interesting 'cause I wanna just add my little own anecdote in there. But just a few months ago, earlier this year, I [00:01:00] actually switched from Google over to DuckDuckGo because I wanted to run my searches on my own versus running whatever was coming up in the Google searches.

So now I'm really interested to find out a little bit more about that today. So Josh, it's gonna be all about you today. It's gonna be all about Pantheon today. So first, for listeners meeting you and Pantheon for the, for the first time, can you tell us a little bit about yourself and what Pantheon does?

Josh Koenig: Yeah, absolutely. We can use that to set some context. That's the buzzword of the year, context. So hi, my name's Josh. It's a pleasure to be with you. I founded this company, Pantheon, about 10 years into my career of building the internet, and we built Pantheon basically because there's a whole lot of work that goes into supporting, maintaining, and running websites that matter for organizations that have important missions, that often it's, it's repetitive.

The websites themselves are very different. People are being creative and so on and so forth, but the operations [00:02:00] underneath them, there's a good way to do it that's pretty much the same across the board. And my prior career had been doing consulting work, setting that up for clients one at a time, which is slow.

It costs a lot of money 'cause you're paying for my hours and my team's hours, and we realized that, hey, what we're doing here is pretty repeatable, and when people get it wrong, it has pretty serious consequences. And so we decided to turn that expertise into a service. We launched Pantheon 16 years ago, and now we support over 10,000 professional web teams running hundreds of thousands of individual websites that collectively reach over a billion unique monthly visitors every month, and growing.

And we're excited to be a part of this next chapter of the web in the AI era. There's a lot going on. We've got a lot of opinions. We've got product releases that are coming out, and I think it's a really important time for mission-driven organizations that need to satisfy the needs of their constituencies to figure out how to use the web to its fullest.

This is [00:03:00] a very important medium for, for communications and organizing and all sorts of other pursuits, and I think in the AI era, frankly, like, more important than ever. So really happy to have this opportunity to dig into all of that. 

Sharon Pare: Stay on you for just a little bit more, 'cause I know it's a big part of Pantheon's story, but you've worn a lot of hats at Pantheon over the last 16 years or so.

Chief trategy officer, head of product, now marketing. Now, what is it like going from building the product to telling its story? 

Josh Koenig: Oof. That's a great question. There's a saying in nerd Twitter back when that was still a thing, which was that you either die an engineer or you live long enough to become a business guy.

And so that's the arc that I went on. And it's really interesting because we work- we've always been guided by the needs of practitioners in our space. That was our-- my co-founders and I, we all came from that ourselves, being hands-on practitioners. Our users are mostly hands-on practitioners. And so when it comes to thinking about storytelling and marketing, there's a way of doing that if it's not authentic, if it's not [00:04:00] grounded in the real problems and the real challenges that people face, it's not helping.

I think of marketing not as a-- marketing is, at its best, is trying to educate and entertain people, and hopefully doing a little bit of both at the same time. And so I think for me, the opportunity to take the credibility that I have as a former practitioner and kind of knowing what it's like to be in the trenches, and then bringing that to the challenge of how do we tell a story that helps people make sense of the world and recognize when they need to think about something like our platform as part of what they need to succeed in the future?

It's really interesting because there's a lot of ways to be creative, and I think that being creative with technology is what actually fires a lot of our customers' and our users' passion. And being able to connect all those dots together is a lot of fun, to be honest. I'm, I feel extremely lucky to have been able to have the journey that I've had with the company over the past decade and a half.

Sharon Pare: You've [00:05:00] definitely seen a lot, right? 

Josh Koenig: Yeah. 

Sharon Pare: So, you know, speaking of the future, you talk a lot about the future of the open web. So what does that phrase mean to you and why should an association care? 

Josh Koenig: Okay, that's a good one. So, the open web is really the web that can be accessed by anyone.

There's a lot of... The web is just this, an incredible medium. You can play games on the web, you can... The web can deliver all kinds of software. And so it's really grown over the past 30 years, and it's really... I, again, and I'm just excited about the innovation that continues to happen. And when we talk about the open web, we talk about the web that anyone can reach, like people can send someone a link, or there can be something that you wanna click on somewhere that takes you to another place.

And for associations, this is where you can meet the public- Oh ... effectively, right? This is the place where you get to really, I think, not just meet the public, but maybe invite them into your space. Because in, in digital communications and marketing, you're gonna be, [00:06:00] you're gonna be doing things on social media, you're gonna be going to conferences, you'll have email, you'll have all these other places where you're going out to what is effectively someone else's space in order to engage the public.

But if you wanna bring them to your space, it's gonna be f- most of the time through the open web in some way, shape, or form. And then maybe people go along a journey, and they develop a deeper relationship. They become a member, they become a customer, they become a fan, a follower, a constituent, whatever it is.

And then that's still, the web has a pretty important role to play there as well, 'cause all of these interactions, again, any call to action these days, it's a click, and a click goes to some place on the web. And so being able to leverage that medium to its fullest to make it something that's really engaging, something that is interactive, something that connects with the value you deliver or the, the mission of your organization or the reason that w- someone would wanna spend time with you, is really important.

And it's also an evolving medium, so you have to not be locked into what [00:07:00] your website looked like last year or even last month in some cases. And unfortunately, the status quo in our industry, and I've been in it for 30 years, is still very much one of people being stuck with relatively static things.

You know, your use of the web is this, you design something, you built it, you launched it, and now you're kind of stuck with it. And part of what Pantheon is solving for our customers is eliminating all the operational complexity of getting that work done in the first place, but also making sure that that work can be ongoing so you're never stuck with it.

You can always evolve, you can always move forward, and you don't have to be on this kind of unhealthy boom-bust cycle of doing big web projects and then going into maintenance mode for a few years until you can find the budget to do it again. That's just not the recipe for success in today's internet.

Sharon Pare: There's something interesting that you said that's sticking with me now, and around the open web and getting those constituents and having almost like a community lens. And with [00:08:00] associations as, and as you're finding out as you work more and more with them, they're all about community. So one of my questions I have for you now is why is Pantheon paying attention to associations right now?

Is there something that drew you to this space? 

Josh Koenig: Yeah. I think we are thinking about elevating what we do. I'll work my way around to associations specifically, but we've been thinking a lot in the past year and a half of we do all this work that is under the covers because operations work is often out of sight, out of mind, and you don't really wanna have to think about it 'cause if you are thinking about it, it means there's a problem, right?

If there's a big security fire drill and everyone has to stop what they're doing 'cause we have to patch the system and it disrupts everything, it's y- yeah, you gotta get that done. That's really important, but it's not fun when that happens. That's not really what you want to be going on. And so we've been thinking as a company about how do we meet people. Where we can talk about their goals?

Mm-hmm. We can talk about what they're trying to achieve. And it turns out that with the web, f- folks have different goals in mind, and a lot of that actually rolls back to what their [00:09:00] use case is, what vertical they're in. And we started to think about this association space as a place where when we looked at our historical customer base, wow, we've got a lot of great customers.

And that's because we had some great partnerships, and we have some great digital agencies that focus in that area. And, and we said maybe w- like when we had actually started talking to those people and said, "Hey, should we start showing up ourselves in these places?" And they were like, "Yeah, you absolutely should 'cause there's a lot of people that need your help."

And so we were following in the footsteps of our, of our partners in deciding to focus on associations with specific intent. But it all comes back from this notion of we can do a lot more for people when we start with the why. Like, why do you even have a website? What is the purpose of that? How does it help you achieve your goals or your mission?

And then depending from there, it's, there, different or- associations are gonna have different answers to that question. But broadly speaking, associations have a t- a type of, a kind of a shape to many of their goals that are not super dissimilar from one another. Versus if you wanted to go into media or e-commerce, [00:10:00] like they similarly have a, have very different shaped goals in those other verticals, and so that's why we're here today.

Sharon Pare: Let's talk about those different answers, right? Something I wanna get into is AI ready. 

Josh Koenig: Mm-hmm. 

Sharon Pare: On every conference agenda, like you've seen, every session is AI ready. But a- again, like you said, there's a different answer for it. Not everyone means the same thing by what they're saying. So what do you say it means for an association website to be AI ready, and what has changed about how people discover information?

Josh Koenig: So I'd love to actually go back to your, I'd love to hear f- your experience and the idea of going saying, "No, I don't. I want search the way I want it, and I want DuckDuckGo." Right? 'Cause that, I've heard that a few other ca- in a few other cases before, but usually people were thinking privacy and, but the i- the idea of, "No, I want the search," like that's, that's great.

And 

Sharon Pare: I think- I wanna go to page 23 on DuckDuckGo. Yeah. Yeah, totally. You know? And I'm used to searching because I wanna go through everything and curate search. 

Josh Koenig: You wanna see what’s out there?

Sharon Pare: That's it. That's it. Exactly.

Josh Koenig: Yeah. Yeah. So I think that what we're seeing is, you know- At [00:11:00] a high level, the way to articulate it in the industry is Google for 20 years or so had a monopoly on this stuff.

Mm. And they ran... They did, they earned that by having a really amazing product, and Google Search was great, but it wouldn't be-- You weren't the first person to observe that over, over the years, it has maybe declined in quality. And then they, they've, they have had to respond to these changes in the overall market by leaning in more to this, the AI overview and the generated response.

Because I think a lot of people, you know, there's a lot of people-- If you think of their searches by volume, a lot of them are simple answers to simple questions. And so you can see a world where people are satisfied by that. But in a lot of other cases where people are doing deeper research, they're- they wanna offload that to a little buddy in the computer that they can talk back and forth to, that'll curate a bunch of links, and then you'll go s- double-check it later.

The behavior of people in terms of how they search and discover for infor- new information is just changing. It's not like [00:12:00] it's gone black and white overnight, but it's clearly shifting from searching, which is relatively labor-intensive for the searcher, to asking, which gets you an answer. And if those answers become higher and higher quality and more and more reliable, and they have the necessary ability for you to double-click and see why you think that or why did that...

What sources are we citing with this response? It seems to be what more and more people out there looking for s- for new information prefer. And that doesn't throw out everything that we've historically known about what it takes to run a good website, but it does change, again, where the website comes up, what job it's doing in the journey for those people who are searching or asking to discover new information.

And that is the really important shift that I think has occurred. 

Sharon Pare: So I think that's where I wanna double-click a little bit more on is if a member asks an AI tool for some question in the association's expertise, I guess what is it that [00:13:00] decides whether that content shows up? 

Josh Koenig: We don't know for sure, right?

That's, there's a bit of a black box effect here, as there always was with Google. Like Google was famously not... They, the s- people inside Google definitely knew. In this case, what's fascinating about this is the people inside the labs don't know because the systems are trained, their internal neural networks are not designed by a software architect.

And so there's actually not a de- deterministic view on why the system came up with a recommendation for X, Y, or Z. And you can infer it based on the behavior, but you're reasoning about like what's going on with, with these models from the outside in. And we've done a bunch of primary research on this, so this is how we can develop opinions on it.

But it's worth acknowledging that this is kind of unknown territory for technology because it's, on, on a certain level, people don't know for sure what's going on inside the system. And the system will give you different answers to exactly the same question. And because it's, it is a, it is not a deterministic system.

It's a [00:14:00] statistical or probabilistic system that's coming up with something that will... It shouldn't be wildly different over if you ask it the same thing 10 times, but it will be subtly different, and in some cases, maybe not so subtly different. So that's a, in terms of how you're thinking about leveraging the technology, that's important to know.

But what it is that we can say that is driving this, there's a few different things. One is that all of these models are trained on websites as data. They scrape the entire internet 'cause they just need this massive amount of text to go into training the models. And so this doesn't happen every day, but at some point, probably more than once a year, the frontier labs are going around and running a giant crawl of the internet so they can continue to freshen and maybe try to train a new model with a new technique.

And so your website is in the mix. But increasingly, what's happening with most chat experiences and the, and certainly the Google AI overview, is that's just one ingredient into [00:15:00] generating the AI response. There's also a real time active search component, and you can... they showcase in the UI when this is happening.

Usually they'll show you, like, little, little icons and stuff of sites that are being scanned as part of this. And the reason for that is, especially if you're asking for anything that has any currency, like, they can't trust the data that was in the, the, the training run, 'cause that could be way out of date.

And also they're looking to what's... it's called retrieval augmentation, a RAG, and it's where you get kind of a general response from the model and then you wanna feed it a bunch more inputs to be like, "Hey, consider all these sources and give us a fuller response, and then cite some of the sources," and so on and so forth.

That's how you get, like, a much more, a thorough response to a question versus, like, if it's a simple yes or no, you're asking for a fact, it doesn't need to do that. So when it's doing that additional searching, what's happening is the AI model is running its own little internal web search, and then it's looking at the results of the pages and in real [00:16:00] time trying to figure out what the best response is to give the user.

And so both in the terms of how you make your website ideal from as a part of the, the underlying training base, and then what it takes to be s- like, considered and cited in those subsequent searches, those are the two areas where you really need to focus. And it all comes down to some of the things that we've known about SEO forever in terms 

Sharon Pare: of structure.

I was just, I was like, he's getting right there. Yeah. Because we've... I think things have changed so much, and so one of my questions is like, did we just waste the last 10 years on SEO? So I kinda wanna dig into that, if that's okay. Yeah. 

Josh Koenig: Yeah, yeah. 

Sharon Pare: Absolutely. I, not to cut you off, but I think you were heading right over there.

I was, I 

Josh Koenig: was. 

Sharon Pare: Does AI search make SEO obsolete, or does it make the fundamentals more important? 

Josh Koenig: Yeah, it makes some of the fundamentals really important, and then I also think it changes the way we need to even think about the idea of website optimization for non-human consumers. [00:17:00] So, so the, there are fundamentals that are true, that were true before, they're true now, which are the cleaner and faster your website is, the better it will do.

Like, the reality is that a part of what, like, speed is important, and more important now than it was before, because Google used to give you, like, a little, like, brownie point for having a faster website, and that was mostly because they wanted to incentivize people having a better experience using Google and clicking through to things, and having the things that they clicked through to load, like, non- in a non-frustrating amount of time, and it was th- their way of putting a carrot out there to get everybody else to try to make faster websites.

That's honestly true. I've talked with the people at Google that made that decision when they introduced that to the as a waiting signal. In the case of the AI tools, the speed is actually a part of an input into the s- into how the system works because they need to go request up-to-date results from some webpages, and then it's gonna [00:18:00] take time to process it, and they basically run a race in the background 'cause they can't take 50 sources.

They can probably only take five or 10. And in the background when it's doing those requests, it's not waiting for everybody to come back and, like, sorting it out. It's getting, again, the first five or 10 and then just going forward. And so there's, like, actually no limit to how much the speed of your website can improve its citability, whereas before there was a threshold of once it's gonna not frustrate someone, it loads in a couple seconds, Google's, you got your brownie point, you can move on.

Whereas if you're in a situation where there's multiple potential sources that could be considered, you wanna be first or at least second in that race consistently, and that could mean being, like, faster to a degree that a person would never appreciate. It's tenths of a second could really matter there.

And then cleaner sites are just easier to understand. They're easier to understand for machines. They're e- easier to understand for humans. Like, those core elements of having a high-quality experience, those were... SEO would push you to do that. In [00:19:00] the agentic era, it's, they're even more important because they will, their weight is even higher than it was before.

There are some other things from the SEO era that kind of matter less, right? Like, it doesn't help you to add a lot of extremely broad content to your site as, like, a strategy. Like, SEO used to involve, like, creating content really, like, for the purposes of SEO, and was always a little bit of, like, um, a, a, a fine line to walk that you don't wanna just do it for the sake of doing it.

You wanna have something to say, but also you need to cover a lot of ground to be able to have these, to hit all your keywords. With AI, like, that is l- like, content strategy shifts to having deeper, longer, more authoritative content on the things that you actually... the core things that you care about, the questions you want to answer.

You need to really go deep on those. And the kind of SEO used to push for some amount of, like, breadth as a [00:20:00] strategy, which works a lot less, or it appears to matter a lot less in, in the world of, of AI. The other thing is SEO. We used to really focus... It would- The mindset of SEO would stop with, did we get onto the page one of the results, right?

Or could we move up? And, and your SEO practice would not particularly consider, would not concern itself with the conversion rate of people who clicked through to those pages. But if you think about what is happening in the era of AI, the external tool, it used to be just a search engine, now it's the chat experience or whatever, is not just selecting the sources to look at, it's also figuring out what the pitch is or what is presented to the user, and how persuasive is that response, is gonna be th- what, it, there's a conversion that's gonna happen right there.

It's not on your site anymore, it's in the answer. And so the really good AI optimization is [00:21:00] actually starting to blend together the practices of SEO and then conversion rate optimization, because you n- you need to not only get in the game, you have to be cited or referred to, you need to be referred to in a way that is positive, that gets your message across, that works to get people to want to take a next step.

Which means bringing these two disciplines, which had been s- siloed from one another, together to do a really good job in terms of optimizing for, for agents. And that's, I think that's fascinating. And, and I think, I also think it's a good thing overall because a lot of the stuff, it's still, it's just pushing people towards creating higher quality websites in the first place.

Right. Thatwhen people do arrive there, when they're ready to engage, they're ready to come to your space on the internet, that they're, that they might do that, they might be a little further along on their journey when they get there. They're gonna have a better experience, and you want that anyway.

Ad Read: And now for a word from our episode sponsor. Your association's website is more than a digital brochure. It is how [00:22:00] members find resources, connect with your organization, and experience your mission every day. But managing important websites often means juggling disconnected tools, complex workflows, and limited technical resources.

Pantheon brings the pieces together, giving teams a secure, governed platform to create, run, and evolve high-performing websites with confidence. Whether you use WordPress, Drupal, Next.js, or another framework, Pantheon helps you move faster while staying in control. Discover how Pantheon can help your association build a stronger digital future. I know you started talking about this a little bit.

Sharon Pare: I think it's good to go into some of the practical starting points for the associations. So where do you think the association teams, especially if they're small and they want their expertise and resources easier to find, uh, understand, and trust, like where should they begin really? 

Josh Koenig: I think it starts with understanding what, again, with this [00:23:00] notion of reframing the, the paradigm from search to ask It starts with understanding what are the questions that bring people to you, or what are the questions that you should be an authoritative, if not the most authoritative, voice to answer.

And really changing, not necessarily throwing out everything you did before, but thinking about that as a top priority in your strategy. And then I also think there's an element of, like, assessing what the current state of the situation is, and there's a bunch of tools that are out there that are continually improving.

I don't think anybody's really cracked the code on this yet, but you could spend a little time researching what is actually going on, right? What are the responses in these various answer engines to the  the questions that I think are important. And just see, are you in there? Is it good? Do you like it?

You gotta kinda measure your performance the same way that you would tr- historically measure performance in SEO by keeping track of your rankings. 'Cause then that's key to knowing whether, what kind of progress you're making or not. [00:24:00] 

Sharon Pare: And then the o- How do they know where they're showing... Like, how would they know if they're even showing up in AI answers?

You just mentioned measuring it. Is there a way to do that now? 

Josh Koenig: Yeah. What it really comes down to is you can do it yourself by going to the tool and typing in the question and seeing what the response is. And there are, that, that is something that is being turned into a service by some traditional search engine monitoring vendors and some new ones that have popped up.

Again, I would say I don't have one that I can recommend, "Hey, you should, everybody should use this 'cause they've really cracked the code," 'cause it's so new. But it's worth looking around at AEO tracking and, and I also think it's, it's not that hard to d- to actually go and do it yourself and check it out a little bit 'cause it's worthwhile just, it can be illuminating just to see how you're showing up in these spaces.

And that's a, a part of the job now is keeping an eye on that. And then the other thing beyond just thinking what are the questions, how am I showing up, you also have to potentially make space to think about what is the journey you want someone to be on, or what is the journey someone is on, wh- whether you like it or not, and [00:25:00] how do you become a part of that journey?

What is the authentic way for you to engage? Because what we're seeing in the AI era is everyone's, like, the top line, but also borderline vanity metrics around clicks and traffic and so forth. But everybody that I know who, not everybody that I know, but many of them that I know who are, they really have a good handle on their analytics, they're like, "Yeah, that's alarming and nobody likes to see it, but actually the number of people that do meaningful things with us through our website has not changed.

It's just that we're getting a lot less people that are just coming in and bouncing. We're getting people that are coming in smaller numbers, but they have much higher intent. They are already, they've already done some research. They're coming to us because they're actually l-" ready to engage. And so it is in the sense of your website is fitting into a broader organizational strategy for how you engage with your constituents, thinking about how that's go- changing or going to change as people are adopting AI as part of their, [00:26:00] whether it's information discovery just in general or part of a workflow that you plug into somewhere along the line.

Those are really interesting questions to start to think about strategically, and that can inform your projects and your plans for the year to come. 

Sharon Pare: I wanna shift gears a little bit, and I know a lot of associations, maybe they have a main site, conference site, foundation site, chapter site, maybe- Yeah

journal, certification portal. What happens to all of that when you're managing a whole collection of sites, often with different teams and volunteers touching them? What usually happens to that? 

Josh Koenig: I think in the, as it comes to AI, this is an interesting anecdote. I just, this just happened to me as I was talking with a, a, a sporting association in the UK.

They're not a customer, I can't reference them. But it was a really interesting discovery call exactly yet, because what we found, 'cause we've been doing these little audits with people to help get the ball rolling, and again, because we don't have a go-to partner or vendor to say, "Just use," they've got it on lockdown.

We've been helping just with people to get the ball started like how are you showing up? What's [00:27:00] going on? We can run a quick assessment for you. And they had a, a main site, and then there, there was an, a sort of a sister organization that helped with fan clubs and stuff, and that organization was getting cited way more than the, the, the actual authoritative one.

And it just happened to be because they had some aspects of their website was a little faster. They had, were posting content more frequently 'cause they had some user-generated con- There was this... We have a pretty good theory about why that was happening, but it was really surprising to them that, "Oh, we just assumed because we're the, the, the one .co.uk, that we would be the place where all the answers would come from."

And can sometimes not be the case. And you need to look across this, take a portfolio view of everywhere you're showing up, and then think about managing that set of sites coherently and collectively. In a case where you would actually have... It's not all one organization, that's probably more challenging.

Although they did say, "We know those people pretty well. We could call them up and maybe get something, work together on this problem a little bit." But that is one of the challenges that I think a lot of [00:28:00] folks struggle with, is they don't just actually have a website. They have a small fleet of websites, and how do you manage that effectively, coherently?

How do you keep an eye on everything that needs to k- keep an eye on? That, that again, that's a place where we're seeing people bringing AI in to just help them with the work, right? We can... There's a lot of things AI can do to help you m- keep track of your websites, keep them up to date, make sure that they're on brand, make sure that they're accessible.

All those sorts of things that, you know, a lot of work that we used to do by hand in terms of auditing and reporting for people. It was pretty repetitive work, and a lot of that can be automated. Now, you can't fix everything through automation, at least not yet. But you can keep track of things much more effectively.

But I think for a lot of places where that fleet has developed, like, organically, sometimes it's just not very well organized. People don't actually have a, "Do we have a list of all of our websites?" We might not. We might not even know what they all are or who's in charge of managing them. So that can be a, an important thing if you're thinking about organizing yourself to make the most of the AI era, is just to get your, get your [00:29:00] portfolio organized 

Sharon Pare: Did you actually have an association client who rebranded or some policy changed, and did they try to update everything across those 20 or 30 sites on their own?

Did that actually happen to you guys at Pantheon with any of your association clients? 

Josh Koenig: Yeah, that's actually something we help people with a lot. Okay. 'Cause one of the things that... This is one of the reasons why we wanna lean into the space, as we were talking about before. The vertical feels like a good fit because- Yeah

we help people, like we, our platform has always, from the beginning, been about helping people with the many sites scenario. We've never been about one, just one project at a time. And so we have a really strong track record with chapter-based organizations, kind of associational networks, and then like other things like higher education, where they have tons of websites, or brand companies where they've got, they have one brand, but they have 50 markets and different things that they're doing.

And so Pantheon actually really helps people a lot with cascading out changes across a larger fleet of [00:30:00] sites. That's something we're really leaning into, helping people do more with helping people do more with leveraging AI in their workflow themselves. 

Sharon Pare: Can we talk a little bit about, you started talking about chatbots, but how about those AI bots that are crawling websites?

Do you think associations should welcome them, block them, something in between? I think- What's your professional recommendation there? 

Josh Koenig: Yeah. I think there's sort of two different things that are happening. One is you have the just increased crawling of sites by, by entities that are, that mean well in doing so, right?

So like even just Google, because they're a part of this story too, the rate at which the Google crawler is going over sites has gone up by 5 or 6X in the past year, and it's 'cause they're thirsty. They want more up-to-date data. And you have all the frontier labs that are doing their things with both building datasets for training and then also augmenting things in real time.

I think you have to welcome all of that, because otherwise you're just not gonna be discovered. You're not gonna be found. Now, at the same time, there's an awful lot of inorganic or inauthentic traffic [00:31:00] that's out there, 'cause it's easier than ever with AI to fake stuff. And that includes like faking traffic.

People are scraping websites for their own purposes and not to build better models that people are gonna use. They're just abusing the open web, if you will. And I think it's really important for organizations to keep a handle on that just so that they don't see their content stolen or they don't have issues like cost or stability as a result of crawlers going crazy on their site.

That actually does happen from time to time, and it can be really annoying to deal with. That's like another thing that we try to take away from people's list of concerns, but it's an ongoing cat and mouse game out there, to be honest. 

Sharon Pare: Can we talk a little bit about the-- there's two new offerings that I know Pantheon has been working on to kinda help solve some of the problems that we've been talking about and some of the challenges that the associations have been facing, AFM and P1.

Can you tell us a little bit more about how do they connect to the challenge of managing and improving websites [00:32:00] in the AI era? 

Josh Koenig: Yeah. So that's a-- those are our two biggest launches of the year, and one I have been talking about a little bit already with this idea of a fleet of websites.

That's the word that we're using now 'cause it's kinda helps people think about things about how we gotta get it organized. The fleet has lots of things of different sizes in them, but they all need to go in the same direction. So agentic fleet management is actually just a-- it's actually a, a whole suite of tools that we're building on top of our core platform to help organizations that have, even if it's a small fleet of four or five, keep them in formation, keep them up to date.

And then some customers who have kind of the daunting challenge of a fleet that could include hundreds or even thousands of sites, like that without a fair bit of automation can become very unwieldy. So agentic fleet management has everything in it from just the core looking after security and core site quality accessibility up through now it's getting pretty exciting.

Like we can do bug fixing with agents and let them suggest, "Hey, it looks like this last update might have made your [00:33:00] homepage look a little wonky, but we fixed it over here in our agentic sandbox. Does it look good to you? If so, you can apply this change." That's really cool. Again, we're all about eliminating the drudge work and the toil from, from running the web, and so I think we can offload...

And when we first launched, one of our slogans was like, "Let's make the machines do more of the work." Uh- 

Sharon Pare: Exactly, right? That's the whole point. 

Josh Koenig: Yeah, that's the whole point. And then P1 is, I'm really excited about because it's actually a tool for literally building sites. We've been a platform for the past 16 years, and we help people be really productive and sleep well at night.

But what they're doing and how they're doing it without literally building their websites, we stay out of. It's like, it's your business, not ours. But P1 is a way to build a website in the AI era that lets you use AI to create pages rapidly without introducing the risk of them going off brand or introducing security issues.

All the kind of the, the promise of vibe coding is quite strong, but the reality is actually [00:34:00] much more fraud. And so we've developed an approach to this that lets people and agents work together on websites safely and quickly, which is taking an approach that I don't see, as nobody else in the market has taken yet, which is really exciting.

And it demos really well 'cause it's very beautiful and it's really fast, and you can put things together quickly, and it's in beta right now. We have a sort of a small group of customers using it, but we're gonna take that out early next year once it's ready for open season, and I'm really excited to work with people on that.

Sharon Pare: That's awesome. Congratulations on those two new launches as they're in beta and launch into 2027. Yeah. Well, before we wrap, I do want to get into a quick lightning round- Okay ... just before we close everything out. Just some advice, some practical advice our listeners can take back to their desks, especially as they're listening to this.

So my first one for you is, what is one thing an association could do on Monday morning, Tuesday morning, whatever morning it is that they're listening to this, to be easier for AI to find and trust? 

Josh Koenig: You could make your website faster. Oh, sure. It could always [00:35:00] be faster. All right. And that will always help.

Sharon Pare: One myth about AI search you'd love to retire. 

Josh Koenig: The notion that- Reframing, just adding a FAQ is the answer. Adding- Adding is the answer. Yep. Right. Like, it- that is the most cheesy SEO trick of the current era, and there's, like with anything, there's a grain of truth in there, but you gotta think more deeply about it than that.

Sharon Pare: One thing associations should stop doing on their websites. 

Josh Koenig: I'm not gonna say stop, because that's extreme, but really consider where you're investing in what type of content to create, and think about that question of breadth versus depth. 

Sharon Pare: Finish the sentence: in two years, the best association websites will

Josh Koenig: Offer people more self-service access to things that used to require calling someone or had gates kept around them. 

Sharon Pare: Awesome. [00:36:00] Thank you, Josh, and w- welcome Pantheon to the association community. I appreciate all your time and your expertise today for this podcast. So again, thank you so much for joining us.

Josh Koenig: Yeah. Thank you for having me here. It was a pleasure to chat with you, and looking forward to meeting more members of the association of associations. 

Sharon Pare: Exactly. And that does it for this episode of Associations NOW Presents. We'll have these episodes throughout the year. Please make sure to join us each month as we explore key topics relevant to association professionals, discuss the challenges and opportunities in the field today, and highlight the significant impact associations have on the economy, the US, and the world.

Again, we want to give a big thanks to our episode sponsor, Pantheon. Be sure to subscribe to our podcast on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts. And for more information, you can go to associationsnow.com. Thank [00:37:00] you.

More episodes from "Associations NOW Presents"