American Socrates podcast

Are Some Pleasures Better Than Others?

0:00
26:59
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Send us Fan Mail

If pleasure is all that matters, a contented pig lives better than a struggling philosopher — and you should plug into a machine that gives you perfect simulated happiness for the rest of your life. Most people find both conclusions obviously wrong. This episode of American Socrates asks why. It works through Mill's famous quality distinction — his argument that it is better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied, and why that argument quietly breaks the utilitarian framework he was trying to defend. Then it introduces Robert Nozick's experience machine: the thought experiment that has haunted philosophy for fifty years, and that reveals what we actually care about when we say we want a good life. Spoiler: it isn't just pleasure. And the gap between what we want and what utilitarianism measures is exactly where its most serious problems live.

Image: Gustav Klimt, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Support the show

Question Everything!

More episodes from "American Socrates"