
Episode Description
Why does every apple you ate as a kid taste like "coffee grounds in a leather glove"? With Thanksgiving pies around the corner, George Duran sits down with comedian Brian Frange, the self-proclaimed Apple enthusiast behind Apple Rankings, the site that scores apples from "Immaculate" all the way down to "Horse Food" and "Apple Hell."
Brian explains how a single bite of a SweeTango ruined every Red Delicious for him, why Honeycrisp is the queen mother of modern apples, how a bad name can sink a perfectly decent apple, and why he re-ranks everything each season (and gets death threats when a stored-over-winter apple lets someone down). Then the mind-bender: plant an apple seed and you get a brand-new variety. Which means every Honeycrisp you've ever eaten came from the same original tree, grafted over and over again.
Plus: how to store apples (fridge, always), the winter "keepers," the farmer who nearly lost the Red Delicious by forgetting to put his address on a contest entry, why Brian wants the American Fuji gone, whether apple picking has turned into a rip-off, and his brick-and-mortar rule for the perfect Thanksgiving apple pie.
This is a Side Dish: a short, one-on-one conversation with someone who really knows their food. For the full Always Hangry experience, with co-hosts, games and rants, check out our regular episodes.
Key Takeaways
- It started as a grievance. Raised on Red Delicious, Brian thought apples came in two kinds, red and green, until a SweeTango changed everything.
- Honeycrisp changed the game. Released by the University of Minnesota in 1991, it's a famously finicky tree to grow, and it's a parent of many of today's star apples: SweeTango, Cosmic Crisp, Lucy Glo, Hunnyz and more.
- Red Delicious was bred for looks. Generations of selecting for color bred the flavor out. Its ancestor, the Hawkeye, still exists, and Brian says it tastes better.
- A name can sink an apple. Brian scores Hunnyz a 58 ("barely worth it") and says it would be in the 70s with a better name.
- Rankings change every season. Rainfall, sunlight, storage, scale and shipping distance all change what reaches the store. A SweeTango in season and one stored over winter are different apples.
- Organic doesn't move the needle (usually). Brian hasn't found a consistent taste difference, though this year's organic Opals are his comeback apple of the year.
- Apples belong in the fridge. In a plastic bag poked with holes, in the crisper drawer at the lowest humidity setting. Apples give off ethylene, so put them next to green bananas to speed ripening.
- "Keepers" get you through winter. Varieties like GoldRush, EverCrisp, Winesap and Arkansas Black store for months. Arkansas Black is so hard off the tree that it needs months in the fridge to become edible, and it still sits in Brian's "Apple Hell."
- Every seed is a new apple. Apples are extreme heterozygotes: a Honeycrisp seed won't grow a Honeycrisp, and most seedlings produce sour, crabapple-like fruit.
- Every Honeycrisp is the same tree. The only way to reproduce a variety is grafting, so every tree of a variety is a clone of the original. You can even graft several varieties onto one tree.
- Apples are big marketing now. New varieties are bred, numbered, tested and focus-grouped; Cosmic Crisp launched with a roughly $10 million marketing campaign. The days of a backyard find becoming a hit are over.
- Red Delicious won a contest — twice. Iowa farmer Jesse Hiatt's Hawkeye won the Stark Bro's contest, but his contact info was lost; he sent it in again the next year and won again.
- Brian's Fuji grudge. American Fujis, he says, are a mealy shadow of the Japanese original, with skin thick enough for a 1920s football helmet.
- Apple picking is pricier for a reason. George thinks orchards squeeze visitors; Brian argues farming apples has never been harder or more expensive.
- The Thanksgiving pie rule: brick and mortar. Use more than one apple. A firm "brick" (Northern Spy — "spies for pies" — or Granny Smith or Golden Delicious) plus a softer "mortar" that melts down (SweeTango, Pink Lady). Brian's pie this year: Golden Delicious and Pink Lady.
- Skip the jar. Brian wouldn't eat canned apple pie filling for less than $70 million.
People & Companies Mentioned
- George Duran — Host, Always Hangry; chef and TV personality
- Brian Frange — Comedian, TV writer and animator from New York (Long Island); creator of Apple Rankings (Tumblr 2016, its own site since 2021), where he goes by "The Appleist"
- Apple Rankings — applerankings.com; apples scored 1–100 in tiers from "Immaculate" to "Apple Hell"
- University of Minnesota — Released Honeycrisp (1991) and SweeTango
- Washington State University / Proprietary Variety Management — Cosmic Crisp and its ~$10 million launch campaign
- Gee Whiz (Auvil Fruit Company) — Producer of Hunnyz (CrimsonCrisp × Honeycrisp)
- Stark Bro's Nurseries — Ran the 1893–94 contest that turned Jesse Hiatt's Hawkeye into the Red Delicious
- Jesse Hiatt — Iowa farmer who found the Hawkeye
- Johnny Appleseed — Seed planter, cited by Brian
- Whole Foods, Trader Joe's, Sam's Club — Where Brian found SweeTango and George bought Lucy Glo and SweeTango
- Sara Lee — Brian says it used Northern Spy for its pies
- Williams Sonoma — Sells jarred apple pie filling, per George
- Apple varieties mentioned: Red Delicious, Hawkeye, Honeycrisp, SweeTango, Cosmic Crisp, SugarBee, Lucy Glo, Ludacrisp, Hunnyz, Opal, Fuji, Golden Delicious, Granny Smith, Pink Lady, Northern Spy, GoldRush, EverCrisp, Winesap, Arkansas Black, McIntosh, Gala, Knobbed Russet, Ashmead's Kernel, Sheep's Nose
Links
Guest
- Apple Rankings — https://applerankings.com
- Brian Frange — https://www.brianfrange.com
- Apple Rankings on Instagram — https://www.instagram.com/theapplerankings
- Apple Rankings on TikTok — https://www.tiktok.com/@applerankings
- Apple Rankings on YouTube — https://www.youtube.com/@applerankings
Always Hangry
- Website — https://alwayshangrypodcast.com
- Instagram — https://www.instagram.com/AlwaysHangryPodcast
- YouTube — https://www.youtube.com/@AlwaysHangryPodcast
- TikTok — https://www.tiktok.com/@AlwaysHangryPodcast
More episodes from "Always Hangry"



Don't miss an episode of “Always Hangry” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








