Hour 3: Steve Schirripa & Rickie RIcardo Join In Studio

Aaron Glenn makes surprises fans with comment that Geno Smith can take the Jets to the ‘Promised Land.’ Hear the best reactions to these comments from Boomer & Gio (0:00), Evan & Tiki (13:18), and Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle (38:34).

Francisco Lindor heard plenty of criticism after his two gaffes in the Mets' series finale against the Cardinals, to the point where Craig Carton called for his tenure in Queens to come to an end. Plus, Evan Roberts says Carlos Mendoza missed an opportunity to send a message and bench the veteran shortstop, and Gregg Giannotti believes the fanbase needs to calm down.

Cam Schlittler was all the hype this week in Yankees Universe, as Evan Roberts declares that the sky is the limit for the Yankee righty, and Gio says Schlittler would fit right in on the 90s dynasty teams. Plus, Tommy Lugauer says Max Fried was worth every penny, Evan and Tiki see a new edge to these Yanks, and Boomer and Gio react to the Bombers' success with the new ABS challenge system.

Things are getting SPICY in New York baseball. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the growing controversy surrounding the New York Mets, including tension involving Francisco Lindor and Brandon Nimmo.

Chris McMonigle react to another Yankees win as the team improves to 6-1 behind dominant pitching and a booming HR from Aaron Judge. But the real story? Evan Roberts joins the show after a BRUTAL experience leaving Yankee Stadium!

The New York Yankees keep rolling to start 2026, and Craig Carton with Chris McMonigle break down a perfect Opening Day in the Bronx!

The New York Yankees are on FIRE to start the 2026 season, and Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break it all down on The Carton Show!

From ‘Go Get ‘Em’ (Subscribe Here): Chris McMonigle breaks down a series win against the Mariners, highlighted by more dominant starting pitching. C-Mac breaks down Cam Schlitter's gem in the series finale, and the concerning return of Camilo Doval's command problems. Plus, the plan for Giancarlo Stanton after a day off, Aaron Boone hitting all the right notes through the first six games, and the struggles of the bottom of the order. Chris also reveals who he is shilling and shaming after the Seattle series. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

After a rough game for Francisco Lindor ,where he not only forgot how many outs there were in the first inning, but also got picked off the base path just before Juan Soto hit a home run. Should Carlos Mendoza prove a point with the 2026 roster by benching Lindor? Deontay Wilder sits down with Piers Morgan and discusses how he came about having a daughter. This may arguably be the best answer in the history of the world. Hold onto your butts! Kirk Cousins continues to shock the world by making more money than any quarterback or player in NFL history. Plus, Cam Schlittler is the best pitcher to ever dawn the pinstripes. Josh Allen is officially a Girl Dad, for now. However, according to some new rules Carton discovers, that may not be the case forever. Plus, can C-Mac have a flawless week with the Wheel?

After a rough game for Francisco Lindor ,where he not only forgot how many outs there were in the first inning, but also got picked off the base path just before Juan Soto hit a home run. Should Carlos Mendoza prove a point with the 2026 roster by benching Lindor?