#149 - Guilty In The Grave

This week, John thanks all of you for tagging him hundreds of times in both the Spice Girls reunion video and David Archuleta singing on American Idol. Daryn meets her own American Idol, Jodie Foster, during none other than Lesbian Visibility Week. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs! Join for as little as $5 a month right here! Want Shaken and Disturbed merch? T-shirts, pillows, hoodies, phone cases, stickers and more are now available here: Shaken and Disturbed MERCH STORE Follow John on Twitter @jthrasher, Instagram @jthrasher and TikTok @johnthrasher Follow Daryn on Twitter @CarpeDaryn and Instagram @CarpeDaryn Join the official Shake and Disturbed Fans Facebook Group here! Make your own AI voice on your iPhone here.

Trigger Warning: This episode contains descriptions of extreme violence including violence against children. Listener discretion is advised. Buckle up and listen to the dark and tumultuous lives of Micajah and Wiley Harpe, two figures born in Scotland and raised during the American Revolution as British loyalists. From joining loyalist gangs as teenagers to their final days evading the law, their story unfolds amidst violence and chaos. This episode explores the trail of crimes that stoked fear across the early American frontier. As their saga ends in betrayal and retribution, we examine the consequences of their actions on themselves and their families, and the shocking extents of their brutality. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs! Join for as little as $5 a month right here! Want Shaken and Disturbed merch? T-shirts, pillows, hoodies, phone cases, stickers and more are now available here: Shaken and Disturbed MERCH STORE Follow John on Twitter @jthrasher, Instagram @jthrasher and TikTok @johnthrasher Follow Daryn on Twitter @CarpeDaryn and Instagram @CarpeDaryn Join the official Shake and Disturbed Fans Facebook Group here! 

In this episode, we delve deeper into the infamous 1954 murder of Marilyn Sheppard, an event that unraveled in Bay Village, Ohio, and ignited a nationwide media storm. We examine the initial night of the crime, the intense scrutiny faced by her husband, Sam Sheppard, and the dramatic legal battles that followed, including a conviction, a subsequent overturning on appeal, and a retrial. Through expert interviews and detailed analyses, we explore how this case not only captivated public attention but also shaped legal precedents regarding media influence on trials and the presumption of innocence in the American legal system. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs! Join for as little as $5 a month right here! Want Shaken and Disturbed merch? T-shirts, pillows, hoodies, phone cases, stickers and more are now available here: Shaken and Disturbed MERCH STORE Follow John on Twitter @jthrasher, Instagram @jthrasher and TikTok @johnthrasher Follow Daryn on Twitter @CarpeDaryn and Instagram @CarpeDaryn Join the official Shake and Disturbed Fans Facebook Group here! 

Daryn takes the wheel solo on this week's interview episode! Is Scott Peterson innocent? On this episode, friend of Daryn's, attorney and host of the podcast "The Presumption," Sara Azari, comes to talk about everything she knows about the case, the likelihood of Scott being found not guilty, and all the pitfalls of public opinion influencing cases. You don't want to miss the captivating conversation! Follow "The Presumption" podcast on Apple Podcasts SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs! Join for as little as $5 a month right here! Want Shaken and Disturbed merch? T-shirts, pillows, hoodies, phone cases, stickers and more are now available here: Shaken and Disturbed MERCH STORE Follow John on Twitter @jthrasher, Instagram @jthrasher and TikTok @johnthrasher Follow Daryn on Twitter @CarpeDaryn and Instagram @CarpeDaryn Join the official Shake and Disturbed Fans Facebook Group here! 

Is that John or John's clone at the top of the show? Tune in to find out. John talks about the updates to his car that drove himself home from a haircut. Daryn has yet ANOTHER gym problem! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs! Join for as little as $5 a month right here! Want Shaken and Disturbed merch? T-shirts, pillows, hoodies, phone cases, stickers and more are now available here: Shaken and Disturbed MERCH STORE Follow John on Twitter @jthrasher, Instagram @jthrasher and TikTok @johnthrasher Follow Daryn on Twitter @CarpeDaryn and Instagram @CarpeDaryn Join the official Shake and Disturbed Fans Facebook Group here! Make your own AI voice on your iPhone here.

Clay Tiffany, a notable figure from Briarcliff Manor, NY, leveraged his platform "Dirge for the Charlatans" to critique local authorities, sparking controversy and evoking mixed reactions. His uncompromising stance against perceived injustices made him a polarizing figure, with a legacy deeply rooted in community activism and journalism. Yet, beneath his public persona, hints of tragedy loomed, leading to an untimely and impactful end that left the community divided in its wake. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs! Join for as little as $5 a month right here! Want Shaken and Disturbed merch? T-shirts, pillows, hoodies, phone cases, stickers and more are now available here: Shaken and Disturbed MERCH STORE Follow John on Twitter @jthrasher, Instagram @jthrasher and TikTok @johnthrasher Follow Daryn on Twitter @CarpeDaryn and Instagram @CarpeDaryn Join the official Shake and Disturbed Fans Facebook Group here! 

Tim Pilleri and Lance Reenstierna, hosts of the "Crawlspace" and "Missing" podcasts join us on this week's episode. Our old friends catch us up on the case that put them on the map, the cold case of Maura Murray. Then, all four of us spend a few minutes highlighting some missing people that we want to bring to the table including Riley Strain, Brianna Maitland, Terrence Woods Jr., and Oakley Carlson. For more on the cases highlighted in this episode and to check out Tim and Lance's shows, check out the links below: Crawlspace Podcast Missing Podcast Missing: Brianna Maitland Missing: Oakley Carlson Dark Valley Light The Way (Missing Database) Uncovered (Missing Database)

This Daryn-heavy episode features EVEN MORE inappropriate weirdos at the gym! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs! Join for as little as $5 a month right here! Want Shaken and Disturbed merch? T-shirts, pillows, hoodies, phone cases, stickers and more are now available here: Shaken and Disturbed MERCH STORE Follow John on Twitter @jthrasher, Instagram @jthrasher and TikTok @johnthrasher Follow Daryn on Twitter @CarpeDaryn and Instagram @CarpeDaryn Join the official Shake and Disturbed Fans Facebook Group here! 

We're taking a week off while John recovers from being sick! So here's an episode from about a year ago. When beauty influencer Khadija O. is approached to do a brand deal with one of her favorite musical artists, she can't help but jump at the idea. What she doesn't know is that the person approaching her is out for blood. This episode originally aired in April 2023. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs! Join for as little as $5 a month right here! Want Shaken and Disturbed merch? T-shirts, pillows, hoodies, phone cases, stickers and more are now available here: Shaken and Disturbed MERCH STORE Follow John on Twitter @jthrasher, Instagram @jthrasher and TikTok @johnthrasher Follow Daryn on Twitter @CarpeDaryn and Instagram @CarpeDaryn Join the official Shake and Disturbed Fans Facebook Group here! 

This is the true crime story of the perplexing disappearance of Carolyn Muncey from her home in Luttrell, Tennessee, on July 13th, 1985. As Carolyn vanished, leaving her two young children and husband Hubert behind, the small town of less than 1,000 people was thrust into a state of unease. With Carolyn's body discovered in a shocking location, the investigation intensified, revealing disturbing details surrounding her tragic demise. Suspicions arose, particularly around Paul Gregory House, a newcomer with a criminal past, who was in the vicinity at the time of Carolyn's disappearance. Join us as we uncover the factual events and intricate details surrounding the Carolyn Muncey case, a saga marked by mystery and unanswered questions. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs! Join for as little as $5 a month right here! Want Shaken and Disturbed merch? T-shirts, pillows, hoodies, phone cases, stickers and more are now available here: Shaken and Disturbed MERCH STORE Follow John on Twitter @jthrasher, Instagram @jthrasher and TikTok @johnthrasher Follow Daryn on Twitter @CarpeDaryn and Instagram @CarpeDaryn Join the official Shake and Disturbed Fans Facebook Group here!