Father and Joe E487: Every Saint Made the Same Choice — Letting God Love Them
On the feast of All Saints, Joe Rockey noticed something simple hiding in plain sight: every saint, across wildly different lives and eras, got there the same way — not through raw talent, but through a choice, exercised like a muscle, to practice virtue. Father Boniface Hicks takes that observation somewhere deeper: the real starting point isn't effort at all, it's letting yourself be loved by God first — and that's harder than it sounds.Key Ideas:No saint was born with a "super-abundance" of courage or humility any more than a home-run hitter is born swinging a bat — virtue is built the same way any skill is, through repeated, conscientious choice.What every saint actually has in common is that they let God love them, even while feeling inadequate or sinful — that received love, not willpower, is the real origin of grace and the fuel for everything virtue builds afterward.Letting yourself be loved is harder than it sounds: feeling unworthy of love and feeling self-sufficient are opposite-looking barriers that both block it, and both require the same vulnerability and trust to get past.Virtue becomes a genuinely upward spiral — the more you do good, the more it's your nature to do good, the more you enjoy doing it — but accustoming yourself to love can tip into entitlement if gratitude for it as a gift isn't actively sustained.Living in "the logic of the gift" (a concept from John Paul II's Theology of the Body) means both giving yourself away to others and letting others' love, attention, and sacrifice actually land on you — and doing good this way doesn't guarantee outcomes will look the way you planned, but that doesn't make the choice wrong.Links & References: None explicitly referenced with a clear official/source link in this episode.If this helped, please leave a review or share this episode with a friend. Questions or thoughts? Email [email protected]: Hello and welcome to another episode of Father and Joe. I'm Joe Rockey here with Father Boniface Hicks. And Father, as we record this, the last Mass of the weekend was All Saints Day. And as I was listening and thinking during that Mass, something really kind of came upon me. And that was that while all of these saints lived different lives, inherently in different times, they all made a choice, and that choice was to exercise at least one virtue, right? Because you have to be heroic and have a virtue very well established. And no one in life is born with a super-abundance of anything — courage, humility, etc. You have to strive and make choices to exercise those, become better. It's just like any other muscle, like any other profession. No one wakes up and day one goes, well, this could be the greatest hitting, home-run all-star of all time — no, he's going to spend some time in the batting cages, and play baseball a lot. And the same is true with each one of these saints, making choices, and then in some cases we see some very extraordinary outcomes come out of it. But it all started with them making a conscientious effort to exercise a virtue and draw closer to God.And that power that each individual has, I don't think we talk about enough. And given the fact that this show is all about the relationship you have with yourself, the relationship you have with others, and the relationship you have with God, exercising virtues helps with all three of those types of relationships. And that's why I want to show each person why this is worth it. And it's not just something, "Oh, I get the benefit after I'm dead" — no, you get the benefit now, today, and so does everyone around you. So with that being said, Father, I want to leave the floor to you, talking about how choosing to exercise virtue is really worthwhile.Yeah, that's right. And your point that we all have to work at it — so we have to make the decision to work at it. We certainly may have certain natural talents, that have a capacity for growth, some of us more than others in different areas. There was probably never going to be possible for me to hit home runs — but who knows, maybe things could have gone differently for me. But certainly, beyond some natural talent, everybody needs to develop it. And all of us have a certain natural talent for being good, let's say. That's really what the focus of virtue is — different ways of being good, knowing the good, recognizing it, and then choosing it for the sake of others, prudence, justice, and then doing that when it takes some effort, with fortitude, and also when there are other sort of self-seeking things that could draw us away from it, we need temperance, and all of the sub-virtues around all of those things. But the point is, we all have a supernatural capacity to do good, and when we really work at developing the habits of doing good, then that can really grow to a heroic degree. And it can grow that much because God is actually at work in us. Each of us, by baptism, have the Holy Spirit alive in us, and the Holy Spirit is pressing in the direction of doing good in a heroic degree, of giving us the very qualities of Jesus himself, of the God-man, to come alive in each one of us. And so it's not just a matter of pushing ourselves harder to achieve something that is within our own power, but rather we're allowing the Holy Spirit to bring about what he is trying to bring about — namely, that we be divinized, that we be made holy, that we be made more like Christ in our capacity to do good.So, but as you said, it takes work, it takes perseverance, and part of that work is recognizing when we're failing at it, and we turn our hearts back to him through repentance and confession, and we have the opportunity to begin again. We're always in that position, and we continue to set out towards the highest ideal, to strive for a life that we wouldn't want to escape from, but rather that we love to live in. And that's one of the consequences of virtue, as you said, Joe — it's not just a matter of pushing hard so that you get the reward and get into heaven, but the very work now sets us free. And the freedom of the holy ones, the freedom of the virtuous, to do good — which is actually what we're made for — and so we feel most fulfilled when we're able to do good, the joy of it, it feels good to do good. And so then we have a fulfilling life, a life that we love to live, that we love to be in, not just sort of getting through it until we're out of it — it feels good to be able to bless people, to love people in particular ways. And the more virtue we have, the more freely we can do that, the more generously and effectively we can do that, the more we see the results of that, the more we enjoy being able to do good. Anyway, it's a virtuous cycle — it builds on itself, the more you do it, the better it gets, the better it gets, the more you do it. And that cycle, that upward-moving cycle, is the cycle of holiness.So, coming back to what you said about the feast of All Saints — I mean, the thing that they have in common is they let God love them. First of all, that's really the origin of grace, and that grace is the most powerful transforming effect in terms of virtue. They let God love them, even when they felt inadequate, unworthy, when they knew that they were sinners, limited — they let God love them. And then they used that love — they responded to that love by extending what they had to others, starting with whatever little they could do. And then the more that they did a little, the more that a little became a lot, and that a lot is what we see in them and honor in them. But, you know, it took a process to get there.And I think that that's one of the important things — we use that word "grace" all the time, but we never really talk about how it actually works. It's one of these things where people can be like, well, those Catholics talk about all kinds of stuff, but how does it actually apply to your life? How does it actually function? And you gave the answer — you have to allow God's love to enter into you. You have to allow period love to enter into you. And that transformation, from someone who's not in a state of doing that, to allowing that, is radical beyond measure. And I think that that is something that is really worth contemplating and spending time upon, more than just saying it as, okay, that's a given fact, now let's go talk about the next thing — but actually spending time on essentially a prerequisite of the faith.Yeah. Letting ourselves be loved — we could ask the question, it sounds like, well, who wouldn't want that? Well, yeah, that's a good question — how well do you let yourself be loved? And we can imagine a few reasons why that becomes difficult. When we feel unworthy of love, perhaps we know what we've done wrong, and we don't feel like anybody would love us. And that could be borne out by people treating us badly on top of it, and so we start to feel like that's what we deserve. That's a certain vicious cycle — because I don't feel lovable, so I shut myself off to love, and then by shutting myself off to love, I don't feel lovable. And so that spirals downward, and needs something to break into it.Sometimes we don't let ourselves be loved because we feel somehow beyond that — we feel kind of self-sufficient, and we feel like, I don't know, the master of the universe or something like that, and I can do everything without anyone. And so there's a kind of pride or arrogance that can separate us from love, can put up a barrier there — I don't want any help, I don't want to be indebted to anyone, I don't want to lower myself to let somebody else do something for me. And that resistance to indebtedness can be a real detriment...