
Whey protein prices are falling. Nonfat remains stubbornly high. And butter and cheese face a long road back.
What’s going to turn these markets around?
In episode 109 of The Milk Check, host Ted Jacoby III and the T.C. Jacoby & Co. team dig into the conflicting signals shaping dairy markets as the year winds down.
Whey protein prices have retreated from record highs, though the long-term demand outlook still looks solid. Nonfat continues to trade above $2 per pound, even as the market anticipates a correction. Meanwhile, rising butter and cheese production is putting more pressure on exports to absorb excess supply.
We cover:
- Whether whey protein prices have finally found a bottom
- Why nonfat prices remain elevated and what could bring them down
- How a narrowing price spread between WPC 80 and MPC 85 could shift demand
- Why butter and cheese need stronger exports to recover
- How Chinese buying and global milk production could change the outlook
With U.S. dairy production growing and global competition intensifying, exports may be the key to bringing these markets back into balance.
But will international demand be enough?
Listen to The Milk Check episode 109: What Will Turn Dairy Markets Around?
Also available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Podcasts, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Got questions?
We’d love to hear them. Submit below, and we might answer it on the show.
Ask The Milk CheckIntro commercial, Mike Brown: For one part of the supply chain to be successful, everyone has to be. I believe firmly that Jacoby’s success is because we help our suppliers and our buyers be successful.
Mike Brown: I’m Mike Brown, and I love working for T.C. Jacoby & Co. because I get to help people make their businesses more successful.
Ted Jacoby III: Coming up on The Milk Check.
Josh White: When we talk about WPC prices coming down, what’s gonna stop it or save it?
Ted Jacoby III: Welcome to the Milk Check from T.C. Jacoby & Co., your complete guide to dairy markets, from the milking parlor to the supermarket shelf. I’m Ted Jacoby. Let’s dive in.
Ted Jacoby III: Today is November 9th, and we’re having a classic market discussion. Usually by this time of the year our highs are in for the year, we’re filling holiday orders, and we’re starting to move towards the end of the year.
But this year has certainly not been a normal year, and the question everybody’s asking is: What’s going on with protein prices? What’s going on with non-fat prices? And will butter and cheese ever recover? So, I thought we’d start with protein.
Josh, whey protein prices have been coming down. Are they done coming down? Where are we at?
Josh White: Yeah, Ted, the rate of descent has slowed. The third quarter, more or less, put in all-time highs.
But it was the first quarter where the spot market and the quarterly contract market converged. It was the first time in a while where spot pricing as you get into a quarter wasn’t higher than the actual quarterly contract price, and that resulted in a few things.
And I’ve interviewed a few customers and asked them, I said, “Hey, of these options do you think is more of the issue? Is it, A, people over-ordered all year long, and the minute that the spot market wasn’t higher than their quarterly commitment price, they said, ‘Hey, we’re gonna back up a little bit, and we’re going to consume a little of this surplus that we’ve ordered?”
Is it B, seasonal slowdown, that we got into the summer, and people take holiday, they go on vacation, they’re away. They bought what they needed leading up to it. Coming out of it they’re looking at prices that had not gone higher, so their urgency to buy wasn’t there. Is it C, that maybe demand has just been overstated because of the supply chain filling that’s been happening with new product launches all year?
Or D, is it that we got to a high price, we’re actually killing demand? We’re actually killing demand, and I think first would be the export market. We killed export demand at some of these prices, especially in the developing markets. And the answer, like almost unanimously, is yep, all the above.
So, that set things in motion. And if you’re a manufacturer or processor out there and, your customers are calling, they usually buy eight units, then they’ve been buying 10, maybe even 12, buying that consistently, and then all of a sudden, they say for the fourth quarter, “You know what?
We’re gonna consume a little inventory. We only need five,” that’s a big whiplash. And I think that’s been a real driver, and the lever to pull is price. And so, we have seen prices moving lower. The thing is, lower prices can’t quickly stimulate a demand response. But the good news is we just finished a big event.
Supply Side Global is a really nice event for protein markets. Lot of discussion there. We had a lot of manufacturers show up with a lot of product to sell. And you also had a lot of buyers that were interested and curious to see, what can they get covered going forward.
So yeah, it is a buyer’s market if you’re buying product right now. The issue is you’ve got a lot of customers that are saying, “We don’t need it until the first quarter. We don’t wanna load up inventory before year end, but we are gonna manufacture it.”
Demand forecasts look pretty good. Everyone still believes that the protein trend is intact and is solid. But the product’s available now, and the people want the price tomorrow. So that’s what we gotta reconcile. It’s a bidder’s market, great deals if you’re willing to take loads today, and people are trying to leverage that into getting good prices for tomorrow.
So I think we’re close.
Ted Jacoby III: To use a trader’s term, this feels a lot like a Fibonacci retracement to me.
We’ve gone from $2.50 for WPC80, all the way up to 14, and usually you pull back into what they call the box, the box is basically, 62 to 38%, just call it on average about a 50% retracement of that. So, that would be a pullback of $6 from 14. So it’s right around 7.50 to 8.
Josh White: I would maybe pull in the numbers a little bit. There was deals below 2.50, but the market average price got as low as 2.50 a few years ago.
I really think it ran out of steam once we touched 13, you could argue maybe 13.50. So, that 38% pullback was right around nine bucks. You can buy quite a bit better than that today. We’re hearing numbers in the sevens for sure. But again, you gotta buy it right now, and I don’t know that the average quarterly price traded today and the one that’ll be sold in the first quarter will be quite that low.
So yeah we’re right in the box there. We’re right in that 38 to 50%, pullback. A normal Fibonacci retracement, then you would resume the uptrend from the retracement point, and it would match that first move. I’m not convinced that we’re going to $17.
But I do think that, we’ve got a little time. The trend seems pretty strong, and [00:05:00] I could see a double top maybe lower highs this time, but I could see the market moving back up. Now, let’s talk about the other side of that real quick, because all it takes is for this protein surge or consumers to run out of money at these prices, and we can reverse things, and I don’t think we’re getting a lot of rosy signals, in terms of the general economy, consumer confidence in the economy.
Protein has been an outlier, as we’ve seen. The quick service reports look pretty bad. We’re seeing a lot of those type of measurements that are looking pretty concerning. All the while, health memberships are up, fitness memberships are up, protein continues to move.
Yeah, if all of a sudden, that starts to slide, okay. These are pretty high prices relatively for dairy protein.
Jacob Menge: In the U.S. specifically, Josh, do you know of anybody launching new products still with WPC80, or is this now feeding existing product lines?
Josh White: I can give you at least some anecdotal reports. Going into the Supply Side Global, there was still a lot of talk about two big demand events, about Black Friday, and I thought that was interesting. And Black Friday has never really been a dairy thing for me, in 20-some years.
But you can see how it could be for protein. A lot of e-commerce, a lot of movement along those lines, so there was a lot of talk about Black Friday. There was even some talk from a couple of co-mans that I deal with that were like, “Hey, we’re still trying to get this new product launched for one of our customers for Black Friday.”
So I don’t know if that evidence is the entire market, Jake, but yeah, that’s an example of it. And then I think we know that New Year’s is coming, and I made the joke through Supply Side Global that, if now more than ever Americans will commit to at least half of January of getting healthy again, and there’s probably gonna be a lot of protein orders coming in for that.
A final note that’s really worth mentioning, and this is more in Diego’s area, but we have really compressed the WPC and the MPC prices now. So, MPC all the while has been really firm, probably because some of these new product launches have been favoring a look at MPCs because of the value. Now WPC 80 and MPC 85 are really starting to tighten.
They’re getting pretty close to the same levels, and MPC has been firming. If you’re looking for another reason to think maybe we’re carving out a bottom, I think that would be a pretty good one.
Ted Jacoby III: I think the general consensus, Diego, has been that the protein market has bled over into the non-fat market, and one of the reasons we’ve had some pretty strong prices in non-fat this year is related to that protein demand.
And while whey protein prices have come down, non-fat prices have not, and they still stay above $2 a pound. What’s going on there? Is it gonna stay up there? Are things looking similar for non-fat and MPC that they are to WPC, or how’s that gonna play out?
Diego Carvallo: Ted, if you look at the futures curve, you’re gonna see that the market is expecting a strong correction for the coming months . That’s why the market is so inverted, right? And I personally agree with that, and most of the traders you talk to would be in line that the U.S. still needs to export product, and we cannot stay completely disconnected by almost $1,000 or $500 from the international market for a period of time that is unreasonable, basically.
so, the market is expecting that once the flush kicks in the U.S., we are gonna have plenty more product, and we’re gonna need those exports. And for that reason, we’re very competitive actually when it comes to first quarter of next year. We are very aligned with European prices, and New Zealand is also very close to first quarter of next year’s pricing.
So, the general consensus is that the market is still very tight. It’s gonna remain very tight, at least until the end of the year, and then we’re gonna see prices become way more competitive. Still at historical high prices above the 180 Or close to 180 for first quarter of the year.
We may see more pressure when the flush kicks in than what the futures are suggesting. So I think we could still go down 10, 15 cents, and I think Europe and New Zealand are also gonna feel the impact of very competitive U.S. prices
Ted Jacoby III: We’ve been having a conversion of WPC and MPC prices, but it sounds like what we expect is we’ll be in this area for maybe a month or two, and then we’ll go back to having a gap between MPC and whey prices with whey going up and MPC going down, right?
Josh White: I don’t know that you’re gonna see MPC go down.
Ted Jacoby III: Just non-fat, so not MPC.
But a lot of MPC prices are based on the non-fat price, aren’t they?
Josh White: Historically. And I think an argument that would support MPC maybe softening a little is the fact that we do have a lot of new production coming on.
And maybe not all in dry form, but even on the ultra-filtrated side.
So, there is an argument that a weakening non-fat market could translate to lower MPC. But if you continue to see demand growth and people are looking at it as a substitute to 80 just because non-fat goes down doesn’t mean-
Ted Jacoby III: True.
Josh White: Yeah … the marketable value of that MPC 85 in dry form as a substitute to [00:10:00] WPC will just immediately go lower.
Ted Jacoby III: That’s fair.
Diego Carvallo: And I also think now that the spread between WPC 80 and MPC 80 has shrunk so much and it’s as tight as it is right now, we’re gonna see some manufacturers switching back to 80 because the incentive to stay on the MPC 85 is not as amazing as it was probably three months ago, right?
Ted Jacoby III: Another reason to argue we’re getting close to the bottom on the WPC 80 market.
Diego Carvallo: Yeah.
Mike Brown: Diego, I’ve heard that same thing. A little less emphasis on the 85, a little bit lower protein MPC.
Diego Carvallo: Makes sense. I heard from a European trader last week that up to they said the number was between 15% and 20% of the volume, in Europe have switched from WPC 80 to MPC 85.
Only a few manufacturers had made the switch, but the volume was equivalent to 15% to 20%, so that’s a significant amount. And they also said now that the spread between the two had narrowed so much, they expected that many of them were gonna switch back to WPC.
Ted Jacoby III: Everybody, we will be right back after these messages.
Center commercial, Diego Carvallo: I’m Diego Carvallo with T.C. Jacoby & Co. T.C. Jacoby & Co. specializes in international dairy markets. For new customers that haven’t done business with Jacoby, I would tell them that we can provide them with many of the powders, dairy products that they consume, not only with the physical product, but we can also help them mitigate their risk.
We know dairy. We know the main players. We know the main providers for the whole value chain. We are one of the strongest players in the U.S. market because we have contact all the way from the farmer moving the liquid milk all the way to the end users that buy the end products. I am Diego Carvallo with T.C. Jacoby & Co., and We bring dairy to the world.
End center commercial.
Ted Jacoby III: Meanwhile, we’ve got butter and cheese, and the question is, will they ever recover? And kind of the way a lot of people have talked about the cheese market this year is we’re making a whole bunch of cheese in order to get to the whey protein. I think it’s also fair to say, even though it’s happening at the cow level, we’re making a whole bunch of butterfat to get to the protein.
But the bottom line is domestic cheese demand is flat to lower for multitude of reasons. Domestic butter demand may be up, but it’s probably not up as much as production is up. And so, in both cases, we’ve got more than enough product to fill every pound of need that we have domestically. And so, the only way those markets can recover, at least in the short term, would be for us to see a big bump in exports.
Joe, I’ll start with you. What are you seeing out there with the butter market?
Joe Maixner: Yeah, the butter market’s probably one of the more boring markets out of all of the current markets over the past month. continues to be long. Exports have been good because of the soft pricing, and we anticipate that exports will continue to be good and continue to grow.
But we’re averaging about 10% of monthly production right now in exports, and we need to pump those numbers up quite a bit to make a material difference. With the amount of fat that’s coming down from the herd, we’re not going to consume it domestically.
We have to continue to grow our export market. And fortunately, while we continue to be the cheapest in the world we continue to penetrate new markets. But it’s gonna have to keep going for us to work our way out of this. And this is a new cycle.
We’re gonna have more competitive pricing, I think, for a little while longer before we work our way out of it.
Ted Jacoby III: You’ve been traveling internationally quite a bit lately to try to drum up some of those international butter sales. Is the interest there? Are we gonna be able to clear it in the international market?
Joe Maixner: The interest is there. There’s a lot of interest in various different forms, not just in industrial. The problem is with U.S. production we don’t necessarily make the type of packaging that the rest of the world wants. And then there’s always the color issue where people see our butter and it is white compared to European or New Zealand butter.
So there’s some hurdles, but the demand is most certainly there.
Ted Jacoby III: Glad to hear that because we’re gonna need it with the amount of butterfat we’re making. Meanwhile, we’ve got cheese. I gave a presentation last week to a group, and I borrowed a U.S. DEC slide that described what the expectations were for cheese exports in the global cheese trade, and basically, they’re expecting global cheese trade to be up six percent a year over the next five years, and they’re expecting the U.S. to garner the majority of that increase.
Something like eighty percent of all the increase in cheese trade going forward over the next five years they think is gonna come from the U.S. So, that’s the good news. We’ll see if it actually happens, but at least from an international standpoint, it looks like we’re gonna be able to clear that cheese.
But Jake, I’m gonna ask you, we did get a bit of a pop in the cheese market in the last month. Is that just your classic holiday pop? Are we expecting things to come back down? Are [00:15:00] we hearing anything out there in terms of cheese exports for the first quarter of next year? Where do we stand with the cheese market?
Jacob Menge: Probably the scariest thing in the cheese market right now if you’re a farmer or manufacturer, is that despite the prices being historically low, people are surprised how high they are right now. There are some manufacturing issues.
It lined up nicely with holiday demand. They’ll get worked through before long. I, I’d say through the end of the year it could remain tight in the 150s, 160s. I think that more people than not would be surprised though if we stay up here.
We should be producing more cheese next year, not just, the incremental year-over-year efficiency gains, et cetera, but there were some plants in Q1 that weren’t, fully started up in 2026 that should be in 2027. And so, we should have more cheese, and this is just daunting is the best way to put it.
We’re gonna have to keep winning international business and to address your Q1 export question , I don’t know that we got a ton locked up in Q1. I think there was a window of time where we had pretty good aggressive pricing for Q4. I think we’ve been high enough in this 150s, 160s area for long enough that the international buyers haven’t jumped on it probably as aggressively.
We might get another one of those windows. We’ll see. But that’s the state of the union for now.
Ted Jacoby III: One of the things I’ve noticed in the cheese market is that in the U.S., the cheese price is based off the cheddar price, and the cheddar price feels really long.
But mozz hasn’t felt long at all. In fact, mozz, if anything, has felt tight.
We tend to price mozzarella off the cheddar market. But I can’t help feeling that the mozz market seems to be driving things more than the cheddar market these days.
Would you say that’s true?
Jacob Menge: I don’t know if I’d go that far. There’s always been the, “Hey, what’s EU Mozz doing?” And there’s been that relationship that tends to pivot around certain extreme levels. I think that’s still certainly gonna go on. But it’s just hard to say that mozz is the reason that cheddar prices are where they’re at in the U.S.
I certainly would stop short of that. But mozz being tight is for real. That has been a persistent theme of this year. And There’s no end in sight as far as I can tell.
Ted Jacoby III: A little bit on the fluid side I was talking to Gus the other day. Gus made a comment that I thought was fascinating. He said that the butter market right now almost is a function of what he’s seeing in the UF market, or basically in the available solids market.
And what he meant by that was in the first half of the year, available solids are relatively available. You were shipping skim solids not only to the ready-to-drink manufacturers that wanted it, but also to any cheese manufacturer that want it. Milk production peaks in May, get into the the heat of the summer, and then milk production starts to go down, and those available solids start to go down as well.
And so, we haven’t been making skim UF like we used to because there’s less milk available to do so, and as a result, we’ve been producing less skim to sell into cheese plants, which means the cheese plants now, instead of adding skim solids to the vat, they have to skim off the cream, and it’s increased the availability of the cream.
On the fluid side of the business, we’re seeing some of the same things with this butterfat length of how it’s changing the dynamic. And when you think about the cheese price being high, but the butter price being low, but it feeling long , nevertheless there may be something to what Gus’s argument is: that skim solids availability has inverted how the butter market functions, at least for the time being.
Diego Carvallo: Should we talk a little bit international?
Ted Jacoby III: Sure. That sounds like a good idea. What are you seeing out there?
Diego Carvallo: There’s a lot of talk in the past two or three weeks about El Niño impact in New Zealand and weather being dry. Apparently there is new weather coming into the island that is bringing a lot of relief for farmers.
And most of the risk of severe impact into production should be over if this rain actually hits. Apart from that, I don’t think there’s a lot of news out of Europe besides skim milk concentrate still being very tight and milk going into the cheese plants before going into any sort of powders.
Ted Jacoby III: What do you think that means in the long run?
Diego Carvallo: I think it’s definitely bearish for whole milk powder and skim milk powder out of New Zealand, I think the market had already priced in a weather risk premium, and if this rain actually materializes, risk premium should come off prices.
It’s one that I’m monitoring closely.
Joe Maixner: This weather risk was about the only bullish perspective that there was for the New Zealand market anyway. So, if this doesn’t materialize, they’re already forecasted to finish out the milk season very strongly. But if this materializes and they get some opportune rain and good weather, then that’s gonna be some weak pricing coming out of Oceania and a lot of product.
Same with Australia area. The Australian market [00:20:00] is forecasted to grow in milk production for the first time in years. They have a surplus of butterfat as well, and so that whole Oceania market is gonna be getting a lot more competitive this year as opposed to the past couple of years.
Couple that with long butterfat coming out of Europe as well and there’s not a whole lot of bullishness, at least on the fat side for the world market.
Ted Jacoby III: Joe, you just came back from Europe. What are you hearing out of Europe right now?
Joe Maixner: I’ll probably know more when I go back next week.
The last show was a bit more globally focused than it was solely Europe focused. The focus has been primarily on the powders and cheese has been very strong especially exports. They have been long butter. There’s been a lot put in the freezers, and they’ve been trying to sit on it, wait for the market to get better, and it really hasn’t.
What I’ve been told is that a lot of the product has actually been starting to quietly move so they’re not quite as long as everybody thought they originally were, but there’s still product in inventory that needs to move out.
Ted Jacoby III: Okay.
Josh White: I think it would be a mistake to not talk about Chinese buying, because I think in the last GDT it was a bit of a surprise, I think, to most. When we talk about the long dairy market, particularly for fats, certainly from a supply side it feels like it’s gonna continue to be heavy and continue to be pretty ugly.
And when we talk about WPC prices coming down, what’s gonna stop it or save it? I’m not saying China’s gonna totally reverse course, but boy, if China continues to buy at the rate that they bought in the last GDT whether that’s seasonal, whether that’s restocking, I don’t think anybody’s arguing that the Chinese market is going through massive growth in dairy again at this moment, but clearly something structurally has shifted there. That market has been buying, and that can really clean up a lot of volume, particularly from Oceana if that continues.
Ted Jacoby III: That’s a good point. We’ll have to watch that one closely and see how it plays out. All right, guys. Hey, this was a great conversation. I hope this was helpful to all of our listeners. Look forward to talking to all of you guys soon. And guys, thanks for joining us today. Take care.
Ending commercial, Ted Jacoby III: If you wanna see the conversation, join us on YouTube at The Milk Check. If you’ve been listening to The Milk Check Podcast, for the first time, you can see our team in action while we dive into dairy markets, risk management, and everything that happens across our industry. Whether you’re in the plant, on the farm, or at your desk, you can listen the way you like.
Be part of the discussion shaping the future of dairy. We will see you at The Milk Check.
End.
Altri episodi di "The Milk Check"



Non perdere nemmeno un episodio di “The Milk Check”. Iscriviti all'app gratuita GetPodcast.








