
Obviously, this is mostly about the literacy crisis, whether we understand it properly, whether it is happening in Spain, whether the PISA data supports James’ thesis, and so on. I began by asking James Marriott how things might work out for the best…
OLIVER: So the book is about the reading crisis and the risk it poses to liberal democracy. I want you to tell me, what is the most likely optimistic outcome? You might think that the odds of everything going well are very low, but if we do scrape through, what will it look like?
MARRIOTT: That’s such a good question, and nobody has ever asked me that question before. Seeking optimism from me is a unique idea. I think the most likely optimistic outcome, as I think so often in history, is stagnation and more of the same, and things don’t change.
We also talked about AI as a transmission of liberal democracy, a means of distributing James’ own work, and things like that. At the end, we had some fun about literary critics and Shakespeare which is much more civilized that arguing about the literacy crisis.
MARRIOTT: Yes, I’m keen to read The Winter’s Tale, and I’ve got it, actually. It came in my little set.
OLIVER: I think you’ll be pleasantly surprised, and then you can read Northrop Frye’s book about it.
MARRIOTT: Yes.
OLIVER: Which would be James Marriott–coded.
MARRIOTT: Yes, good. I am very biased towards things that are James Marriott–coded.
The Frye book I had in mind was A Natural Perspective. James is also going to read A.C. Bradley and we might record another podcast about that. Bradley being one of the greats.
Transcript
HENRY OLIVER: Today I am talking to James Marriott. James is a Times columnist, a Substacker—he writes Cultural Capital—and he has a new book called The New Dark Ages. James, welcome.
JAMES MARRIOTT: Thanks very much for having me.
The Reading Crisis
OLIVER: So the book is about the reading crisis and the risk it poses to liberal democracy. I want you to tell me, what is the most likely optimistic outcome? You might think that the odds of everything going well are very low, but if we do scrape through, what will it look like?
MARRIOTT: That’s such a good question, and nobody has ever asked me that question before. Seeking optimism from me is a unique idea. I think the most likely optimistic outcome, as I think so often in history, is stagnation and more of the same, and things don’t change. And I guess I think there are a lot of reasons to be pessimistic.
I think societies have a remarkable capacity to go on stagnating or declining slowly and imperceptibly for a very long time, and often much longer than we think. I know that’s pretty tepid optimism. Probably in the general scheme of the sort of takes that I offer, that is quite optimistic. But yes, I always think that stagnation and drifting and can-kicking are underrated forces in history.
OLIVER: Are we not going to stagnate at quite a high level?
MARRIOTT: Yes.
OLIVER: So is the pessimism sort of misplaced, in the sense that even a relatively bad outcome for us would be really quite good by the standards of human history?
MARRIOTT: Yes, of course. Although, I mean, the standards of human history are an appallingly low bar. And I think any of us asked to try to eke out an existence in pre-industrial modernity would view that with more horror than a prison sentence or being sent to almost any country in the modern world. To live in a sort of pre-industrial, pre-democratic state would be pretty terrible, so that’s a low bar.
That said, I think the main lesson from history is that—and I guess this is one of the points that is in the background of the book—is that we are living extraordinarily anomalous lives. To live in a literate and democratic culture is overwhelmingly not the norm through the entirety of human history. And I think sometimes humans have an extraordinary capacity for complacency, and the thing that comes back to me more and more, the more history I read, is how unusual and how fragile the modern world is.
We are not the norm. This is weird. And that’s a cause in some ways for great optimism, and if things do stagnate, they’ll stagnate with living standards that most of our ancestors would have viewed as almost miraculous. But I think an awareness of how anomalous it is to live in a literate and democratic society can be quite, I don’t know, maybe chastening isn’t the word, but salutary perhaps.
The Impact of AI
OLIVER: Now, AI is bringing a huge amount of writing into the world. Some of it’s slop, but some of it’s going to be quite good, and it’s going to get better. Is there a future in which the overall balance is quite different but is either sufficient to sustain democracy or produce something, you know, better?
MARRIOTT: Yes, I thought there’s an interesting point that you made in your piece. I’ve seen Dan Williams make the same argument, that the biases of—I guess is what you’re referring to, that we know the biases of artificial intelligence machines are basically Enlightenment liberal. AI is basically a centrist dad when you quiz it about politics.
Yes, I think that’s definitely a cause for optimism. I think that talking to AI through text about politics is probably a minority experience of artificial intelligence. I think most people’s political exposure to AI is much more likely to be image-based and is much more likely to be seeing slop memes on TikTok or Twitter or something like that.
And I think if you are using AI to write questions to ask it about policy, you’re probably in a very small minority. If you are seeing, I don’t know, racist AI-generated memes on Twitter or TikTok, you’re probably much closer to what the majority experience of the political implications of AI are. So that would be my take.
I don’t discount the fact that AI is often more reliable in its political takes than a lot of newspapers. I think that’s just a minority experience of AI for politics.
OLIVER: But the AI is going to be integrated into all sorts of things: in corporate life, in politics directly, in newspapers, and it’s going to be the major transmission mechanism to get the old liberal Enlightenment view from the old world into the new world. So could it be, in a way, a replacement for print culture?
MARRIOTT: Good question.
OLIVER: Obviously, a very imperfect substitute and very different thing, and the overall balance of good and bad will change significantly. But it might just be the thing that gets print into the future.
MARRIOTT: Maybe, but I guess my feeling would be that this move from a literate culture to a visual one has been in train for a long time now. And I think we worry a lot about AI writing, and we worry about university students getting AI to write their essays, and we view this deluge of artificially generated text as a major story of AI.
And I guess I would just come back to the previous point, which is that I think a lot of people’s major interactions with AI are probably more likely to be visual than they are to be text-based. And also, anybody trying to monetize AI for commercial purposes will find themselves susceptible to exactly the same commercial impulses that social media is susceptible to, that newspapers are susceptible to.
So although AI, if you talk to it as an individual user, may give you a sort of wet centrist dad on the one hand, on the other, “maybe we should be fiscally responsible” sort of answer. I think AI, as utilized by companies seeking to make a profit from it, will probably be drawn into the general direction of discourse that I think is now more than half a century old, which is more tribal, more emotional, more extreme. That would be my view.
OLIVER: Okay, so imagine, though, that we create a sort of James Marriott AI, and it takes all of you, all of your writing, all of your ideas, and it makes a little James Marriott avatar. And it puts you on TikTok or wherever it is that people are going to be, and you are part of this visual, video-based world. Is there not a sort of sense in which the playing field can be…
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.commonreader.co.uk
Altri episodi di "The Common Reader"



Non perdere nemmeno un episodio di “The Common Reader”. Iscriviti all'app gratuita GetPodcast.








