Sandra Birchmore: Everyone's Getting Things Wrong

A 29-year police veteran and a 911 dispatcher break down the Matthew Farwell verdict in the Sandra Birchmore case: what the federal jury actually decided, what the verdict does and doesn't mean, and what the deadlock note really tells us.The jury told the judge it was deadlocked. The next day it came back guilty on both counts. We walk through the four elements prosecutors had to prove, the expert fight over the hyoid bone, the 29 minutes on the lobby camera, the unrecorded parking-lot interview, the dispatcher's warning that was never preserved, and what a hung jury would have meant.

Matthew Farwell is on trial in federal court in the death of Sandra Birchmore. Who actually exposed the misconduct inside the Stoughton Police Department, and what is some of the coverage getting wrong? A retired police commander and an active 911 dispatcher follow the testimony.Sandra Birchmore was 23, pregnant, and failed by people who should have protected her. That is the starting point. From there, Jon and Drew separate three agencies that get blurred together, test the word "corruption" against the testimony, and walk through the January 2021 call to Stoughton dispatch from the dispatcher's side of the console.

On March 8, 1994, dozens of people across western Michigan called 911 to report mysterious lights in the sky. What happened next would become one of the most extensively documented UFO sightings in American history.Near Holland, Michigan, police officer Jeffrey Velthouse responded to a UFO report—and witnessed strange lights himself. Meanwhile, National Weather Service meteorologist Jack Bushong began tracking unexplained radar returns over Lake Michigan, describing objects that appeared to hover, separate, and travel at extraordinary speeds.More than 60 reported emergency calls. Hundreds of witnesses. Police reports. Recorded 911 conversations. And a meteorologist whose observations would haunt him for decades.In this episode of Comm Center, we revisit the 1994 Michigan UFO sightings using eyewitness testimony, original emergency recordings, police accounts, and historical reporting.Was it an extraordinary aerial phenomenon, a radar anomaly, or something else entirely? And with so many witnesses and so much documentation, why didn't this incident change the world's perception of UFOs?Listen to the calls. Examine the evidence. Decide for yourself.

The Matthew Farwell murder trial is revealing a deeply disturbing picture of what happened to Sandra Birchmore—and the evidence suggests this case may be even worse than we originally believed.What began as troubling allegations involving a young woman and several Massachusetts police officers has become an extraordinary federal criminal case raising serious questions about misconduct, abuse of authority, institutional accountability, and the circumstances surrounding Birchmore's death.In this episode, we examine the evidence and testimony presented in federal court, separating early accusations and speculation from what has now entered the official trial record.

For months, the death of Nolan Wells fueled accusations of murder, racism, and a law enforcement cover-up. While Mississippi District Attorney Angel Myers McIlrath was legally constrained from revealing details of an active investigation, the public narrative continued to grow.Now, a Jackson County grand jury has unanimously declined to indict anyone, finding no credible evidence that Nolan's friends committed a crime. But Nolan's cause and manner of death remain undetermined.In this episode of The Comm Center, Drew Breasy and Jon examine the district attorney's explosive public statement, her allegations that Ben Crump's legal team failed to cooperate fully and allowed misinformation to spread, and the correspondence that reveals a more complicated dispute over evidence and cellphone access.We ask some uncomfortable questions: Did confidentiality leave public safety institutions defenseless against false accusations? Did social media personalities exploit a family's tragedy to inflame racial tensions? And where are the loudest voices now that the grand jury's findings challenge their allegations?We also examine the emerging defamation lawsuits, the evidence the grand jury actually considered, and the critical questions about Nolan Wells' death that remain unanswered.The grand jury has spoken. But will those who made the accusations take responsibility for what they said?

Caleb Flynn was sentenced October 5, and the judge didn't hold back. But importantly, Caleb Flynn isn't simply locked away and the key thrown away-- the judge deliberately held him highly accountable for all his crimes, and the complex sentencing reflects it. Watch Drew break down exactly how hard Caleb Flynn was sentenced for the murder of his wife Ashley Flynn.Andrew Baxter (Drew Breasy) is a retired Police Commander with 29 years in law enforcement including narcotics, criminal intelligence, and 911 center administration. Jon is an active 911 Dispatcher and certified crisis negotiator with 11+ years on the line. Every good true crime story starts with a 911 call — we start there too.

A real 911 dispatcher asks is this a fake 911 call?A motion light snaps on. His dog was recently killed. Then he sees something nearly 7 feet tall walking upright through his yard—and it’s looking right at him.We break down the infamous Kitsap Bigfoot 911 call, what the terrified caller actually reported, what happened when police were called, and the decades of claims that followed.Was it a prowler? A bear? A hoax? Or did this man really call 911 after seeing Bigfoot outside his home?

The case against Caleb Flynn came down to one final showdown.Prosecutors Matthew Joseph and Paul Watkins and defense attorney Patrick Mulligan duel over the evidence: Caleb knew Ashley had been shot twice—but how? Where did the missing 9mm go? What do we make of the confusing DNA results? And what did Caleb mean when he texted that February 16 would be a day he’d “never forget”?Authentic Cop Drew brings 29 years of law-enforcement experience, while Actual 911 Dispatcher Jon breaks down the closing arguments, the strongest and weakest moments from both sides—and the evidence the jury ultimately had to weigh.Then the case went to the jury.They needed only about two hours to decide Caleb Flynn’s fate.

On Day 1 of testimony in the Caleb Flynn trial, the jury heard the 911 call, watched body camera video from inside the Flynn home, and heard the first officer on scene explain why his own camera wasn't recording.A retired police commander (29 years) and an active 911 dispatcher break down the witnesses who do the jobs we do: the 911 center director who authenticated the call, Sgt. Corey Rismiller, the supervisor who beat his own squad to the scene, and Officer Alexandra Giampapa, whose Chicago experience made her the most seasoned officer in the house.

In the Caleb Flynn case, we got to see a phenomenon in human communication displayed with poignance and subtlety from the witness stand.Jill Smith is told her daughter is dead. A father is told his daughter has been murdered. Both need to hear it twice. What that moment teaches us about the people answering 911.