Why Only 3% of Sales Managers Are Effective — and Why Role-Play Is the Missing Piece with Derek Baer
Derek Baer of Kurlan & Associates is back with Ed Marsh for another unscripted sales-topics conversation on the Industrial Growth Institute Podcast. This time they unpack three things industrial sales leaders constantly mix together: sales methodology, sales process, and qualification frameworks — and why a team can be running Challenger, SPIN, Sandler, Gap Selling, or BANT and still have a pipeline full of fabricated close dates.Ed and Derek start with the difference between how a conversation should sound and the checkpoints that prove a deal is actually moving. They look at why "When are you hoping this will be done?" produces a stack of December 31st opportunities, why leading with budget before you understand the buyer's needs makes a realistic number almost impossible, and why an ROI that doesn't touch a compelling reason is just math. Derek's examples are pointed: a $2 million problem that wouldn't be worth a minute of Jeff Bezos's time, a 20-year-old microwave with a broken handle he doesn't care about, and a 2019 Jeep Wrangler owner who is not buying a Tesla because the gas-savings spreadsheet looks good.Then they turn to sales management. Derek says only 3% of the sales managers he meets are good, and the two things that take the rest down are coaching and accountability. His standard is blunt: coaching without role-play isn't coaching, and if you can't navigate an uncomfortable conversation in practice, that's probably why you're struggling to sell. Along the way they cover what actually makes fractional sales management work, why a weak full-time manager with 40 hours isn't more valuable, and Derek's rule of thumb that a good full-time manager should have about six reps. They close on a question they'll pick up next time: Why are people resistant to getting help with sales?In This Episode, We Discuss:[00:00] — Only 3% of sales managers are effective: In the cold open, Derek names the two things that take most managers down — coaching and accountability — and says that if you can't role-play, that's probably why you're struggling to sell.[00:44] — Welcome back: Ed Marsh opens another unscripted sales-topics session with Derek Baer and asks whether anything earth-shattering has happened in sales training since they last talked.[01:26] — Methodology is not process: Derek defines methodology as the conversations, questions, and how you navigate from A to Z. Ed separates that from process: the checkpoints, milestones, and information you have to collect. The best methodology, Derek says, is the one that actually gets you results.[04:26] — The usual names, and the missing map: Ed runs through Challenger, SPIN, Sandler, Miller Heiman, and Baseline Selling. Derek says you don't need an off-the-shelf name, but you do need to train new reps on objections, resistance, and turning pushback into a question. His first thread: companies often hand reps a methodology or a book (Gap Selling, Straight Line Selling) without a process to run it on, and that's where deals get stuck.[05:55] — The December 31st close-date trap: Everyone requires an agreed close date, but if the methodology is weak, it gets asked as "When are you hoping this will be done?" That has nothing to do with urgency or a compelling reason, so pipelines fill up with dates that don't change the buyer's business on January 1st.[07:00] — Where BANT gets dangerous: Budget, Authority, Need, and Timeline are milestones, not a script. Derek warns that unseasoned reps who try to establish budget before they understand the person — or why the person would change — can't get a realistic number, because the buyer can't quantify it either.[08:10] — Frameworks vs. a full methodology: Ed treats MedPIC (or MedPIC Plus) as a qualification framework that plugs into a methodology, not a complete one. Derek says Gap Selling is excellent for discovery, Challenger is incomplete on presenting and closing, and the move is to learn them all, keep what works, and build something that covers the entire process. Different reps on the same team can use different methodologies — if they have the courage to ask, "What happens if you don't have a solution in place by then?"[10:41] — Does Baseline Selling cover the whole sale?: Ed asks whether Dave Kurlan is right that Baseline integrates process and methodology across the full sale. Derek, admitting he's biased, says yes — and in an enterprise deal you restart the process with each new decision maker until you know why each one would be motivated to change. Check every milestone and you'll know with almost 100% certainty whether the deal moves, or you'll exit early.[12:09] — Quantitative vs. qualitative qualification: December 31st is a number. The qualitative questions are the ones that make a forecast trustworthy: How does the business fail on January 1st if this isn't done? Who is fighting to stack-rank their project ahead of yours in capital approval? What happens to your objectives if the date slips?[13:38] — Money tolerance, microwaves, and a Jeep vs. a Tesla: Training often goes "in one ear and out the other" until enough deals fail. Derek explains why a salesperson's money tolerance can be wildly different from the buyer's: a $2 million problem may lose to a $10 million one, and it wouldn't be worth a minute of Jeff Bezos's time. His broken microwave handle means nothing to him, and a 2019 Jeep Wrangler owner is not buying a Tesla because the gas-savings and horsepower pitch looks good on a spreadsheet.[16:40] — The JOLT Effect, perceived risk, and the screw hole: Ed points to The JOLT Effect and why a 20-minute Costco swap feels easy while a built-in install that needs a permit and a 12-hour window does not. Buyers remember "it'll pay for itself in 17 hours" pitches they were still fighting two years later, and a compelling ROI is irrelevant if an edict sends all available money to cybersecurity. Derek cites Dennis Connolly: "I asked for a screw hole." Ed's reminder: nobody wants the drill bit. They want the picture hung so they can get on with their day.[19:59] — Can fractional sales management actually work?: Derek says yes — with no hard cap on team size or duration if the manager is good. A weak full-time manager who is available 40 hours a week is still not valuable. His rule of thumb for a full-time span of control is six reps (it can be 8–10 if the coaching is real): four days a week, at least 30 minutes a person, plus pre-call strategy, post-call debriefs, and daily huddles, not just check-ins. He puts training at once every two weeks (or weekly); it becomes fractional when the team reports to him, starting around five hours a week on the low end. A player-coach who sells half-time and manages half-time is, if they're good, functionally a 50% fractional.[25:43] — Coaching without role-play isn't coaching: Ed asks the 3% question in full. Derek again names coaching and accountability, and adds that accountability without positive motivation fails too. The "coaching" he hears most often is "What do you need to get this deal closed?" and "Try telling them this." There is almost no role-play, and he has yet to meet a manager who does it effectively.[28:00] — Why managers avoid the work: Derek compares a day of four training calls to being in the middle of a jiu-jitsu or MMA circle, with everyone trying to debunk h...