Father and Joe podcast

Father and Joe E486: Why AI Doesn't Have "The Twinge" — Conscience, Stem Cells, and the Church's Claim on Every Industry

0:00
19:42
Manda indietro di 15 secondi
Manda avanti di 15 secondi

Building on last episode's real estate cliffhanger, Joe Rockey and Father Boniface Hicks zoom out to the bigger claim underneath it: that the Church has something true to say inside every industry, not just the ones with "church" in the name. The conversation runs through the embryonic-versus-adult stem cell story as living proof of ethical boundaries paying off decades later, then lands on what might be the most practical idea in the episode — the "twinge," the gut-level moral intuition every person has and AI simply doesn't.

Key Ideas:

  • Every industry — AI, accounting, nonprofit work, medicine — ultimately reduces to relationships, and relationships are exactly the terrain the Church has the deepest, oldest body of tested wisdom on, independent of whether someone brings faith to the table or just reason.
  • The stem cell story is the clearest proof point: the Church held the ethical line against embryonic stem cell research (which required destroying a human embryo) even while the science looked unstoppable — and adult, then reverse-engineered pluripotent, stem cells ended up outperforming it anyway, without the moral cost.
  • "Now is the most important second ever" is a pressure marketing and human nature both apply — but major decisions call for patience with the process, not grabbing the bird in hand because the deadline feels urgent.
  • There are two different "twinges" worth telling apart: a prudential twinge (this isn't going to produce as good an outcome as it could) and a conscience twinge (this is actually wrong) — and sorting out which one you're feeling, ideally with a priest or someone outside your own head, is the actual skill.
  • AI runs purely on reason and the rules it's given — it has no conscience, no "elephant" (borrowing Jonathan Haidt's image of intuition as the elephant and reason as its small rider) telling it something is unconscionable before any rule says so. That gap is also why Father Boniface thinks the Church's teaching on AI and the human person may be as urgent now as its teaching on the human body was for John Paul II's generation.

Links & References: None explicitly referenced with a clear official/source link in this episode.

If this helped, please leave a review or share this episode with a friend.
 Questions or thoughts? Email [email protected].

Transcription:
 Hello and welcome to another episode of Father and Joe. I am Joe Rockey here with Father Boniface Hicks. And Father, I think we hit upon something that was really important in the last episode. Don't have to re-go through everything that my business was on the micro level, but on the macro level, you talked about how there are divides that people put up that say, this is your category — you're the church guy, I talk to you for confession and baptism, you're the banker, I talk to you on any money, you're this, you're that, I talk to you whenever you do that.

And as an overarching thing, what I think that I have found — and this is simultaneously life and business observations — is that when that situation occurs, regardless of what it is, you know, you're the AI company, you figure out how to give me the answers I want to have, I will figure out this, that, or the other, you know, I'm the one who makes sure the economics work — anytime there's that type of industrial compartmentalization, normally the best answers, even within the peak of that expertise, can be influenced and enhanced from someone else's. And that's one of the things that I really believe in — that someone who's really good at accounting can give insight to an AI company and go, if you would just do it this way, you'd have a better result, something could work better. Or for a nonprofit that only works with taking care of blood research, hearing a different perspective, a different way of running something, really can help it enhance. And it goes, in my opinion, as deep as that industry does — which is the calling for, quote-unquote, your industry, Father, because the faith is the deepest wealth of information, experiences, testing, et cetera, that you could ever possibly want. Yes, they might not have developed the Pythagorean theorem — I don't even know if I said that right — for geometry or engineering, but everything that all of our industries do, regardless of what they are, boils down into a relationship, in one way or another — you're selling something, you're providing a service, or you're hiring someone — all of those eventually include relationships, and therefore your industry needs this connection. And I want to point out that starting point, that learning from the church is much more important in the macro, other parts of your business. It's why I did the last episode that we did, it's why I have found so much growth in my business, implementing things that you have taught me. And I want to give the floor to that point.

Yeah, one way to say it is that the church, in her teaching, so in her perfection, is an expert in humanity. And of course humanity is involved in all of these things — that's the ultimate takeaway from these things, you can raise money, I suppose, in a vacuum, but not sure what that does for you. So humanity is integral to everything, and the pathways for the thriving of humanity, at the level of the individual as well as the level of the family, which is the building block for society — the church, in her philosophy, which would be accessible to everybody without the additional light of faith, but through reason unaided by faith, the church understands in her philosophy, which is always purified and perfected by the light of faith. And so that deep understanding is there, the principles and history are there — we've drawn so many times from the Church Fathers, or the elements of Greek philosophy that were brought in by the Church Fathers, or the doctors of the church, like Saint Thomas Aquinas, or more recent philosophers and theologians, like John Paul II or Edith Stein. In any event, the church has held as treasures this font of wisdom that comes ultimately from God, that comes through the divinely inspired Scriptures, and ultimately the word made flesh, and is entrusted to the hierarchy of the church, or teaching office, and then comes to us through a variety of means.

So that's kind of what we're tapping into — that's going to be the ethical realm, in terms of perhaps what not to do, where the boundaries are, that if you cross these boundaries, they're going to be problematic. And that's also going to be in the personal realm — what leads to the thriving of the human person, and what does that person need. We've talked about emotions and virtues, the habits of success, and the goals that we're striving for, that lead to our thriving. So that's going to be a necessary element of everything else. And so the church has something to say about everything, in that sense — what is the best business practice, what is the perfect governmental model? There's prudential judgment, and there are different times and places for that, and there are other experts who work that out, but the church will say, well, it's not going to be over here. And I love the example of stem cell research, in which there was initially a lot of hope around embryonic stem cells, which require the destruction of a human person, a fetus, to extract those embryonic stem cells — and the dream was, well, they can turn into anything, and so they could reproduce any kind of organ or human tissue. And the church said, no, you can't ever destroy a human being, however young, for any reason, you can't do it. And there was a lot of fighting against that, and the scientific community talked about how limited things are, you know, the church has this role and just goes against it....


Altri episodi di "Father and Joe"