Faith in Process podcast

When You Are Disappointed With God

0:00
35:06
Manda indietro di 15 secondi
Manda avanti di 15 secondi

"I consider myself a disappointed child of God." Rev. Jill Keyser Speicher wrote those words in a short personal essay in the January/February 2026 issue of Messenger, the magazine of the Church of the Brethren. Not many people say that sentence out loud in church. Jill says it, and then she says the rest of it: she is also a precious child of God.

Jill is a retired Church of the Brethren chaplain who served in hospice, hospitals, and retirement communities. She talks with Pastor Harry Jarrett about the two great disappointments of her life: the children she and her husband, Tim, longed for and never had, and a hip replacement that never healed, after twelve surgeries, which left her using a wheelchair. She tells about the innocent faith of her childhood, the "reward mentality" she had to let go of, and why she does not believe that everything happens for a reason. Harry names what he hears in her story: not a gospel of prosperity, but a gospel of presence.

Then the room joins in. Class members ask about young women who no longer see motherhood as an expectation, about what her lowest point looked like and how she found her way back to God, and whether her picture of God changed. Jill describes a God who is not up in the clouds but down here, walking beside us. Harry connects her words to Jesus on the cross, and Jill offers a practice that helped her: read the psalms of lament, then write your own, because God can take it.

This conversation was recorded in Pastor Harry's Sunday school class at Pleasant Valley Church of the Brethren in Weyers Cave, Virginia, with questions from the people gathered there. Produced by Grayson Preece.

Run of show:

0:00 Grayson's welcome

0:27 Harry welcomes the room and introduces Jill

2:04 Jill's Messenger essay, "A Disappointed Child of God"

3:18 A milestone birthday and two great disappointments

4:23 Life in a wheelchair at Brethren Village

5:13 "I am a precious child of God"

5:51 Jill's childhood faith

7:40 Night school, nonprofits, and the American Cancer Society

8:30 Longing for a child

8:54 Wounded souls and the call to chaplaincy

9:29 What are we teaching children about blessing?

11:44 "Everything happens for a reason"? Jill does not believe it

12:09 Seek first the kingdom, and when God says no

12:54 Women in leadership, and the patient who wanted a male chaplain

14:13 A gospel of presence, not prosperity

14:59 Hebrews 11, Hannah, Elizabeth, and the Bible's happy endings

15:53 Open and relational theology, and what seminary did to the Bible stories

17:03 Naming disappointment out loud

18:15 How it felt to publish something so vulnerable

18:26 Angry at God, and realizing it is a relationship

19:13 From a God who micromanages to a God who walks beside us

20:41 "Our very own Joni Eareckson Tada" and questions from the room

21:32 From the room: young women and the choice to have children

23:46 From the room: the lowest point, and the way back to God

25:13 Punishment, hidden sin, and the reward mentality

26:41 Pat answers, "God is good all the time," and some ridiculous advice

27:35 Millard Driver asks: did your idea of God change?

28:35 Not up in the clouds, but down here walking with us

29:21 Where to find the article

29:40 Do you still consider yourself a disappointed child of God?

30:22 Jesus on the cross, a disappointed child of God

31:14 Psalms of lament, and writing your own

31:49 Giving people words: Psalms and Lamentations

32:35 Closing words: writing to help others

34:09 We all grow through suffering

34:39 Thanks for listening

Faith in Process on Substack



This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit pastorharryjarrett.substack.com/subscribe

Altri episodi di "Faith in Process"