
Why do we trust people who are clearly lying to us about who they are?
I want to start with that question because it is stranger than it first appears, and I do not think we examine it nearly often enough. Think about the figures we turn to for guidance about how to live. The wellness guru with the serene voice and the immaculate kitchen. The motivational speaker who strides across a stage radiating certainty. The influencer whose every morning is a sunlit ritual of cold plunges and gratitude journaling. We hand these people our attention, our money, and most importantly our trust, and we do it knowing, on some level we rarely admit, that the image is constructed. We know nobody is actually like that. And we trust them anyway. In fact, we often trust them more precisely because they appear flawless. The polish is not a warning sign to us. It is the credential.
I want to spend real time with you today unpacking why that is, why it fails us so reliably, and what an honest alternative actually looks like. And I want to be clear from the very first minute about where I am standing while I talk to you. I am not standing above you. I am flawed, deeply and permanently, in ways I have made peace with and ways I am still wrestling with. I am not a man who fixed himself and is now reporting back from the summit. There is no summit. And I think the fact that I am willing to say that out loud is the single most useful thing I can offer you, because it means we can finally have an honest conversation instead of a sales pitch.
So let us begin with the guru, and the mask.
There is a brilliant idea from the sociologist Erving Goffman that gives us the language for this. Goffman described social life as a kind of theater. Each of us has a frontstage, where we perform a curated version of ourselves for an audience, and a backstage, where we drop the performance and become messier, more tired, more real. You have a frontstage for your colleagues, a different one for your in-laws, maybe a different one again for strangers on the internet. This is not dishonesty exactly. It is human. We all do it. The trouble is what happens when someone builds an entire career, an entire identity, an entire income stream, out of letting you see only the frontstage and convincing you it is the whole house. The guru's perfection is not a lie they tell once. It is a stage they never step off, at least not where you can see.
And here is why we fall for it. There is a part of us, an old and frightened part, that desperately wants to believe that someone, somewhere, has figured it out. That the chaos and uncertainty of being a person is solvable, that there is a finished state of having it together, and that if we just follow the right person closely enough, we can get there too. The flawless guru is not really selling a morning routine. They are selling the promise that the finish line exists. And we buy it, again and again, because the alternative, that there is no finish line, that everyone is improvising, that even the calm ones are scared, is genuinely frightening to sit with.
But sit with it we must, because that frightening idea happens to be the truth, and the truth is where everything good starts.
Let me introduce the central villain of this episode, the belief I most want you to question. I call it the fixed self. The fixed self is the imagined, completed version of you that lives somewhere in the future. It is the you who has finally beaten procrastination, the you who is patient with your children, the you who does not get jealous, does not overeat, does not say the cruel thing, does not lie awake replaying conversations from a decade ago. We carry this person around in our heads as a kind of standard, and we measure our daily, stumbling, actual selves against them, and we always come up short. The fixed self is always patient. You snapped this morning. The fixed self is disciplined. You are tired and you skipped the gym again. The gap between the real you and the fixed self is where an enormous amount of human suffering quietly lives.
And here is what I want you to understand about that person. They are not a goal you are failing to reach. They are a fiction you have been recruited into believing. There is no static, finished, fixed version of a human being. We are not statues waiting to be carved into our final form. We are rivers. We are always moving, always changing, never the same from one year to the next, and the idea that you will one day arrive at a permanent, sorted, completed self is not just unrealistic, it is a category error. It misunderstands what a person fundamentally is. You will never be finished. Not because you have failed, but because finished is not a thing that people get to be.
Now, I can feel the objection forming, because I would feel it too. If there is no fixed self to aim for, if I will never be finished, then what is the point of trying to improve at all? Why not just give up, lie on the couch, and accept whatever I happen to be?
This is the exact moment where most thinking about this topic goes wrong, and it goes wrong in two opposite directions, and I want to walk you carefully between them.
The first wrong direction is toxic positivity. This is the response that says, since there is no fixed self and you are always changing, just love yourself exactly as you are, every flaw is beautiful, never apologize, you are perfect. This sounds generous. It is actually a quiet form of cruelty, because it asks you to stop looking at the things in your life that genuinely need to be looked at. If you have a habit that is hurting the people you love, "you're perfect just as you are" is not encouragement. It is permission to keep hurting them. Toxic positivity is avoidance dressed in a sunny outfit. It uses the language of self-acceptance to help you escape the hard, necessary work of self-honesty. And the tell is always the same: real growth feels like a difficult conversation with yourself, while toxic positivity feels like a warm bath that asks nothing of you and changes nothing.
The second wrong direction is the one toxic positivity is overcorrecting against, and it is just as destructive. This is the cult of relentless self-improvement, the belief that you are a project to be optimized, a broken thing to be fixed, and that the way to fix yourself is through harsh, constant self-criticism. This is the inner prosecutor, the voice that calls you lazy, pathetic, hopeless, the voice that treats contempt as motivation. And here is the thing that took me far too long to learn: that voice does not work. It has never worked. Decades of psychological research point in the same direction, that self-criticism does not produce lasting change. It produces shame, and shame produces hiding, and hiding is the opposite of the honest look you need in order to grow.
So we have to find the narrow path between these two ditches. Between "you're already perfect, don't look" and "you're broken, hate yourself into fixing it." And the name of that narrow path, the thing almost nobody teaches because it is harder to package, is honest self-acceptance.
Let me bring in Carl Rogers again, because he stated this better than I ever could. Rogers, one of the most influential psychologists of the twentieth century, said that the curious paradox is that when he accepted himself just as he was, then he could change. I want to slow all the way down on this, because it is the hinge that the entire series turns on, and it sounds backwards the first time you hear it.
We believe, almost universally, that the path to change runs through rejection. I must reject this flaw, despise it, refuse to accept it, and that rejection will somehow burn it away. Rogers found the reverse. That as long as you are at war with a part of yourself, frantically denying it, performing its opposite, you cannot actually change it, because you cannot get close enough to it to understand it. You are too busy hiding it from yourself. It is only when you stop the war, when you say, "Yes, this is here, this is part of me, I am not going to pretend it is not," that you can finally turn toward it with clear eyes and ask the real questions. Where did this come from? What is it trying to protect me from? What does it cost me? What would it take to do differently next time? Acceptance is not the end of change. Acceptance is the precondition for it. You cannot transform what you will not first admit.
And I need to draw the cleanest possible line here, because this is where people get nervous. Acceptance is not approval. To accept that you have a tendency toward jealousy is not to approve of jealousy or to decide you will let it run your relationships. It is simply to stop pretending it is not there. Approval says, "This is fine, leave it alone." Acceptance says, "This is real, let us look at it honestly." One is a verdict. The other is an invitation. Toxic positivity offers approval and calls it growth. What I am offering you is acceptance, which is harder, and is the only thing that actually leads anywhere.
Let me make this concrete with something that lives in almost every household. Picture a parent who grew up being told that anger was unacceptable, that good people are always calm. So they spend their whole adult life performing calm, presenting a serene frontstage, while backstage the anger they refuse to acknowledge leaks out sideways, in sarcasm, in cold silences, in a tightness their children can feel but cannot name. Because the parent will not accept that the anger exists, they can never actually work with it. It controls them precisely because they deny it. Now picture the same parent finally saying, out loud, even just to themselves, "I have a lot of anger, and I have been pretending I do not, and that pretending is hurting my kids." That sentence is not a failure. It is the first honest moment in decades, and it is the only possible starting point for things to get better. The flaw they could not bear to look at was the flaw that ran their life from the shadows.
That word, shadow, brings me to an idea from Carl Jung that I find enormously useful, and I will keep it simple. Jung used the word shadow to describe all the parts of ourselves that we have disowned, the traits we have decided are unacceptable and pushed down into the dark where we do not have to see them. The anger we are not supposed to feel. The selfishness, the envy, the neediness, the parts that do not fit the image we present. The trouble is that pushing something into the shadow does not get rid of it. It just removes it from our control. The parts of yourself you refuse to acknowledge do not disappear. They run the show from backstage, and they tend to leak out at the worst possible moments. Jung's insight was that growth does not come from killing the shadow, which is impossible, but from integration, from bringing those disowned parts back into the light, looking at them, and consciously deciding how to hold them. You do not become whole by amputating the parts you dislike. You become whole by owning all of it.
Now let me get into the machinery of why self-criticism fails, because I do not want you to take it on faith. I want you to understand it well enough to catch it in your own head.
When you make a mistake, you have a fork in the road, and which way you turn matters more than almost anything else about your growth. The fork is between guilt and shame. These two words get used interchangeably, but they are profoundly different, and the difference decides your whole trajectory. Guilt says, "I did a bad thing." Shame says, "I am a bad thing." Guilt is about behavior, and behavior can be changed, apologized for, repaired, done differently tomorrow. Shame is about identity, and identity feels permanent, so shame offers you no way forward. There is nothing to do with "I am bad" except hide it. The research here is remarkably consistent. People who respond to mistakes with guilt tend to repair and improve. People who respond with shame tend to deny, blame others, and repeat the very behavior they are ashamed of, because shame is so painful that the mind's first priority becomes escaping the feeling rather than fixing the cause.
This is why the harsh inner critic is not your ally. It feels like discipline. It feels like the responsible, rigorous part of you that refuses to let you off easy. But what it actually does is convert every guilt, every workable "I did a bad thing," into shame, an unworkable "I am a bad thing," and shame sends you straight into hiding and avoidance and repetition. The cruelest irony of self-criticism is that it keeps you stuck in the exact patterns it claims to be fighting. The voice that says "you always do this, you never learn, what is wrong with you" is not motivating you. It is guaranteeing the next failure by making the honest look unbearable.
So what replaces it? Not the warm bath of toxic positivity. The answer is self-compassion, and I want to be precise about this because the term gets softened into mush. The psychologist Kristin Neff has spent her career researching this, and she draws a sharp distinction between self-compassion and self-esteem that I find genuinely clarifying. Self-esteem is about evaluating yourself positively, deciding you are good, special, above average. The problem is that self-esteem requires constant success to maintain, it collapses the moment you fail, and it often depends on being better than other people. Self-compassion asks none of that. Self-compassion is simply the willingness to treat yourself, when you fail, with the same basic kindness you would offer a good friend who failed. Not "you're amazing, you did nothing wrong." A real friend does not say that. A real friend says, "That was a genuine mistake, it matters, and you are still a person worth caring about, so let us figure out what to do next." That combination, honesty about the failure plus warmth toward the person, is the engine. It keeps you in the room. It lets you look at the flaw clearly because looking is no longer unbearable. Self-compassion is not soft. It is the most practical tool for change I know.
Let me give you an example that I think a lot of people will recognize, because it lives in the gym, in diets, in every attempt at a new habit. You decide to change something. You do well for a week. Then one day you slip. You eat the thing, skip the workout, break the streak. Now watch the fork. If your inner voice is a prosecutor, it says, "Of course you failed, you have no discipline, you always do this, why even bother." And what happens next is almost mechanical. The shame is so unpleasant that you reach for relief, which is usually the very behavior you were trying to change, and now you have not only slipped but confirmed the story that you are a failure, and you quit entirely. The slip became a collapse, not because of the slip, but because of the prosecutor. Now run it the other way. You slip, and the voice says, "Okay, that happened. One day. It does not erase the week. Tomorrow you are back." No shame, no collapse, no quitting. The difference between those two people is not willpower. It is which voice they let narrate the mistake.
I want to talk about another mechanism, because it explains so much of why we cling to the mask in the first place. It is called cognitive dissonance. This is the deep discomfort we feel when our actions and our self-image do not match. If you think of yourself as honest and you catch yourself lying, that gap produces real psychological pain, and the mind will do almost anything to close it. The healthy way to close it is to change the behavior, to bring your actions in line with your values. But that is hard. So the mind often takes the lazy route instead, which is to rationalize, to deny, to reinterpret the lie as not really a lie, to protect the image at the cost of the truth. This is why honest self-examination is so rare and so uncomfortable. Every flaw you look at directly threatens the flattering story you tell about yourself, and your mind is wired to defend that story. Understanding this does not make it easy, but it does explain the resistance you feel when you try to look honestly at yourself, and it lets you recognize that resistance for what it is rather than mistaking it for proof that everything is fine.
Closely related is projection, one of the oldest ideas in psychology and one of the most useful in daily life. Projection is when we take a trait we cannot stand in ourselves, refuse to acknowledge it, and then see it everywhere in other people, where it enrages us. The person who cannot admit their own selfishness is often the one most furious about everyone else's selfishness. The trait we attack most violently in others is frequently the one we are most desperate not to see in ourselves. This is worth knowing not so you can diagnose your friends, which is a terrible idea, but so you can use your own irritation as information. The next time someone's flaw makes you disproportionately angry, out of all proportion to the actual offense, it is worth quietly asking whether you are looking at a mirror. Some of my own most useful self-discoveries started as complaints about other people.
So let me start pulling this together into something you can actually do, because I refuse to leave you with insight and no practice.
The foundational practice of this entire series is what I call the honest inventory. It is exactly what it sounds like, and it is harder than it sounds. It is the willingness to sit down and look, clearly and without flinching, at your own shortcomings, the persistent ones, the embarrassing ones, the ones you have been performing your way around for years. But, and this is the part that makes it survivable rather than devastating, you do it with self-compassion riding alongside honesty the entire time. Honesty alone turns the inventory into a self-attack, and you will not survive it, you will close the notebook and never open it again. Compassion alone turns it into a feel-good exercise that changes nothing. You need both, in the same room, at the same time. The voice you are aiming for is the voice of a wise, loving friend who is also unwilling to lie to you. Honest enough to name the real thing. Warm enough that you can bear to hear it.
Here is how I would structure it. Name the flaw plainly, using "I have a tendency to" rather than "I am." Notice the difference. "I am a coward" is shame, it is identity, it is a dead end. "I have a tendency to avoid hard conversations" is guilt, it is behavior, and behavior has a door you can walk through. Then get curious instead of condemnatory. Where did this come from? What is it protecting you from? Avoidance usually protects us from the fear of conflict or rejection, and that fear usually has a history. You are not looking to excuse the flaw by understanding its origin. You are looking to understand it well enough to work with it, because a flaw you understand is a flaw you can finally do something about, while a flaw you only hate stays exactly where it is.
Then there is the small linguistic tool I mentioned in the short version, and it is worth saying again because it does so much work for one word. The word is "and," and it is the replacement for the word "but" in how you talk about your own character. "But" forces a verdict. "I am generous, but I was stingy yesterday" makes you choose which one is the real you, and you will usually choose the one that confirms whatever you already believe. "And" refuses the verdict and holds the contradiction. "I am a generous person, and I was stingy yesterday, and I want to understand why." Now you are not a saint or a hypocrite. You are a whole, complicated human being who can hold two true things at once, which is the only honest way to hold a self. Practice this. It sounds tiny. It rewires something fundamental.
Another practice, and this one takes courage, is to name a flaw out loud to a trusted person. Not a public confession, not performance, just one real human being you trust, to whom you say a true thing about yourself that you would normally hide. Something happens when a flaw leaves the sealed chamber of your own head and enters the air between you and another person. It shrinks. The shame it was feeding on, which lives entirely in secrecy, loses its food source. Shame cannot survive being spoken to someone who responds with warmth instead of judgment. This is, incidentally, the entire mechanism behind why confession, in religious and secular forms alike, has helped people for thousands of years. Not the punishment. The being seen, fully, and not rejected for it.
And there is one more idea I want to leave you with, an old one, because it reframes the whole relationship with your own imperfection. The Stoics had a phrase, amor fati, which means love of one's fate. It is the practice of not merely tolerating the reality of your life, including your own flawed nature, but embracing it as the actual material you have been given to work with. You are not going to be handed a different self, a flawless self, a fixed self. This is the one you get. The flawed, contradictory, beautifully imperfect human being reading or hearing these words right now is the only raw material you will ever have. You can spend your life resenting that and waiting for the upgrade that is never coming, or you can love the material you have, flaws and all, and build something honest out of it. The second path is the only one that goes anywhere.
Let me return to where we started, to the guru with the serene voice and the immaculate kitchen, because I want to close the loop honestly. I am not telling you that person is your enemy. I am telling you that their mask is. The frontstage they never leave is teaching you, with every perfect frame, that your backstage is shameful, that the gap between your messy reality and their polished image is a personal failing rather than the universal condition of being human. And the most freeing thing I can tell you, the thing this whole series is built on, is that there is no one on the other side of that gap. The flawless self does not exist. Not in them, not in me, not in anyone. We are all backstage, all the time, doing our best, getting it wrong, getting it a little less wrong tomorrow.
So here is my actual offer, and it is the opposite of the guru's. I will not pretend to be fixed, because I am not, and neither are you, and neither is anyone who has ever lived. What I will do is stand beside you, openly flawed, and refuse to look away from the truth, and ask you to do the same. Not so you can finally become perfect. So you can stop wasting your one life chasing a person who does not exist, and start living honestly as the imperfect, contradictory, still-growing human being you actually are. That is not a lesser goal than perfection. It is a far braver one. Perfection is a fantasy that asks nothing real of you. Honesty asks for everything, and gives back a life you can actually stand inside.
Before we end, sit with these questions, and give them more than a passing thought, because they are the real work.
What flaw have you been performing your way around for so long that you have nearly convinced yourself it is not there? When you fail, listen to the voice that narrates it: is it a coach or a prosecutor, and where did that voice learn to speak to you that way? Is there a difference, in your life, between the parts of yourself you accept and the parts you secretly hope to amputate, and what would change if you stopped trying to cut them out and started trying to understand them instead? And what would it actually feel like, in your body, to stop waiting to become a fixed and finished version of yourself, and to let your real, unfinished self live now?
To practice this week, do the honest inventory once, properly. Sit down, name one real, persistent flaw using "I have a tendency to," and write toward it with both honesty and warmth, the way a wise friend would. Then take one "but" sentence about your character and rewrite it with "and." And if you are brave, say one true thing about yourself, out loud, to one person you trust. That is the whole practice. It is small, and it is harder than it looks, and it is the foundation everything else in this series will be built on.
You do not need to be fixed to begin. You only need to be honest. Go be a little more honest than you were yesterday, and I will meet you there.
Altri episodi di "English Plus"



Non perdere nemmeno un episodio di “English Plus”. Iscriviti all'app gratuita GetPodcast.








