
Hosted by Phil Goff and Chris Finlayson, Cross Party Lines records one day early — the day after election night — for a timely debrief on a result that has raised more constitutional questions than it answered. With 400,000 specials still to count, no government formed, and an overhang of eleven seats producing a 131-seat parliament, the boys dig into the numbers, the seats, and the system itself.
Thanks to Frank Risk Management, the 100% Kiwi-owned Insurance Brokerage.
In this episode:
* The result, the overhang and the path that remains — On election night’s counting, the current coalition partners hold 67 seats in a 131-seat parliament — a narrow majority, but one built substantially on overhang. Labour sits on 36 seats to National’s 42, despite the two parties being separated by a matter of thousands in the party vote. TOP came in at six seats and finished the night trending upward. Phil outlines the path: Wairarapa at 139 votes, Hamilton West at 469, possibly Te Tai Tokerau going Green rather than Te Pāti Māori. If those seats flip and the specials favour the centre-left as they historically have, the overhang shrinks from 131 to 128 and the coalition’s majority disappears. Neither Hipkins nor Luxon conceded or claimed victory for a reason.
* Seat by seat: what happened and what it means — Banks Peninsula back to National as expected. The surprise was Nelson — a Green candidate took 3,000 votes off Labour’s Rachel Boyack and may have cost Labour the seat, raising the uncomfortable prospect of parties formally directing their supporters’ candidate votes to avoid splitting the progressive vote. Wellington Bays too close to call pending specials. Hutt South gone to Ginny Andersen — Phil says Chris Bishop was the cabinet minister who added most to parliamentary democracy. Wairarapa hanging on 139 votes, with Kieran McAnulty’s unique communication style gives Labour a real chance.
* The constitutional reckoning — is MMP broken? — An overhang of eleven is not a rounding error. It is a structural problem. Phil and Chris both agree a Justice Select Committee inquiry won’t cut it — the issues are too large, too important and too partisan for a committee dominated by the governing party. Helen Clark has called for a full independent inquiry, and both men support it. The questions are serious: should the number of electorate seats have stayed at 60 rather than growing to 70, to avoid this overhang phenomenon? Should parliament expand to 140 seats to create more list places? Is supplementary member — which both Phil and Chris privately prefer — a better system? And what happens to electoral finance when billionaires spend millions to engineer an outcome? Chris notes that Jim Bolger, who implemented MMP, and Ken Keith, one of its architects, are now buried next to each other and Jocelyn Keith says the two of them will be able to discuss MMP into eternity.
Cross Party Lines exists to lift political literacy and create space for calm, good-faith political conversation. New episodes every Tuesday. If you value thoughtful debate, follow the podcast and share it with someone who might too.
📋 400,000 special votes still to count. The result is not final. Watch this space.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit crosspartylines.substack.com
Altri episodi di "Cross Party Lines"



Non perdere nemmeno un episodio di “Cross Party Lines”. Iscriviti all'app gratuita GetPodcast.








