
How Pro Cycling Teams Are Testing Durability (& What We Can Learn)
Summary:
What is cycling durability, how do professional cycling teams measure it, and could it be more important than your FTP or VO2 max?
In this episode of the Road Cycling Academy Podcast, Cam Nicholls is joined by RCA coach and exercise physiologist Ben Treble to unpack emerging research into one of cycling's hottest performance topics: durability and fatigue resistance.
Fresh from the Science & Cycling Conference in Barcelona, Ben shares insights from unpublished data presented by Red Bull–BORA–hansgrohe, exploring how WorldTour teams are attempting to identify riders who can continue producing high power after thousands of kilojoules of work.
Because having a big FTP or VO2 max is one thing. Being able to produce that power after several hard hours in the saddle is something very different.
Ben explains how cycling durability can be measured by comparing fresh power with power produced after significant accumulated work, why elite riders can experience remarkably little power decay, and why some amateur cyclists may see substantially larger declines.
We also explore an emerging metric involving four-minute torque, which Red Bull–BORA–hansgrohe has investigated as a potential predictor of durability in younger elite riders.
But does the same relationship exist in recreational and Masters cyclists?
Ben has started analysing real-world data from Masters cyclists competing in UCI Gran Fondo events — and his preliminary findings don't necessarily match what is being seen in elite riders.
In this episode:
- What does "durability" actually mean in cycling?
- Why FTP alone doesn't tell the whole performance story
- How professional cycling teams test fatigue resistance
- Fresh vs fatigued five-minute power
- Why accumulated kilojoules matter
- How much power cyclists lose after several hours of riding
- The difference between FTP, VO2 max and durability
- Why WorldTour teams are investing heavily in durability
- How durability is being used for talent identification
- What the "compound score" is
- Four-minute torque and its potential relationship with durability
- Unpublished insights from Red Bull–BORA–hansgrohe
- Why elite cycling data may not translate directly to Masters cyclists
- Ben's preliminary analysis of Masters and UCI Gran Fondo riders
- What recreational cyclists can learn from the latest durability research
If you've ever felt strong at the beginning of a ride but watched your power disappear after three or four hours, this episode explores the science behind why some cyclists maintain their performance better than others — and how researchers are trying to measure it.
Ben is also looking for additional Masters/UCI Gran Fondo cyclists willing to contribute training and racing data to his ongoing analysis.
📧 Contact: [email protected]
🌐 Road Cycling Academy: https://roadcyclingacademy.com
Transcript:
Cam Nicholls (00:01.836)
Welcome to the RCA podcast, designed for recreational and amateur road cyclists with a focus on performance. We dive into cycling training, nutrition, strength training for cyclists, and even bike fitting tips, all designed to help you train smarter, ride faster, and hopefully tear your mates' legs off. So without further ado, let's dive into today's episode.
Welcome back to the RCA podcast, where today I'm joined by the RCA's science geek who's now based out of Switzerland, Ben Treble. And as per his nickname at the RCA, Ben has been at a cycling and science conference in Barcelona, and he's got some unpublished data from one of the world's biggest cycling teams, Tour de France teams, that he's going to share with us.
So this is a bit of a an inside scoop. Are you allowed to share this info, Ben? Or like are we gonna get it in a bit of trouble here? They didn't say anything.
Ben Treble (01:02.848)
I didn't see the first like two minutes, so Okay. That was often my trick. I mean, if they gave us a and there's no NDA anyway. I'm not sharing photos of it, it's verbatim. Some of this I feel like let's just do it.
Cam Nicholls (01:05.112)
Yeah.
Cam Nicholls (01:16.514)
Okay. Good.
Ben Treble (01:17.826)
But hot topic, hey? it's on durability.
Cam Nicholls (01:22.414)
Okay, and which team are we talking about? Which Tour de France team?
Ben Treble (01:25.696)
Red Bull Bora Handscrow. Yes. Yeah, yeah. So David De Klerk from Red Bull, I think he's one of their performance managers. He may also be a coach, I can't remember. Sorry, David. he gave a very nice presentation in Barcelona on some of the work that they're doing with some metrics to measure say durability and and performance.
Cam Nicholls (01:28.437)
look at.
Ben Treble (01:55.116)
beyond the the standard metrics of say threshold and stuff. So this is actually very big business in the World Tours, which is we would bucket it under talent identification or talent ID. Why is this important? When you're a World Tour team, you have a budget and at some point you have a pipeline of riders and the performance of those riders or finding the next Tade Pogachar, that becomes one of your biggest goals. Can you find the next Tade Poggachar?
And how do we know if a rider's going to be good in the future? How do we measure that?
Cam Nicholls (02:28.29)
Well what are the standard mechanisms for testing durability now? Because to me it's such a untangible because durability is the ability to produce, you know, high bouts of power essentially after long periods, long fatiguing periods in the saddle. So is is there a standard testing protocol? Because I guess, you know, what what we hear is, you know, often in articles on online is the twenty minute FTP test.
But that's not a durability test.
Ben Treble (03:01.344)
You might argue in some cases that in part a threshold test. It could be a ramp test for FTP. It could be a multiple maximal efforts for critical power test. Ultimately those are testing your threshold, which still represents durability. How much power can you push for how long?
Cam Nicholls (03:20.152)
Twenty minutes, yeah.
Ben Treble (03:21.44)
It's still a a durable marker. But I think the difference is those things were always trying to measure, at least in my books, the gold standard threshold, which was metabolic, your lactate steady state, MLSS. Right. And this is very difficult to test well. So people come up with easy tests you can do from home that they found some correlation to MLSS that was actually really poor. And that's how we came up with FTP.
That's my that's my nutshell history that scientists will debate forever.
Cam Nicholls (03:55.352)
So is there a gold standard dura durability test?
Ben Treble (03:58.76)
No. You know, it's been a hot topic for the last two, even three years at Science and Cycling Conference. And I don't think anybody has agreed on a single test that says this measures durability. There are multiple tests out there. Some of them are quite similar. I would say the most common type of testing to look at durability and assess it would be to do a ride where you
deplete a certain amount of kilojoules. So let's say you have to deplete, I don't know, 2,000 kilojoules, 3000 kilojoules, 4,000 kilojoules. And then you have to do a maximal effort at the end. And they look at, let's say, let's just use five minute power, for example. They get you to do a fresh five minute power test. Like what is your best five minute power you can do in a fresh state? Then they go and do these, you know, depleted efforts.
And then you have to try and do your best. How close to this five-minute fresh power can you get? And what is the percentage decay in this power? Now, different teams and different riders use different durations of this. So this is where we see differences in the Jubilee protocols and why there's not a single one necessarily. For GC riders, they might use a longer, they might use your 20-minute power. So you go do a 20-minute fresh test, you do a depleted ride.
If you're a world tour writer, it's probably going to be even 4,000 kilojoules because that's closer to what you would have in, you know, a hard hilly stage. And then what is the decay in your power, your 20-minute power? And that is something they see. They talk about this in Tade Pogachar a lot. That's where he's different to a lot of other riders, right? His decay in like 20 it was quoted somewhere. His decay in his 20 minute power.
After like four thousand kilojoules is only one percent.
Cam Nicholls (05:56.738)
Huh.
Ben Treble (05:57.912)
course. You and I are probably like minimal fifteen percent, twenty percent declines. Amateurs can be thirty plus percent decline in their power after doing only say two and a half thousand kilojoules, not four thousand. That is a very big difference. So that's probably the most common method of durability testing that I've seen across the conference and different teams and what's used. but I would say there is no single standard protocol
There's big questions even around this protocol. So we don't have to go too far down this rabbit hole. But for example, when you do let's say you have to do three thousand kilojoul depletion, you can deplete three thousand kilojoules by doing, you know, five hours of zone two, or you could do it by doing high intensity efforts for one and a half hours.
Cam Nicholls (06:47.676)
Of course.
Ben Treble (06:48.93)
You know, doing a fresh versus a depleted, doing another twenty minute test at the end of high intensity intervals for two hours versus four hours of zone two, those are very different depletions that lead you into this. So this was a topic that was brought up by David in his presentation, as he said something they're working on is trying to find a way to standardize that depletion. But at the moment they predominantly use training data because it's too difficult to pull writers out and say,
literally go do a 3,000 kilojoul depletion and do this effort. They typically get them to do a training ride or look at training data where they did a 20 minute PB or close to after a big day out.
Cam Nicholls (07:29.524)
Okay, that makes more sense. So what what was the inside scoop?
Ben Treble (07:34.37)
Yeah, let's chat about it. So on that topic, what was presented? So we'll start with something that's not Red Bull on their own came up with, right? So beyond the standard measures of performance. So the joiner, there's a thing called the joiner model of performance predictors, which predominantly looks at efficiency, VO2 max, and threshold. Durability is considered this fourth element that needs to be added to this classic model of performance predictors that was.
Put together by a scientist called Joyner. But how we measure it is the big question. Red Bull and a bunch of other scientists came up with an idea called compound score to start with. That was their first, I would argue, attempt at measuring durability to some respects. And compound score is easily calculated as it's your absolute power output. Typically they use five minutes. So let's say you can do 300 watts for five minutes in a fresh state.
And then you multiply it by the same five minute power, but in its relative form. So you would take your 300 watts, divide it by whatever your weight is, let's say 70 kilograms. So then you just multiply the absolute power by the relative power five minute. And you get this score. It could be anywhere from say, I don't know, a thousand up to three thousand, roughly, right? And they came up with a table of benchmarks that kind of says depending on your score, this would be where you sit. And they found some
relationships between high people who had high compound scores typically got more podium results.
Cam Nicholls (09:08.014)
What do you mean compound scores?
Ben Treble (09:10.008)
So what I just talked about, so the compound score. Yeah. Yeah. If we look at your absolute five minute power output multiplied by the relative power output, so watts per kilo, you get this score. And let's say it's two thousand points. Yeah. People who had this higher number were more likely to get a podium in a race. Yep. And they said, well, we know that the joinum model alone is not predicting like if you have a high VO2 max, it doesn't tell us that you're going to get a podium result anymore.
You need to have a high VO2 max, but it doesn't tell us if you're going to win the race. Hmm. So they're saying what else is contributing to people winning? So they're trying to measure that. That's this and that means when they know how to measure that, they could potentially in talent ID find the new Tate pogger chart earlier. That's where this is coming from.
Cam Nicholls (09:58.914)
Okay.
Ben Treble (10:02.414)
So they started with compound score. they found a relationship between higher compound scores and results that was not found with, say, just pure watts per kilo threshold, VO two max, those other measures that are more, let's say, traditional. Mm-hmm. But then they started to see some differences where it didn't necessarily predict race results, especially in juniors. And they're saying, Okay, maybe there's something else to this. We need to look at other metrics. So
Let's dig into the study. What was presented? So, David, really what they're looking at here. So we're going to go back to the sort of durability test we talked about before, where we have a decay and the Red Bull team are using their five minute mean maximal power. So the fresh five minute power versus their depleted five minute power. And they take a percentage of this decline. So maybe it's two percent, 10%, whatever it is.
They take that percentage decline and compare it against other variables to try and find a relationship. Is there something that is able to identify who has smaller decline or decay in their mean maximal power? The reason they use five minutes is because five minute mean maximal power is a very good indicator of your VO2 max. So you might be able to argue the decline in VO2 max after
3,000 or 3,500 kilojoules is also a very important contributor to performance. So what they did is they looked at they used 3,000 kilojoulle depletion for the under 19s and they did three and a half thousand kilojoulle depletion for under 23s. So they have a fairly large pool of riders in their database and they looked at all the training data and they compared this decay percentage to fresh four minute torque value in Newton meters.
Cam Nicholls (11:58.776)
Today's podcast is brought to you by the Road Cycling Academy. I know from personal experiences that one of the most frustrating things as a recreational and amateur road cyclist when you're wanting to improve is putting in more time and effort on the bike, but never reaching the level you know you're capable of. So often people start riding more because they think that's the answer, but the harder they work, the more frustrated they become because the results just don't match the effort.
And eventually many people start to ponder maybe this is just my level. But I can tell you after seven years of being involved with recreational and amateur road cyclers through the road cycling academy that it's not your level. And that's exactly why we've created the Road Cycling Academy's 12-week custom plan. It's a plan designed specifically for recreational and amateur road cyclers who aren't quite ready for ongoing one-to-one coaching.
But know they've hit a plateau and they want to do something about it. It all starts with a one-on-one consultation with one of our experienced coaches. We'll learn about your riding history, your goals, your available training time, and your not negotiable rides. Next, we'll guide you through some testing so we can establish your accurate training zones. And from there, the coach will build a fully personalized, periodized 12-week training plan in training peaks that's designed around.
Your life with coach support throughout the entire program. And the results speak for themselves. Recently, we've had Ryan come to us wanting to improve his tour to Brisbane result. That's a UCI qualifier. And following his custom 12-week plan, he didn't just crack the top 20, which was one of his goals. He actually finished third overall on the podium, calling the program, and you can see this on our Google Reviews an absolute game changer.
Steve increased his critical power by 35 watts in 12 weeks. That's a 15.7% improvement. And he enjoyed the coach experience so much that he actually continued with one-to-one coaching following. So if you've had a gut full of putting in the work without getting the results, you know you're capable of. We'd love to help. Head to the Road Cycling Academy website and check out
Cam Nicholls (14:17.888)
Our 12 week custom training plan. And as a thank you to our listeners of this podcast, for the first five people, use the code RCA ten and you'll receive 10% off. Once those five spots are gone, the offer ends. Let's get back to the podcast. Okay. So how do people know what their fresh four minute talk value is in Newton meters? Not something I've looked at before, Ben.
Ben Treble (14:44.524)
Yeah, do you have a power meter can?
Cam Nicholls (14:46.902)
I do, yes. Asioma.
Ben Treble (14:48.942)
Do you spin the pedals? Then we can measure torque. So your power meter, well, when to measure power, you essentially have to have velocity times torque. That's that is power. It's velocity times torque. So people who spin more need less torque to produce the same power. And then people who have slower cadence, so they s they spin less, they're producing more torque to achieve the same power as the spinners. Yep.
So this is when we think of people who are more aerobic, right? They can lean more on this producing power through the cardiovascular system by spinning more, right? High cadence. And then you get the people like probably more you and me. we have more muscle mass. So we probably naturally lean more towards producing our power from a torque component of the equation, right? We have more type two fibers. So that's the torque component. If you have a power meter, pretty much every modern power meter is going to be calculating.
Talk or at least estimating it. Some power meters are better at measuring torque through the whole stroke cycle, but to get a four minute average it's they're probably pretty much every power meter is measuring this.
Cam Nicholls (16:00.616)
So for the layman out there, and I'm certainly a layman, the four minute talk number is gonna be different to your four minute power number because it's not taking into account how much you're spinning. Yep. So now you can go back to what you were saying before I interrupted with my question.
Ben Treble (16:10.51)
Correct.
Ben Treble (16:16.472)
Yeah. And if you think of torque, where is it also coming from a little bit? If you think of people who do this low cadence or high torque training, it's often about improving the fatigue ability of the fibers and the motor units in the muscle itself. Right. People who can tolerate higher torques often have like the the muscle fibers can tolerate more fatigue. Yep. So that's why they were like, okay, this let's look at the relationship between torque.
And the decay in the mean maximal power. And they found a strong relationship here. So that for the scientists who are listening, the R score 0.49, P score was 0.03. So they found a, in terms of science, that is a good relationship between fresh absolute four-minute talk value and the percentage in decay. So people who had higher fresh four-minute talk values had smaller percentages in the decay.
of their main maximal power.
Cam Nicholls (17:17.643)
Okay.
Ben Treble (17:18.594)
And that was across both the 3,000 kJ depletion in the under-19s and the 3,500 kJ in the under-23. David Declerc, who did this presentation, didn't present data on the world tour riders themselves, but he indicated it's going to be published soon. And I imagine it's kind of indicated it's gonna share the same story, but they looked at using a 4,000 kilojoul depletion in the Elite Riders, and I think it had the same story. So
What else was interesting in his presentation? They didn't just look at fresh four minute talk. They looked at your relative torque. So a bit like your relative power. This is torque divided by your body weight. And they found no good correlation here, which is quite interesting. So your relative torque had no relationship to the decay in your five minute power, which I just thought that to me was actually a very interesting.
thing that I I thought I kind of expected it would at the end of the day. They also then, if you remember we talked about the compound score before, they looked at the decay in five minute power percentage against compound score and found no strong relationship. So what does this mean? It means that the compound score, it's important for predicting performance success, but it doesn't correlate to durability. They're separate from each other. So his
summary on this was compound score is good to measure and it's good to measure performance capacity. And then looking at absolute fresh four minute talk values was a good predictor on your decay in five minute power in terms of V2 Max. So they are now looking for riders who have both good compound scores and high fresh four minute absolute talk values. And they're thinking the four minute talk value might become one of the key markers to measure durability.
Cam Nicholls (19:15.232)
Interesting. So, you know, that's pretty pretty good insight from a professional level. If we're amateur recreationals, which I think most of us are listening to this and I certainly am, what can we glean from this? Like what what can I take from this to implement into my own cycling? Or is it is it more about how much attention and focus pro teams are giving to durability now and trying to find durable riders?
that it should really be a focus in my own training too.
Ben Treble (19:48.748)
I think that's why I wanted to start with the context of the talent ID, right? So there's a very big emphasis in the world tool. Why does durability matter? It's about finding the next writer and getting value for money in their budget and trying to find the next big thing. We know durability is important. We probably don't really know how to quite measure it yet. and when we think of amateur writers like you and me and most of our audience, I was sitting there in the room thinking, this is amazing.
Like I've got plenty of writers who come to me and say, you know, I want to improve my durability. And we come up with some individualized ways to try and measure it. And I'm thinking, this might just be what I've been missing. Like maybe I have to just be putting a bit more emphasis on fresh four minute talk values. And I was like, but this will be easy to test because I have quite a few masters writers. I can look at their data and say, do I get the same relationship?
Cam Nicholls (20:35.328)
Okay.
Ben Treble (20:45.706)
that David De Klerk has found. So I'm going to give you a little bit of unpublished, unofficial, and very small sample size data. So take this as you want. But I'm collecting more data. So if you're listening to this and you are a UCI Fondo writer and you've been training for a year, get in touch because and you're willing to share your data. I would love to add you into this little research project. The more data, the stronger the insights get and the summaries. So but long story short, Cam.
I do not get the same findings as David De Klerk with Masters Riders. There's so far at least in my small sample size, there's zero relationship between decay in five minute mean maximal power and fresh four minute talk value. I'll let that sit with you for a second.
Cam Nicholls (21:32.984)
Go, h how many riders have you been able to look out data wise? Eight. Okay.
Ben Treble (21:37.762)
I got eight. And to give you an idea, I mean I think David Claklerk, they had around twenty-three from memory, he said. So eight's not bad. I wouldn't say it's amazing, but in terms of the performance, real-world values, it's not bad. Yes. To give you more context to that sample size, I had they're all male. I didn't have any females, unfortunately. They were a mixture of podium performers. Yep.
People who qualified. So this is at the the Tour of Brisbane. And I had riders who did not qualify. So say mid-pack or even towards backpack. And so I think there's a really nice mixture of performance abilities. There was obviously a range of age categories within that. And it's just it's interesting because I looked at both how do these values compare to how close they got to a qualifying race time and also
performance race time. So how far away from a podium performance time were they and also the qualifying time? And there's just no I couldn't find any relationship between fresh four minute talk or relative four minute talk or compound score to their performance.
Cam Nicholls (22:53.396)
Okay. And this is all data. You did you get y these you know, these people that you looked at, you didn't need to get them to go and test, did you? The the data was already available. Just from their tr their training data.
Ben Treble (23:02.456)
Yeah.
Yeah, I can use WKO and pull out their you know, I can create I just created a little dashboard in WKO that looked at fresh four minute talk values.
Cam Nicholls (23:13.834)
WKO is a is an application inside Training Peaks which is a bit more advanced for all those people that are wondering what WKO is.
Ben Treble (23:22.304)
Yeah. And then I created a graph for the five minute like decay percentage on mean max full power. So kind of easy to pull the data out. One thing to note, I did not use a like a three thousand or a three and a half thousand kilojoul depletion. Most masters riders are rarely hitting those numbers. In fact, I looked at two and a half thousand and also two thousand kilojoul because on average, in the end, I used two and a half thousand because on average
It was almost spot on. Two and a half thousand kilojoules was the depletion across that sample size at tour of Brizzy for the event. So I don't think a three thousand or three and a half or even four thousand kilojoulle depletion is relevant for masters riders in terms of UCI fondos, because for the most part, the race is not even getting close to hitting those depletions. So what we care about would be and what's more relevant is between two and two and a half thousand depletion in Masters riders.
The UCI fondos are often shorter and less intense than World Tour racing. So I tried to make it very specific when I looked at it, but also because most of them just don't have the data. Like you there's no five minute effort that they've done after 3,000 kilojoules because heaps of them have just never done it.
Cam Nicholls (24:38.868)
If there is a recreational and amateur out there that wants to lean into your your study here, Ben, and maybe get involved, what's the best way for them to get in contact? They just contact the general RCA email and then we can forward it across or do you wanna give do you wanna give your personal details away here?
Ben Treble (24:54.414)
Yeah, I mean they can hit up the RCA for sure and that can get passed on to me. You can also reach me at my RCA email, Ben at RoadcyclingAcademy dot com. Also happy for you to hit me up on Instagram. I have a public profile. it's nothing super exciting. If you're it's just Benjamin Treble would be my handle if you search me. yeah, you can reach me on either of those forms.
Cam Nicholls (25:19.192)
Yeah. Well we'll we'll we'll link those in the podcast description as well if people want to get involved because it's it's it's quite it's interesting what you're doing and it's an emerging, developing space. And obviously, you know, while pro athletes and that they do their pro things, their expertise and their their frameworks can definitely be leveraged to advantage in what we we do, you know, with our members and athletes at the at the Road Cycling Academy. So yeah, that's really interesting. Ben, is anything else that you wanted to add there?
Ben Treble (25:49.868)
No, I'll probably leave it there and stay tuned because I have some hypothesis and some other insights from the masters data that surprised me in terms of what predicts performance at UCI fondos. So stay tuned.
Cam Nicholls (26:06.318)
Alright, that's great. Well, yeah, as mentioned, if you if you want to get involved in what Ben's doing, we'll drop the details to get in contact in the podcast description. And Ben, thank you for sharing. That scoop was very interesting. We'll catch everyone in the next podcast.
Altri episodi di "Road Cycling Academy Podcast"



Non perdere nemmeno un episodio di “Road Cycling Academy Podcast”. Iscriviti all'app gratuita GetPodcast.








