Too Much TV podcast

Lanterns S1 EP8: Dirt and Stars

6/10/2026
0:00
39:28
Manda indietro di 15 secondi
Manda avanti di 15 secondi

We finally made it to the end of Lanterns, and this week we're closing the book on the season with the finale, "Dirt and Stars." (I couldn't remember the title, which tells you how invested I was.)

Here's the twist: Jeff really liked it. He had the show at a C going in and bumped it up to a B+ on the strength of this episode, and it mostly came down to Hal's last lines. I thought the episode was fine and the show stays a flat C for me. We both agree the ending was sweet, though. John's "I love you," Hal's "I think you'll be way better at this job than I ever was," the wink, and the flight across the lantern all landed. It's bittersweet because it isn't really Hal, and I think killing off such a well cast character is both a bold move and a bit of a wasted opportunity.

Jeff also felt vindicated about the pep rally he ranted about last week, since it turns out Noah matters. We still have questions about him, though. If Zoe is a Manhunter and Noah is a Manhunter, why does the sheriff's dad skip a generation? Are Manhunters programmed to rule? Noah's casual path to power (get famous playing football, run for Congress, run for president) is both hilarious and probably accurate. We get into why Hal feels so guilty when the town benefited from Zoe, why the Guardians would be the villains from Rushville's point of view, and why Guy Gardner would ever notice a light in Nebraska. Guy is a tool, but he's our tool, and "What's up, Homes?" has been living in my head.

Sinestro gets a whole segment as the show's biggest wasted potential. He spent the season looking like a sunburnt old man, but Jeff is convinced it's Palpatine style bait and he's coming back in a big way. We also dig into his point about fear and evolution, why Hal's "don't be afraid to be afraid" is the better philosophy, and why John's oath at the end of the episode really works.

Then there's Sheriff Carrie, who shoots Hal after his "we're going to Guadalajara" speech. We debate whether Hal would really have handled a mother and her son that badly, and whether Carrie's reaction made sense. By the end we were both sort of on her side.

To close, we hand out final grades, talk about why a show can look exactly like HBO and still not read like HBO, and get into why superhero universes are so hard to build well (Marvel's island full of writers planning ten years ahead, anyone?). I'm glad we watched it. I'm also glad it's over.

Next week is something way more fun. Jeff sent me five episodes of The Office, we're both ranking them, and we're comparing the funniest lines. After that, South Park.

Altri episodi di "Too Much TV"