Ask Holly Hall podcast

What If There’s Only ONE Answer to Every WHY?

0:00
7:36
Manda indietro di 15 secondi
Manda avanti di 15 secondi

This is about WHY.

Why do we always ask why?

Why am I like this? Why am I like that? Why did I get ill? Why did I injure myself? Why did I lose that job? Why did they leave me? Why don’t they talk to me? Why didn’t they test me? Why am I this way?

And why is all of this happening in the world?

Why, why, why?

We’re constantly on a quest to find answers. Were we born that way? Were we born into a world of WHY? Perhaps we shouldn’t even call this Earth. Maybe we should call it the World of Why.

From the moment we begin understanding language, mathematics, the world around us, our parents and our upbringing, we’re questioning everything. And eventually, we arrive at the biggest question of all:

Why are we here? Why am I here?

Isn’t that the big daddy of all questions?

I just finished a session with a client, and she gave me one of the best compliments ever. She said, “You’re cheaper than a therapist, and you’re just as good, if not better!”

Her entire hour revolved around WHY. It was about a complicated relationship involving family, friendship and interpersonal dynamics. A series of events had unfolded over time, and she wanted to understand why. Why did this happen? Why did that person behave that way? Why had things changed?

And, of course, that’s what people often come to me for: answers, understanding and clarity. She left with a much better understanding of the situation.

But then I spoke with a friend who had recently experienced a setback. Her questions were also about WHY. This time, she was looking for the spiritual meaning behind what had happened. Why had life slowed her down? Why was this happening now?

And I found myself saying, “Maybe there’s no answer. Maybe there is no WHY.”

“No, no,” she said. “I need to know why!”

And I thought, don’t we all?

I do exactly the same thing.

I recently experienced a relapse with one of my autoimmune issues. Immediately, I knew some of the reasons. I knew what I’d eaten that could trigger it. I knew I’d physically overextended myself. I could identify several contributing factors.

But then came the next WHY.

Why wasn’t I healing as quickly as I normally do? Why was this taking longer? Why wasn’t my body responding the way it usually does?

After that conversation with my very intelligent, intellectual best friend, I found myself asking a different question:

Why do I need to know WHY?

And I’ve been sitting with that thought all day.

Isn’t that a conundrum? I’m trying to stop asking WHY by using WHY to understand why I need to know WHY!

It just keeps stacking up, one question on top of another. And it never ends.

What if we reached a point where we simply questioned our need to know?

Why did they need to love me? Why did they need to stay? Why couldn’t they leave? Why did they have to be in a good mood? Why couldn’t they take their frustration out on someone else? Why did they fire me?

What if we stopped needing an explanation for everything?

What if we could simply say, “I don’t need to know why. It just is.”

That’s a little like Buddhist 101.

So much of our suffering comes from resisting what is, from refusing to accept reality as it unfolds. We become caught in the illusion that there must be an answer, that if we just think long enough, analyse enough or ask enough questions, we’ll finally understand everything.

But what if we don’t?

Now, don’t get me wrong. There are WHYs we absolutely should investigate.

If I drop something heavy on my arm and it starts hurting, I want to know why. Is it broken? Is it bruised? Have I torn a muscle? I might need an X-ray or an assessment from a physician or another practitioner. Understanding the injury helps me know how to care for it and allow it to heal.

That’s a useful WHY.

But where do we draw the line?

When does our need to understand become more of a problem than the original situation itself?

I think it happens more often than we realise.

Can constantly questioning why interfere with our healing? Can it prolong the pain of a relationship? Can it keep us stuck in negative circumstances? And can we become so focused on understanding what’s wrong that we stop creating something different?

There’s a saying attributed to Buckminster Fuller that, rather than fighting an existing reality, we should create a new one that makes the old one obsolete. That’s a paraphrase, but the idea is powerful.

Instead of endlessly asking WHY, perhaps we should ask:

Why aren’t we doing something different?

Why aren’t we thinking differently? Looking at things differently? Creating something new?

What if, instead of spending all our energy trying to understand the door that just closed, we opened another one?

That brings me to an idea I had recently for a new guided meditation.

Imagine opening a completely new door.

Not the old door. Not the familiar door. Not even one of the doors you’ve been considering.

A brand-new door.

And you have absolutely no idea what’s behind it.

Remember those old game shows where you could choose door number one, door number two or door number three?

Door number three was the mystery. You had no idea what was behind it. It could be better than door number one or two. It could be exactly the same. It could even be worse.

But you had to take a chance.

I think I might choose door number three.

No more analysing why I don’t want door number one, or why door number two might be a better choice. Just open a new door and see what’s possible.

Maybe that’s where we need to put more of our attention: less time trying to explain everything that has happened and more time creating what happens next.

Something to ponder.

What do you think?

I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments. Did you have an aha moment? Do you disagree? Do you have an answer to my WHY?

Namaste, everyone.



This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit hollyhall.substack.com/subscribe

Altri episodi di "Ask Holly Hall"