The Justice and the Injustice of Our Claim: Hebron, the Settlers, and How Israel Came to Rule the West Bank | With Yossi Klein Halevi
In the fall of 1967, a group of young Israelis went to Prime Minister Levi Eshkol with a request. As children they had been evacuated from Kfar Etzion, a kibbutz near Bethlehem that fell in the 1948 war, where defenders were killed after they surrendered. Now they wanted to go home. As Yossi Klein Halevi tells it, Eshkol wouldn't commit, so they asked to pray there for Rosh Hashanah, and he answered in Yiddish: "Kinderlach, children, go pray." In Yossi's words, "this is how the settlement movement was born, with a noncommittal wink from the Israeli prime minister." Then: "They went and they never left."Israel hadn't planned to rule that land. Yossi, who wrote a book about the paratroopers who took Jerusalem in 1967, found "there had been no contingency plans, even for taking East Jerusalem, let alone what we call Judea and Samaria and the world calls the West Bank." Settlement became government policy when Menachem Begin came to power in 1977. By his count, it's now "close to a million Jews living in areas that were not in Israeli hands on the eve of the Six-Day War." He argues the Palestinian leadership could have stopped that growth by joining the peace process when Anwar Sadat came to Jerusalem, or by accepting the Clinton-Barak offer in 2000: "I can't think of another stateless people that was offered sovereignty more often than the Palestinians and turned it down more often."He draws a line most of the debate skips: "We are occupying another people. We are not occupying our ancestral land." For a genuine peace, he says, he "would be prepared to give up land that belongs to me, not give back." After October 7th almost no Israeli Jew will risk the West Bank turning into another Gaza, but he won't call anything permanent: "There's no such thing as never, as impossible."On the settlers, he agrees the strong majority don't support violence against Palestinians, and says that matters less and less. He calls the violence "a devastating, I would almost say historic blow against the moral credibility of Israel and the Jewish people," and he holds the settler leadership and their politicians responsible for staying quiet: "There's a phrase in the Talmud, silence is a form of admission, of confession."He knows the extremist mindset from the inside. As a young man in the U.S., he was a follower of Rabbi Meir Kahane, who he calls "the spiritual father of the Hilltop Youth." In 1973, as a student in Israel, he volunteered for Kahane's first Knesset campaign and noticed that "he wasn't really talking about Soviet Jewry anymore," and that "he was talking about expelling Palestinians." He left and never went back. In 2014 he said radical aloneness is the soil extremism grows in. After October 7th, he says, that soil is richer: "Jewish extremism thrives in an atmosphere of isolation when the Jewish people is under siege."And then there's Hebron, where the Jewish story begins with Abraham and Sarah. "Hebron is the place that simultaneously proves the justness of our claim and the injustice of our claim." He says, "If we don't belong in Hebron, we don't belong anywhere," but holding it inflicts "a great dislocation on Palestinians there," and "every time I'm there, I feel torn to pieces." Any peace, he argues, will be a "mutual injustice" for both peoples. The obstacle is what each side is trying to satisfy: "You compromise on dreams. It's very hard to compromise on grievances, especially when your grievance is based on a deep sense of injustice."Also in this episode: why the hills of Judea and Samaria matter for Israel's security; how Kahane changed once he moved to Israel; his father, who was hidden by a non-Jew in Hungary; a Yad Vashem official who called the Righteous Among the Nations "a drop in the ocean"; the coverage imbalance, and the anger of Iranian dissidents at the pro-Palestinian movement; treating Palestinians as a people with agency; Oslo's Areas A, B and C; the difference between a necessary occupation and a voluntary one; and how a people moves from grievance to aspiration.YOSSI KLEIN HALEVI Senior Fellow, Shalom Hartman Institute: https://www.hartman.org.il/person/yossi-klein-halevi/ For Heaven's Sake, with Donniel Hartman: https://www.hartman.org.il/program/for-heavens-sake-podcast/ Books: Letters to My Palestinian Neighbor; Like Dreamers; Memoirs of a Jewish ExtremistMORE FROM THE HONEST TAKE Yossi Klein Halevi, "The Other Side of the Nakba": https://podcast.honestreporting.com/episodes/the-other-side-of-the-nakba-the-forgotten-history-of-1948-with-yossi-klein-halevi Yardena Schwartz, "The Lie That Lit the Match": https://podcast.honestreporting.com/episodes/the-lie-that-lit-the-match-hebron-nazis-and-the-wests-vanishing-memory-with-yardena-schwartzTHE HONEST TAKE Podcast: https://podcast.honestreporting.com Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-honest-take/id1896315802 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/1pCnClcM4jiggKP46YZGjG YouTube: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLLuF-lEHTGTw_RrfN9EP6pdWhgjMX7Fg5 HonestReporting: https://honestreporting.com HonestReporting on X: https://x.com/HonestReportingThe Honest Take is HonestReporting's weekly long-form interview show — 60 to 90 minutes, recorded remotely, hosted by Ben Chertoff. Every episode at podcast.honestreporting.com.If this conversation gave you something to chew on, please leave The Honest Take a rating and review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. It's the single biggest thing that helps new listeners find the show.