The Uncertainty Podcast podcast

#107 Why I Am a Naturalist - Graham Oppy

0:00
1:27:33
Retroceder 15 segundos
Avanzar 15 segundos

Graham Oppy, professor of philosophy at Monash University, is widely regarded as one of philosophy of religion's foremost atheistic thinkers. Here, Graham and I discuss our foundational disagreements: probability in philosophy of religion, branching actualism, what counts as an "explanation" of fine-tuning, John Norton's material theory of induction, and much else besides.

Video of this interview is available on YouTube.

To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating, either via PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee.

Follow me on X because you’re awesome.

EPISODE CHAPTERS:

00:00:00 Introduction

00:00:47 What makes a good argument?

00:06:39 Arguments versus making a case

00:08:42 What is naturalism?

00:13:55 Why compare specific worldviews?

00:17:47 Oppy's method for theory comparison

00:25:17 Animal suffering and the problem of evil

00:33:37 Is naturalism simpler than theism?

00:44:35 Is Oppy's method really Bayesian?

00:48:38 Can we compare theories without probabilities?

00:58:01 The Bayesian turn in philosophy of religion

01:00:59 Branching actualism and cosmic fine-tuning

01:06:19 Does necessity explain fine-tuning?

01:14:52 Can fine-tuning count against necessity?

01:17:02 Divine psychology and the limits of Bayesianism

01:23:42 What is Oppy most uncertain about?

01:25:39 Can philosophy make progress?



Get full access to Miles K. Donahue at mileskdonahue.substack.com/subscribe

Otros episodios de "The Uncertainty Podcast"