Are We There Yet? Rebuilding Trust in the Value of Education

Emily M. Bender & Alex Hanna share about their book, The AI Con: How to Fight Big Tech’s Hype and Create the Future We Want on episode 576 of the Teaching in Higher Ed podcast. Quotes from the episode What's going on with the phrase artificial intelligence is not that it means something else than what we're using it to mean, it's that it doesn't have a proper referent in the world. -Emily M. Bender There's a much broader range of people who can have opinions on AI. -Alex Hanna The boosters say AI is a thing. It's inevitable, it's imminent, it's going to be super powerful, and it's going to solve all of our problems. And the doomers say AI is a thing, it's inevitable, it's imminent, it's going to be super powerful, and it's going to kill us all. And you can see that there's actually not a lot of daylight between those two positions, despite the discourse of saying these are two opposite ends of a spectrum. -Emily M. Bender Teachers' working conditions are students' learning conditions. -Alex Hannay Resources The AI Con: How to Fight Big Tech’s Hype and Create the Future We Want, by Emily M. Bender and Alex Hanna Distributed AI Research Institute (DAIR) The Princess Bride Emily Tucker, Executive Director, Center on Privacy & Technology at Georgetown Law On the Dangers of Stochastic Parrots: Can Language Models Be Too Big? By Emily M. Bender, Timnit Gebru, Angelina McMillan-Major, and Shmargaret Shmitchell Emily M. Bender’s website How the right to education is undermined by AI, by Helen Beetham How We are Not Using AI in the Classroom, by Sonja Drimmer & Christopher J. Nygren  Empire of AI: Dreams and Nightmares in Sam Altman's OpenAI, by Karen Hao

Rolin Moe shares about rebuilding trust in the value of education (among other things) on episode 575 of the Teaching in Higher Ed podcast. Quotes from the episode I never again had a static lesson plan. I was always very fluid in whatever I was going to be doing. I knew where I wanted to get, but the road could go in all sorts of different directions. - Rolin Moe Learning is a continuous activity in all sorts of areas and all sorts of places. - Rolin Moe Education is the process of helping people find things that they don't yet know they love. - Rolin Moe Resources Gary Stager George Siemens Van Gogh-Inspired AI Course Policy (YouTube) MOOCs (Massive Open Online Courses – Wikipedia) Smithsonian Institution Michael Peter Edson UC Riverside XCITE Center Community Colleges in California California State University (CSU) System Go Somewhere Card Game James A. Michener quote Wingspan Board Game Elizabeth Hargrave (Game Designer) Merlin Bird ID App (Cornell Lab)

Alex Edmans shares about his book, May Contain Lies: How Stories, Statistics, and Studies Exploit Our Biases and What We Can Do About It on episode 574 of the Teaching in Higher Ed podcast. Quotes from the episode We think a lie is basically the opposite of truth. So something is a lie if you can disprove it factually. -Alex Edmans What I focus on in my book is a more subtle form of a lie where something could be 100% accurate, but the inferences that we draw from them might be misleading. -Alex Edmans It's not that they're bad people, it's that they're people, they're humans. And if we're a person, we have biases. -Alex Edmans What I'm trying to highlight is the importance of being discerning. We want to have healthy skepticism, but we want to have the same healthy skepticism to something that we do like as something that we don't. -Alex Edmans Resources May Contain Lies: How stories, statistics and studies exploit our biases — and what we can do about it, by Alex Edmans Outliers, by Malcolm Gladwell Cookie Monster Practices Self-Regulation | Life Kit Parenting | NPR Addiction Rare in Patients Treated with Narcotics Taking A Mosaic Approach to AI in the Writing Classroom, presented by Chris Ostro All Else Equal Podcast A Little Life, by Hanya Yanagihara

Tolu Noah shares about her new book, Designing and Facilitating Workshops with Intentionality, on episode 573 of the Teaching in Higher Ed podcast. Quotes from the episode Whenever I'm planning a learning experience, I start by identifying a clear goal for the experience. -Tolu Noah I don't think there's necessarily one right way to approach planning. -Tolu Noah A really important aspect of facilitation is that yes, you have a plan, but you also need to be flexible with that plan and be willing to take a rest stop or a detour if needed. -Tolu Noah Timing is probably one of the most important aspects of facilitation. -Tolu Noah Resources Designing and Facilitating Workshops with Intentionality: A Guide to Crafting Engaging Professional Learning Experiences in Higher Education, by Tolulope Noah Yoruba The Art of Gathering: How We Meet and Why It Matters, by Priya Parker Richard E. Mayer Padlet Breakout Rooms Padlet Sandbox Bryan Mathers Permission Slip Headliner App Butter Scenes SessionLab Facilitating On Purpose

Leon Furze shares about myths and metaphors in the age of generative AI on episode 572 of the Teaching in Higher Ed podcast. Quotes from the episode In higher education there is a need to temper the resistance and refusal of the technology with the understanding that students are using it anyway. -Leon Furze We can take a a personal moral stance, but if we have a responsibility to teach students, then we have a responsibility to engage with the technology on some level. In order to do that, we need to be using it and and experimenting with it because otherwise, we're relying on third party information, conjecture, and opinions rather than direct experience. -Leon Furze My use of the technology has really shifted over the last few years the more I think about it as a technology and not as a vehicle for language. -Leon Furze Let the English teachers who love English, teach English. Let the mathematics teachers who love math, teach math. Let the science teachers teach science. And where appropriate, bring these technologies in. -Leon Furze Resources Myths, Magic, and Metaphors: The Language of Generative AI (Leon Furze) Arthur C. Clarke’s Third Law (Wikipedia) Vincent Mosco – The Digital Sublime MagicSchool AI OECD’s Definition of AI Literacy PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment) NAPLAN (Australia’s National Assessment Program – Literacy and Numeracy) Against AI literacy: have we actually found a way to reverse learning? by Miriam Reynoldson ChatGPT (OpenAI) CoPilot (Microsoft) Who Cares to Chat, by Audrey Watters (About Clippy) Clippy (Microsoft Office Assistant – Wikipedia) Gemini (Google AI) Be My Eyes Accessibility with GPT-4o Be My Eyes (Assistive Technology) Teaching AI Ethics – Leon Furze Black Box (Artificial Intelligence – Wikipedia) Snagit (TechSmith) Meta Ray-Ban Smart Glasses

Jackie Shay Shares about overcoming imposter syndrome through joyful curiosity on episode 571 of the Teaching in Higher Ed podcast. Quotes from the episode Sometimes I get in my head about imposter syndrome about being joyful. -Jackie Shay Why can't we recognize that these different types of intelligences have just as much value as intellectual intelligence? -Jackie Shay It's about supporting the learning by doing meaningful, challenging work that promotes growth, that allows us to find joy in the discomfort that comes from the vulnerability of pushing your mind to its boundaries and beyond. -Jackie Shay Resources Joy-Centered Pedagogy in Higher Education: Uplifting Teaching & Learning for All, edited by Eileen Camfield Emotional Intelligence Video about neuroplasticity Making Challenging Subjects Fun: Episode 66 with Anissa Ramirez Creating Desirable Difficulties to Enhance Learning, by Elizabeth L. Bjork and Robert Bjork Beyond Dichotomous Thinking: Episode 527 with Alexis Peirce Caudell What Baby George (and Handstands) Taught me About Learning from Mike Wesch Radical hope: A teaching manifesto, by Kevin Gannon Fred Wolf Awe: The new science of everyday wonder and how it can transform your life, by Dacher Keltner Coaching for Leaders Episode 254: Use Power for Good and Not Evil, with Dacher Keltner Tennis ball massage  Relaxed Cozy House Mix in a New York Loft | Tinzo

Laura Gibbs shares how to get started with interactive storytelling in any discipline on episode 570 of the Teaching in Higher Ed podcast. Quotes from the episode I think what happens with a lot of people's efforts to tell stories is that they're staring at a blank page or a blank screen, and they just feel lost in it because they don't have a form that they're filling up. -Laura Gibbss Everybody was thriving with these hundred word stories. -Laura Gibbss Meaninglessness in education won't work. Education has to be meaningful, personally meaningful. -Laura Gibbss Resources Laura Gibb’s Website and Blog Laura Gibb’s Aesop Survivor and Other Games Improvised Shakespeare Company TV Tropes George Station The Mouse Bride Mike Caulfield MYFest Nursery Rhyme Maze Game LinkedIn Post: Go Somewhere + Games, in General Laura’s Ungrading Padlet Who Cares to Chat? by Audrey Watters Audrey Watters’ 2nd Breakfast Newsletter Readers Theater, by Laura Gibbs & Heather Kretschmer Zine Construction video with Dawn Stahura Dawn Stahura’s Zine-Making Resources 100-Word Stories from Laura Gibbs (and her students) Tiny Writing Workshop Padlet, including 6-Word Stories Keeping ScOR from John Biewen Write Your Own Book List, by Laura Gibbs Ungrading Chapbook, by Martha Burtis Bonus Video After Pod Party with Laura Gibbs

Mike Perkins and Jasper Roe share a practical framework for ethical AI integration in assessment on episode 569 of the Teaching in Higher Ed podcast. Quotes from the episode We wanted to be flexible and have some opportunities for students and faculty to really have open conversations about how AI might be suitably used given the individual circumstances and the cultural context. -Mike Perkins One of the things that is happening that we can't deny is that the rate of hallucinations is going down. The capabilities are getting better and better. -Jasper Roe Criticality and pessimism aren't the same thing, especially when it comes to GenAI models. -Jasper Roe Resources AI Assessment Scale Website Updating the AI Assessment Scale, by Leon Furze The Artificial Intelligence Assessment Scale (AIAS): A Framework for Ethical Integration of Generative AI in Educational Assessment, by Mike Perkins, Leon Furze, Jasper Roe, & Jason MacVaugh Nick McIntosh Artificial intelligence and illusions of understanding in scientific research, by Lisa Messeri & M. J. Crockett Amelia King Jane Rosenzweig’s Bluesky post: Schitts Creek: The Sequel (Bluesky login required to view) Jane Rosenzweig’s Breakfast Club Ai generated photos mixed with real ones (login required) SIFT Toolbox for Claude (and ChatGPT) Released, by Mike Caulfield Strava Garmin AI and the Future of Higher Ed, by Nick McIntosh The Residence

Tricia Bertram Gallant and David Rettinger discuss The Opposite of Cheating: Teaching for Integrity in the Age of AI on episode 568 of the Teaching in Higher Ed podcast. Quotes from the episode It is true that people cheat, and that's the reason we have rules in the first place in our lives. -David Rettinger There are always going to be social, personal, and individual pressures on us that cause us to do things that either we didn't realize were wrong, or that we perfectly well know that are wrong, but that in that moment seem like a reasonable trade off to our behavior. -David Rettinger Take care of yourself first, whatever that looks like. You're never going to help somebody else if you're not on firm ground yourself. -David Rettinger You can treat people with dignity and respect even as you’re calling out their mistake. You can challenge them while being respectful. -Tricia Bertram Gallant It is important for us to remember to give grace to ourselves. -Tricia Bertram Gallant Resources The Opposite of Cheating: Teaching for Integrity in the Age of AI, by Tricia Bertram Gallant and David A. Rettinger Doing School: How We Are Creating a Generation of Stressed-Out, Materialistic, and Miseducated Students, by Denise Clark Pope The Four Agreements: A Practical Guide to Personal Freedom, by Don Miguel Ruiz Crucial Conversations: Tools for Talking When Stakes Are High, by Joseph Grenny, Kerry Patterson, Ron McMillan, Al Switzler and Emily Gregory Authentic Assessment Phil Dawson at Deacon University How Van Gogh Informs my AI Course Policy Taking A Mosaic Approach to AI in the Writing Classroom- Episode 555: A Big Picture Look at AI Detection Tools Good Robot Podcast Forever Chemicals, Forever Consequences: What PFAS Teaches Us About AI International Center for Academic Integrity Make It Stick: The Science of Successful Learning, by Peter Brown, Mark A. McDaniel, and Henry L. Roediger Study Like a Champ, by Regan a. R. Gurung and John Dunlosky The Residence Galatea 2.2: A Novel, by Richard Powers Tulsa Oklahoma

Therese Huston shares about Sharp: 14 Simple Ways to Improve Your Life with Brain Science on episode 567 of the Teaching in Higher Ed podcast. Quotes from the episode As an instructor, there are multiple streams that you're having to pay attention to and you're switching between each one. -Therese Huston The research shows that listening to music that moves you will increase dopamine in your ventral striatum, so you feel a sense of reward. -Therese Huston Visualizing the process actually increases productivity. The neuroscience shows that you see five times more brain areas activated when you picture the process than when you picture a glorious outcome. -Therese Huston If you do just a 5 minute meditation right before you need to recall something, you can get up to a 75% improvement in your recall. -Therese Huston Resources Sharp: 14 Simple Ways to Improve Your Life with Brain Science, by Therese Huston Unlocking Us Podcast: Brené Brown on Anxiety, Calm, and Over-/Under-Functioning Classroom Assessment Techniques: Episode 554 with Todd Zakrajsek The Dunning–Kruger Effect Calm App The Live Your Values Deck The Healthy Minds App