Glee Reunions, New York State of Mind, and What Really Goes on Backstage

Jenna & Kevin are joined by Johnathon Schaech, who played Jimmy in That Thing You Do!, to talk about the audition that changed his life! From dressing the part, singing the iconic “I quit” line, and walking out. He shares what it was like working with Tom Hanks and Liv Tyler, becoming a real band on set, and how a simple acting instinct helped shape the movie. Plus, why the film’s legacy still lives on today, even inspiring HAIM’s album I Quit.For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Jenna & Kevin revisit what they believe is a perfect movie, Tom Hanks’ directorial and writing debut, That Thing You Do! They share their own stories of meeting Tom Hanks (and why you SHOULD meet your heroes), including the moment when Tom & Rita told Lea Michele she was “robbed” at the Golden Globes. Plus, they gush over the cast, the music, Liv Tyler’s performance, develop a crush on Tom Everett Scott, and debate why this movie has never become a stage musical. For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Kevin finally went to see Just In Time with Jonathan Groff and bumped into Matthew Morrison! Plus, Kevin shares the behind-the-scenes chaos of Spelling Bee’s real-life Traitors game, and Jenna & Kevin debate which Glee cast members they’d want to sit next to (and avoid) on a 10-hour flight.For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

No need to ‘wait for it’ ... Jenna and Kevin are ‘not throwin away’ their shot and finally reviewing one of the most popular Broadway musicals of all time - Hamilton! They share their memories of watching it live in person (Jenna saw the original cast) and of its streaming debut during the pandemic. Jenna also reveals the personal reason why watching the pro shot version left her emotional. Plus, their favorite songs, their performance MVP, and does watching Hamilton make for a good first date? Kevin has stories!For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Get ready for a pitching good chat with "Pitch Perfect's" vocal arranger and music director. The Godfather of a cappella, Deke Sharon, joins Jenna and Kevin with a whole lotta aca-awesome behind-the-scenes scoop from the set of "Pitch Perfect!" Including why he thought the movie was going to be a straight-to-video release, the eye-popping song that didn't make the cut, the muse behind the character of Benji, and who broke down in tears during 'aca-bootcamp!' He also chats Glee and the arrangement he feels was directly stolen (or borrowed) from college a capella recordings! Plus, for anyone who is burning to join a singing group or start one, Deke is offering to help free of charge. No joke! Listen in to get his personal email address! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

It’s an honor just to be nominated! Kevin and Jenna are back with a review of all the glitz and glamour of Hollywood’s booziest night, The Golden Globes! They dive into the new carpet layout, Nikki Glaser as a host, the real winners, show highlights, and what felt hokey and gross. Plus, they share their own experiences attending the Globes for Glee, including what happens during commercial breaks, standing on stage after winning an award, and the nominated films you should check out!For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

It's about aca-time! Kevin and Jenna are back with a look at the musical comedy that premiered during the height of Glee madness ... Pitch Perfect! Right off the bat, Kevin admits he wasn't feeling the movie back in the day, but shares what he thinks after rewatching it! They also break down their favorite performances, thoughts on the casting choices, jokes that did not age well, Glee similarities, and the scene that gave Jenna chills! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Happy 2026!    Kevin and Jenna are ringing in the new year with a good ol' catch-up sesh, including how they made it through the holidays, Kevin’s time on stage, the bug that is going around, and Kevin’s review of Darren Criss in Maybe Happy Ending!For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

What better way to kick off 2026 than with a smashing good time! Jenna and Kevin are taking a look back at the TV musical series, "Smash," often seen as Glee's "competition." They have plenty to say about the pilot episode! They compare their initial impressions of the show to their rewatch, the memories the audition scenes brought up for them, their thoughts on the original songs versus the covers, and what they thought was excellent about the show and what didn't quite work for them.For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Jenna and Kevin are ending the year on a high note! They share what they are grateful for, the musicals they are super excited to explore for the pod, book recommendations, favorite TV shows of the year, and New Year’s resolutions! Plus, the scoop on Jenna’s brand new upcoming podcast! For fun, exclusive content, and behind-the-scenes clips, follow us on Instagram @andthatswhatyoureallymissedpod & TikTok @thatswhatyoureallymissed!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.