Theory of Change podcast

Is America a developing country?

0:00
39:35
Spol 15 sekunder tilbage
Spol 15 sekunder frem
When all 193 United Nations member states adopted the Sustainable Development Goals in 2015, their defining breakthrough was universality. 

Unlike their predecessors, the SDGs were designed to apply to every nation, wealthy or poor. Yet more than a decade later, the United States remains one of only three countries in the world — alongside Myanmar and Haiti — that has never submitted a voluntary national review tracking its progress, according to Sarah Mendelson, a professor at Carnegie Mellon University and former U.S. government official.

“That's a really intentional list to be on for 10 years. I think that's really telling,” Mendelson said.

On the latest episode of Devex’s Theory of Change podcast, Mendelson explained why Washington has long resisted the idea that global development happens at home, too. She traces this blind spot to a bipartisan belief in American exceptionalism and a Cold War-era reluctance to treat health, housing, food, and clean water as fundamental human rights rather than commodities. 

While U.S. policymakers have historically viewed development as something America exports abroad, Mendelson argued that disaggregated data — when and where it exists — tells a very different story.

For example, while the aggregate life expectancy for American men sits at 76.5 years, that number drops to 65.9 for Black men in Chicago, 65.2 in Washington, D.C., and 62.2 in Memphis — putting outcomes in major U.S. cities on par with or behind countries receiving significant U.S. foreign assistance, such as Ethiopia (64.4) and Jordan (75.9), according to Mendelson’s research.

“We tell ourselves a story about America and American exceptionalism, which is not wholly wrong. ... But when you compare the United States on things like life expectancy, health outcomes, education, it's not a good story. There's a lot of hurt out there,” Mendelson said. “There's a lot of people experiencing serious socioeconomic deprivation."

Mendelson, who served as U.S. ambassador to the United Nations Economic and Social Council, said that when she was working on the Sustainable Development Goals agenda, she was contacted by Americans from Flint, Michigan, who wanted to understand how the SDGs might help them secure access to clean drinking water.

“I just paused because I thought, well, on the one hand, yes, this is absolutely how it's designed, but I don't know where in the American government there's going to be receptivity to this,” she said.

Following the dismantling of the U.S. Agency for International Development and recent U.S. midterm elections driven by domestic economic frustration, Mendelson argued that Washington can no longer afford to treat foreign assistance and domestic well-being as separate worlds. 

Instead of choosing between global leadership and an "America First" posture, she makes the case for rebuilding U.S. development capacity to operate both at home and abroad — connecting domestic communities to global innovations and finally embracing the SDG mandate to leave no one behind.

Flere episoder fra "Theory of Change"