The Harvard EdCast podcast

Cellphone Bans and Student Achievement: A Small Boost, a Bigger Question | Tom Kane

0:00
19:15
Spol 15 sekunder tilbage
Spol 15 sekunder frem

Strict cellphone bans in schools may give student achievement a small boost, adding the equivalent of one to two weeks of instruction each year, according to new research by Harvard economist Tom Kane.

The study, which analyzed data from 3 million students and thousands of schools, found that schools using lockable cellphone pouches saw greater academic growth than schools that did not restrict phone access.“What our results suggest today is, yes, cell phones in schools are having a negative impact, at least that's what our findings imply,” Kane says.

“Since 2013, there's been almost a whole grade equivalent loss in eighth grade math and reading. And what we find is that when you take phones away, you boost achievement growth per year by about half of the rate that it had been declining at,” he says.

Although the gains are modest, Kane points to the potential for academic growth to accumulate over time, and how these bans may offer a more cost-effective intervention for schools. The study found improvements in both math and reading, with similar effects across grade levels and student groups.

The research also raises a much bigger question: What role has social media use outside school played in the decline in student achievement? While researchers have been able to study the effects of restricting phones in classrooms, they have had little access to the data needed to connect students' social media use with academic outcomes.

Kane sees a recent settlement between states and Meta as a potential opportunity to close that gap, provided researchers can gain access to meaningful data on how young people use social media.

 “It could be that cell phone use out of school are having even bigger negative impacts, but we just don't have the data yet to be able to draw that link as clearly as we should be able to,” he says.

In this EdCast episode, Kane discusses what the new findings reveal about cellphone bans, why even modest gains in achievement matter, and what researchers still need to understand about the relationship between technology and learning.

In This Episode

·       Why student achievement has been declining since around 2013, and how that timeline overlaps with the rise of smartphone use among children

·       What a study of 3 million students across thousands of schools found about strict cellphone bans and academic achievement

·       Why cellphone bans produced a modest but meaningful boost equivalent to one or two additional weeks of instruction per year

·       What researchers learned about differences across grade levels, student groups, math, and reading

·       Why taking phones out of classrooms doesn't address the larger question of social media use outside school

·       How the settlement between states and Meta could create new opportunities to study the relationship between social media and student learning

·       What educators and policymakers should consider when implementing cellphone restrictions, including potential unintended consequences

Episode Timestamps

  • 00:00 Why researchers are connecting smartphones to declining student achievement
  • 02:00 What a study of 3 million students found about cellphone bans
  • 04:00 How much difference do cellphone bans actually make?
  • 06:30 What the research reveals about reading, math, and different student groups
  • 09:00 Why researchers still know so little about social media and student learning
  • 11:30 Are cellphone bans a cost-effective intervention for schools?
  • 14:00 What the Meta settlement could mean for future education research
  • 17:00 The bigger questions about phones, social media, and student learning

About the guest

Thomas J. Kane is the Walter H. Gale Professor of Education and Economics at the Harvard Graduate School of Education and faculty director of the Center for Education Policy Research. An economist, his research spans K–12 and higher education, including school accountability, teacher effectiveness, college access, and student achievement.

Learn more about the Harvard EdCast.

 

Flere episoder fra "The Harvard EdCast"