
Episode 5: Can we prevent suicides by writing letters?
In 1969, psychiatrist Jerome Motto began sending short, kind letters to people who had refused care after a suicidal crisis, and his results made “caring letters” one of the most cited ideas in suicide prevention. This month, the largest test ever, more than 227,000 veterans who called the Veterans Crisis Line, found the letters made no difference to suicide deaths. Dr. Tyler Black goes back to Motto’s original numbers, walks through the new JAMA Psychiatry study, and asks why the ideas we most want to work deserve our hardest look, with a few words for Zero Suicide along the way.
Notes and corrections noticed since recording:
* 1) I swapped the ages of the two study populations. Motto’s patients averaged about 34 years old; the veterans in the VCL trial averaged about 54.
* 2) The lead author of the VCL trials is Mark Reger, and the program serves callers to the Veterans Crisis Line.
* 3) On Motto’s statistics: on reflection, I think a survival test was a reasonable choice. The issue is that his significant result was one-tailed and limited to the first two years. The two-sided version of the same test gives roughly p = .09, and no version is significant over the full five years.
Reference list:Reger et al., Caring Letters and Suicide Mortality Among US Veterans Who Contacted the Veterans Crisis Line: A Prespecified Secondary Analysis, JAMA Psychiatry, 2026
Motto et al., A Randomized Controlled Trial of Postcrisis Suicide Prevention, Psychiatric Services, 2001
Reger et al., Caring Letters Sent by a Clinician or Peer to At-Risk Veterans: A Randomized Clinical Trial, JAMA Network Open, 2024
Carter et al., Postcards From the EDge Project: Randomised Controlled Trial of an Intervention Using Postcards to Reduce Repetition of Hospital Treated Deliberate Self Poisoning, BMJ, 2005
Luxton et al., Caring E-mails for Military and Veteran Suicide Prevention: A Randomized Controlled Trial, Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior, 2020
Comtois et al., Effect of Augmenting Standard Care for Military Personnel With Brief Caring Text Messages for Suicide Prevention: A Randomized Clinical Trial, JAMA Psychiatry, 2019
Skopp et al., Caring Contacts for Suicide Prevention: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis, Psychological Services, 2023
Zero Suicide Institute (Education Development Center), Evidence Base, zerosuicide.edc.org, accessed 2026
Get full access to Suicidology Data and Evidence at suicidology.substack.com/subscribe
Flere episoder fra "Clear Intent - Suicidology Data and Evidence"



Gå ikke glip af nogen episoder af “Clear Intent - Suicidology Data and Evidence” - abonnér på podcasten med gratisapp GetPodcast.



