
John Vervaeke’s Meaning Crisis and my Meaningness address similar issues in similar frameworks. Yet there seem significant differences!
Andrew Conner pinpointed some in his insightful essay “Is the ‘meaning crisis’ a real loss?”
Coincidentally, he was visiting Charlie Awbery and me at the time, so we were able to discuss it in person, and recorded a video of our conversation.
In addition to that, this post includes a section of links to relevant discussions elsewhere, assembled by Andrew; and a transcript in case you’d rather read than watch.
A follow-up post, going live next Saturday, explains bits I botched during the recording and we deleted from this video. It’s about ways metaphysics muddles our thinking, feeling, and acting. And, about how we perceive sacredness in the actual world—such as in a salt shaker.
Relevant discussions elsewhere
Primary sources
* John Vervaeke, Awakening from the Meaning Crisis (AftMC): YouTube playlist · series home · community transcripts
* David Chapman, Meaningness
* David Chapman, Meta-rationality
* Andrew Conner, Is the “meaning crisis” a real loss?
Chapman’s concepts, in the order they’re mentioned
* Eternalism: meaningness.com/eternalism: the stance that meanings must be perfectly definite
* Nihilism: meaningness.com/nihilism: the mirror-image stance, that since meanings aren’t perfectly definite, they don’t exist
* The complete stance: meaningness.com/meaningness: recognizing meaning as inseparably nebulous and patterned
* Nebulosity and pattern: meaningness.com/nebulosity
* No world beyond the actual one: https://meaningness.substack.com/p/this-is-it
* Stances trump systems: meaningness.com/stances-trump-systems
* Materialism (as stance): meaningness.com/materialism
* Textures of the complete stance: meaningness.com/textures-of-completion · wonder · curiosity · humor · play · enjoy-the-dance · creation
* Vision, Instruction, and Action (Chapman’s PhD thesis, lightly revised)
* Vividness: vividness.live · Approaching Vajrayana
* Nobility arc: table of contents
Vervaeke’s concepts, in the order they’re mentioned
* Relevance realization: Vervaeke, Lillicrap & Richards (2012), “Relevance Realization and the Emerging Framework in Cognitive Science,” J. Logic and Computation 22(1): Oxford Academic · open PDF
* Four P’s / Four Ways of Knowing (propositional, procedural, perspectival, participatory): Henriques overview · Vervaeke & Mastropietro, revised 4P paper
* DIME / Ecology of Practices (Dialogical, Imaginal, Mindfulness, Embodiment): Vervaeke Foundation EoP page
* Reverse-engineering enlightenment: AftMC Ep. 36 and Ep. 37
* The sacred as inexhaustibility: AftMC Ep. 35 develops it; Ep. 50 ties it together
* Cultural grammar: AftMC Ep. 38
* Serious play: AftMC Ep. 17 (Gnosis and Existential Inertia)
Developmental psychology, cognitive science
* Robert Kegan, The Evolving Self (1982): Harvard UP
* Robert Kegan, In Over Our Heads (1994): Harvard UP
* The frame problem: SEP: Frame Problem
* McCarthy & Hayes (1969): “Some Philosophical Problems from the Standpoint of Artificial Intelligence” (origin)
* Dennett (1984): “Cognitive Wheels: The Frame Problem of AI” (philosophical generalization)
Miscellaneous
* Adjective ordering (“clear blue sky” vs “blue clear sky”): Cambridge Grammar: order of adjectives · Wikipedia: English adjective order (the so-called “royal order of adjectives”)
* Bronze Age / Late Bronze Age Collapse: Bronze Age · Late Bronze Age collapse
Transcript
[Caveat: Generated by “AI,” inaccurate and in places misleading.]
[00:00:00] David: I thought maybe it would make sense for you to start by introducing your project here, what it is that you’re trying to do and why. And some background on John Vervaeke’s general project, because people may not be familiar with that.
[00:00:29] Andrew: So I encountered your writing and his writing around the same time. I would guess about five to six years ago. It was kind of a time where a lot of things were breaking for me, and so I found them both incredibly useful. John Vervaeke recorded a 50-hour lecture series called Awakening from the Meaning Crisis, and you have written many partial books, which are probably far more than 50 hours of reading.
In my mind they’re a little bit interleaved, and I found both of them very useful. Recently I wanted to figure out how your ideas interact. They’re both about the word “meaning” and different aspects of it. I think that both you and him have a diagnosis of what’s going on, and I wanted to understand how you saw each other’s ideas. I think I have a decent idea of the way you disagree, but you can correct me.
[00:01:46] David: So I don’t know Vervaeke’s work well at all. I read a few of his academic papers, and I watched, I think, two episodes of the 50-hour meaning crisis series. Then I read a lot of blog posts from other people about his work. So I have a quite diffuse sense of it. Something you mentioned when we were talking about this earlier is that he has developed his ideas in further directions, or maybe even a different direction, since the meaning crisis series. And neither of us, I think, is very clear on quite how he’s gone.
I thought it’d also be good to say that the Meaningness book I started working on 25 years ago, and I worked most of the ideas out during a six-month period when I was staying with Rin’dzin, who’s now Charlie, my now spouse —
Andrew: Congratulations.
David: Yeah, it’s great to be married to Charlie. On her kitchen table while she was off at work. This was when she was living in Bristol in the UK. So that book doesn’t really reflect my current understanding. It’s not that I disagree with anything or that I think it’s wrong, but there’s another 15-plus years of development since I put it on the web, which was in 2010 or 2012 or something like that. So we have two out-of-date understandings.
[00:03:58] Andrew: Try to merge two out-of-date understandings, right. And see how they go. So I had written a tweet thread that may go out as a tweet thread, or maybe this conversation, or something like that. Perhaps we could go through it. I can kind of summarize. I think it’s useful to speed-run his ideas. Maybe you can interject with your background.
The overall shape of his lecture series is that it’s a little bit entertaining. If you like watching him lecture, then it is an entertaining thing to watch. If you’ve never encountered the ideas, there’s a lot of learning. He’s knitting together thought from eastern, western, different branches of philosophy in very pleasant ways.
One way of looking at what he’s doing is this intellectually entertaining sort of thing. I think that understates what his goal was, but there’s intellectual understanding there. The first half is largely a history lesson and the second half is largely cognitive science. Maybe we could go through a little bit. Would that be good?
[00:05:22] David: And maybe I’ll throw in random, incoherent interjections periodically.
[00:05:28] Andrew: That’d be great. That’s what we signed up for: David Chapman random interjections.
I think looking back at his work, one of the fundamental things I realized is he believes we have lost something.
[00:05:43] David: So I’ll interject right at the beginning. I think maybe I’ll get to the substance of my objection a little later, but I think we haven’t lost something. I think we probably disagree already at this point. I think we’ve gained an enormous amount. We have enormously more sophisticated ideas about meaning, and how it works and what it is and how to work with it, than at any time in the past.
And the whole history that he tells — it’s great that he’s telling that history. It’s important to understand the history, to understand how we now understand meaning. But we’ve actually just accreted a whole lot of extra stuff. And there’s nothing that we’ve lost. A little later, I’ll get back to why I think he thinks that, and why I disagree.
[00:07:00] Andrew: So if he approaches from “we’ve lost something,” it makes sense to do two things. One, that motivates understanding: well, how did we get to where we are now? So that motivates t…
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit meaningness.substack.com/subscribe
Flere episoder fra "Meaningness Podcast"



Gå ikke glip af nogen episoder af “Meaningness Podcast” - abonnér på podcasten med gratisapp GetPodcast.








