
Summary:
Do you know your best five-second, one-minute or five-minute power, or are you basing almost all of your cycling training around FTP?
For many recreational and amateur cyclists, FTP becomes the number used to set training zones and measure progress. But one number can't necessarily tell you where your strengths and weaknesses sit across everything from a short sprint to a sustained effort.
In this episode of the Road Cycling Academy Podcast, Cam Nicholls is joined by RCA head coach Ryan Thomas to discuss the cycling peak power curve and why Ryan considers it one of the first things worth examining when assessing a cyclist.
Using a power meter and platforms such as TrainingPeaks, cyclists can look at their best power across durations ranging from a few seconds through to longer sustained efforts. Ryan explains how those numbers help build a picture of the rider's physiology and why simply relying on an estimated FTP can sometimes lead to inappropriate training intensities.
A major issue is whether the data actually contains maximal efforts. A cyclist who mostly completes structured workouts in ERG mode, for example, may never have produced a genuine all-out five-second sprint, one-minute effort or five-minute effort. In that situation, a model trying to estimate fitness from existing ride data may be working with an incomplete power curve.
Cam and Ryan discuss how critical power testing can provide a more useful picture without requiring cyclists to test every individual duration. Ryan explains the RCA approach, including a 10-second sprint, a three-minute maximal effort and a longer 12-minute effort, and why shorter and longer efforts can be used to help model critical power.
They also discuss why two cyclists with a similar threshold may need very different VO2 training prescriptions. One rider may have considerably more capacity above threshold than another, meaning a standard workout based purely on a percentage of FTP may be too easy for one cyclist and unsustainable for another.
Ryan also introduces W prime as another useful, although not perfectly precise, way of thinking about a cyclist's capacity to repeatedly work above critical power.
In this episode:
- What a cycling peak power curve actually shows
- Why Ryan looks at the power curve when assessing a cyclist
- Five-second, one-minute, five-minute and longer-duration power
- Why FTP doesn't describe every aspect of cycling performance
- Why you need a power meter to build a meaningful power curve
- How racing and bunch rides can produce different power data from structured workouts
- Why ERG mode may leave gaps in your peak power data
- How to tell whether your existing power curve is representative
- Why you don't need to test every point on the curve individually
- How critical power testing works
- RCA's 10-second sprint and three-minute maximal test
- Why Ryan uses a longer 12-minute effort
- When a five-minute maximal effort can provide additional information
- Why estimated or modelled FTP can sometimes be misleading
- How incorrect threshold settings affect your training zones
- Why VO2 power can differ substantially between riders with similar thresholds
- Why fixed percentages of FTP don't suit every cyclist
- What W prime can tell you about work above critical power
- How TrainingPeaks and Strava can help you examine your power data
- Why tracking more than FTP can provide additional ways to measure progress
For recreational cyclists, the practical takeaway isn't that FTP has no value. It's that FTP is only part of the picture. Understanding how your power changes across different durations can help identify strengths and weaknesses, make training targets more appropriate and give you additional ways to recognise progress.
Road Cycling Academy helps recreational and amateur cyclists train smarter, improve their performance and get more from the limited training time they have available.
For cyclists who want ongoing, personalised guidance, RCA coaching can help interpret individual strengths and weaknesses and use that information to make training more specific to the rider.
#CyclingTraining #CyclingPower #PowerMeter #FTP #CriticalPower #VO2Max #TrainingPeaks #CyclingPerformance #RoadCycling #RoadCyclingAcademy
Transcript:
Cam Nicholls (00:02)
Welcome to the RCA podcast, designed for recreational and amateur road cyclists with a focus on performance. We dive into cycling training, nutrition, strength training for cyclists and even bike fitting tips, all designed to help you train smarter, ride faster and hopefully tear your mates' legs off. So without further ado, let's dive into today's episode.
Welcome back to the RCA podcast, which is also on YouTube. Today I'm joined by the RCA's head coach, Ryan Thomas, and today we're going to be talking about, we believe, the most important graph for any cyclist, definitely more important than FTP.
And I think, well, you would know because you coach a lot of people, that not many people know what this is, or they don't spend a lot of time looking at it when it tells them a lot.
So much. If you're a rider wanting to be better, you should know this, shouldn't you?
Ryan Thomas (00:58)
100%. Yeah. The context, we onboard members all the time doing off-the-shelf programs.
And first thing I would go into is the TrainingPeaks dashboard. I'll go in and I'll look at the peak power chart and I'll say, oh yeah, looks good. Compare it to this year versus last year, and then go in and look at threshold and see if threshold's right.
Measure it, like see the zones. But the first thing is look at the peak power chart.
Cam Nicholls (01:21)
Okay. So for those out there that don't know what a peak power chart is, I know we're going to go into a fair bit more detail here, but just at a high level, like what is it?
Ryan Thomas (01:30)
It's essentially, you can choose the date range, but it's...
Cam Nicholls (01:30)
You need a power meter.
Ryan Thomas (01:30)
You need a power meter. And it's the, in TrainingPeaks, it's the peak powers that you have produced across their ranges.
So five seconds, 10 seconds, 12 seconds, 20 seconds. And it's not every, it's not very specific. It's like one minute, five minutes, six minutes, 10 minutes, 12 minutes, 20 minutes, 60 minutes.
It essentially plots a curve based on your...
Cam Nicholls (01:30)
Does it go all the way out to two or three hours if you want?
Ryan Thomas (01:30)
Yeah, it goes, yeah. That part of the curve is probably not as important.
It's more the under 60 minutes that's the critical one as it defines the physiology of the rider type.
But yeah, it's super important if you want to know, you will know what type of rider you are, but as a coach or someone looking into it, or you don't know what your peak five-minute power is, how do you do a five-minute effort, for example, or a 20-minute? You don't know what that number is.
A lot of people will know those two, five and 20, but what's your one-minute or your 30-second or three minutes, for example? It's very specific to what type of rider you are.
Cam Nicholls (02:34)
So that's a good segue. Well, why bother understanding your numbers across those segments?
Essentially they...
If you're a recreational amateur, and you sit out there and you're watching this video and you're like, no, I'm not going to bother because it's too much hard work.
I've got to go do all these tests. I don't need to figure this out. What would you say to that person?
Ryan Thomas (02:57)
I'd say you're not training the right areas if you don't know what your peak powers are across those curves.
It depends on what type of rider you are, whether you're a rider that trains or you're a rider that does bunch rides, racing, two very different people in terms of what that curve looks like.
A rider that just trains, let's say, I'll just pull a generic one out, someone who does AI programs or chooses a program online, and they just do specific workouts.
They're never going all out.
Cam Nicholls (03:27)
Zwift workouts is a very popular one.
Ryan Thomas (03:29)
Zwift workouts.
They just go on and choose a workout. It's in ERG mode, never going all out. You're not doing racing.
That power curve is not going to represent the rider type you are because you've never done a five-second sprint, or you've never done a one-minute, five-minute all-out effort.
Cam Nicholls (03:42)
You might've done one 10 years ago.
Ryan Thomas (03:47)
Or five years ago, but not racing.
It's not representative of the rider you are today.
Someone who's racing or doing bunch rides, they're going all out for certain durations, might have a better idea in that curve.
More often than not, people who are coming to the RCA, I'll look at the curve and I'm like, your threshold setting's 250, but the highest power you've ever done for 20 minutes is 200.
Why is your threshold at 250 watts? That's an example, even if you're doing one-minute efforts. What's your one-minute peak power?
I don't know. What do you do on these efforts?
Cam Nicholls (04:20)
In order for somebody to understand their peak powers, if they haven't really done this before, and they want to go, I want to get a little bit more accurate with my training, and I want to understand what rider type that I am.
Am I actually, I think I'm better at VO2 than threshold, but I don't really test it.
Would you recommend that they spend a week going out and doing an all-out five-second, then a 10-second, and then a one-minute, and then a three-minute, and then just following the TrainingPeaks cycle?
Because I know some people might have this information. I mean, you would know better than me.
What percentage of people, recreationals, come to you and you look at their data, they've never done structured training before.
They're about to start. You look at their peak powers. You're like, okay, you've got a good picture there.
Ryan Thomas (05:03)
One to 2%.
Cam Nicholls (05:05)
Oh, okay. Very, very few.
Ryan Thomas (05:06)
Very little. Very little.
Cam Nicholls (05:10)
A lot of people... Do they then have an idea of what they think they're good at? They must.
Ryan Thomas (05:15)
Yeah, they do.
Cam Nicholls (05:17)
Okay. Is it normally accurate once you've actually figured it out?
Ryan Thomas (05:22)
Yeah, to some extent. It depends on the type of rider. If they're a trainer or a racer, depends what type of their goals are with riding, essentially.
But yeah, you don't necessarily need to go out and pick every point along that curve and do a maximum effort.
There's testing we can do that plots that curve. That's the whole point of critical power testing, essentially, is we choose three, four, five parameters, two parameters, and it mimics that curve based on the two to three markers we put on that curve.
Cam Nicholls (05:56)
Yeah. You only normally practically, because you think it's most practical for recreational and amateurs with critical power testing, which is essentially another way to get your threshold estimate.
We throw FTP, as you said, throw it in the bin.
We're now going to look at critical power. So critical power gives us that threshold estimate, but it also gives us a rough idea of this power curve.
From your experiences, three is probably what they say online, but you say you can get away with just doing two tests across two days, and that'll give you a pretty good feel for your power graph without having to go do all the tests.
So why do you say just the two and what are the two tests?
Ryan Thomas (06:37)
The two tests, the first test has two maximum efforts in it, but it's not used within the critical power model.
So the first test that we do in the RCA is a 10-second sprint and a three-minute maximum effort in one session with a long recovery in there.
The 10-second sprint gives us your five-second peak power.
That'll tell us your peak neuromuscular capacity. If you've got a lower threshold, where does that sit and how does that curve look? It's essentially how steep is the top end of that curve versus if it's a four.
Three-minute is your anaerobic VO2 estimate in between, and then the other test on the next day, we would do a 12-minute effort.
Okay. We have a critical power testing week, RCA testing week that I use, and I have a five-minute in there as well.
But my experience, the five-minute peak power within the critical power, if we have a three and a 12, that five-minute power, it changes the middle.
So if we think about what's happening at the other two ends, it only moves it up a tiny bit. It's like plus or minus five watts to the five-minute.
So if you're motivated to do three, then yeah, do the third. If you're not, then I don't think it makes massive.
Cam Nicholls (07:50)
Yeah. Okay. And you were saying as well, last time we spoke about this, it doesn't have to be exactly three minutes.
So if somebody has got a segment, which is like a climb and it's going to take them two minutes, 45.
And if someone's got a longer climb, but it's not 12, it's eight minutes, 43. That's fine.
You can use this and we'll link to a calculator below where you put in the timestamp and then you put in the wattage and then it will calculate your critical power.
Ryan Thomas (08:16)
Yeah. So there's general parameters, like the people who created this, the critical power and critical speed, it's been around for a long time, but there's general parameters around if you're just using two, what sort of durations you want.
And we use three minutes because it works well.
Three and 12 minutes was the first ones that they came up with.
Cam Nicholls (08:36)
Oh, okay.
Ryan Thomas (08:37)
Just align really well with how that curve sits.
But I would recommend anywhere from two to four minutes for the shorter effort and anywhere above 10.
Getting below 10 minutes starts to mess it up a little bit, I would say, because it's not quite long enough to see what's happening there.
I'd say over 10 minutes, 10 to 20.
Cam Nicholls (08:58)
Today's podcast is brought to you by the Road Cycling Academy's Weight Training for Cyclists program.
And if you're listening from the Northern Hemisphere, now is a very good time to start thinking about strength training as you head towards the winter months and begin building towards next season.
Because if you do strength training right, you're looking at about a five to 10% gain.
But the problem many recreational cyclists face is they know they should be lifting weights, but they're not sure what exercises to do, how heavy to lift, nor how to fit strength work around their cycling.
And that's exactly why we have created this program with Dr. Aaron Turner, a strength and conditioning specialist with 20 years of experience working with athletes, including elite-level cyclists.
In our program, you'll get a beginner, intermediate and advanced strength program, all downloadable, backed by six detailed video tutorials, and then 60 individual exercise video demonstrations, showing you exactly what to do and how to integrate it with your riding.
The goal is simple, more power, better durability and improved efficiency on the bike.
And you'll get lifetime access to this program for only $147 USD, backed by our money-back guarantee.
If you're keen, head to the Road Cycling Academy website and check out our Weight Training for Cyclists program.
Now let's get back to the podcast.
Okay. So once you work with recreational amateurs, they haven't done this before, they do the tests and then maybe they're, you know, a few months in and they might be doing some other power numbers.
So they're getting a better feel for what their graph looks like, their power curve graph. What is it? Are they interested in it?
Is it changing the way that they see things?
Obviously it changes the way that you coach them because you can train more accurately to the zones and you can get a better feel for how they're improving over time relative to not just FTP, but all these other numbers.
Ryan Thomas (11:03)
Yes.
Cam Nicholls (11:03)
So that's great that you can see that, but what's most, what's of most interest to them?
Ryan Thomas (11:03)
I think it gives, like you just said, it gives them another parameter to improve on.
So a lot of people, a lot of people will come and they'll know their threshold number, whether it's accurate or not, they'll know a rough threshold number.
But if you ask them, what's your best one-minute power, they'll have no idea.
And if we say, well, let's test it, let's try and improve it. Oh, cool. Like it's something, it's motivation.
It's something extra to test and track and follow.
And even if it's on TrainingPeaks, they go and do a bunch ride and there's a, in TrainingPeaks, you'll get notified if you get an all-time best or a 2026 best across that curve, but you only get notified for specific durations.
But as a coach, I can go in and look at that peak power curve and I can say, oh, that was, you don't get notified on your 12-minute best, but I'm letting you know that this was your 12-minute best effort for 2026, or this was your best two-minute for 2026.
Oh, that's awesome. I didn't know that. I'm going to look at that more often.
So making them aware of it gives them motivation to track those.
Cam Nicholls (12:05)
Tangible improvements that they can now actually understand.
Ryan Thomas (12:08)
Yeah. And if you're not looking at it or you're not just looking at the notifications that whatever platform you're using sends you, you may not be getting the whole picture.
So as a coach, I see that because I say, awesome, well done.
That was your best three-minute or two-minute, which isn't a notification in any system.
That's your best two-minute power for the last six months or last year or last two years.
And they're like, oh, what really? That's awesome.
Cam Nicholls (12:33)
Yep. Okay. And then just to round out in terms of the training side of things, you say that people get more accurate with their zones, but most people out there will either have an estimated FTP from an app, AI tool, whatever it might be, or they might've done an FTP test.
They've done a 20-minute test. Okay. This now enables them to get more accurate with their training.
Why is that?
Ryan Thomas (12:58)
Because your zones are set correctly.
I have a big gripe with AI-detected threshold zones because I mentioned in the start of this, it assumes that the efforts that you've done are maximal.
And if they're not maximal, then they're very incorrect.
So an example for myself at the moment, so even TrainingPeaks has this in their new Analyze360.
If you've got premium, you go into the power and it'll predict what your modelled FTP is.
If you haven't done any maximum efforts across any of the power curve, it's going to spit you out a threshold number based on the maximum efforts that you've done or the peak powers that it reads.
At the moment, it's telling me my threshold is 290 watts and it's 40, 50 watts off what I know my threshold is.
It's because I haven't done any maximal efforts. I've just been riding easy.
I've been doing some threshold efforts, a couple of Zone 2, but if you're coming into training and you're doing training based off this modelled power, you might be 10% lower on your threshold.
You're not training any zone accurately.
So you're just not training hard enough, essentially.
Or you're training too hard. It's two parts of the picture there.
So coming in, doing proper testing, critical power testing, the 20-minute test is good and it'll give you a good threshold number to base your zones off, but critical power gives us more data to go off.
But if you come in and you set that threshold zone properly, you're going to be training properly.
You're going to be training hard enough to get a stimulus in the areas that we're trying to get it out of.
Cam Nicholls (14:30)
Yeah. One of the examples that I like in this space is, you know, I speak to a lot of people on a Performance Breakthrough Call and they haven't done this process before.
So they're kind of assuming, and often they're correct, that I really struggle with the sustained efforts, the 20-minute FTP efforts.
But then when I do my VO2, it feels too easy. Like I'm getting through it too easy.
And it's like, well, maybe your VO2, if you've done the proper testing, could actually be higher because you're more genetically gifted for whatever reason at VO2, but therefore it should be higher.
So I think that's a great example.
I know there's a lot of people out there that experience that. My VO2 is a lot better than my threshold.
And so when I do VO2 efforts, I train harder than what my FTP calculator suggests.
Ryan Thomas (15:21)
Exactly. Yeah.
And if you're training based on a percentage of threshold, percentage of critical power for VO2 stuff, it can be wrong.
Someone did yesterday, for example, I got an email from a Mileage Club member and he just did a five-minute maximum effort.
He did an RCA testing week because he hadn't done one for a while.
He did his five-minute peak power and his percentage, his five-minute peak power was 114% of his critical power, which is quite low.
So going through a program, if he's got four- to five-minute efforts set at 120% threshold, he's going to go out with that and he's going to fail pretty hard because it's not appropriate.
Cam Nicholls (16:00)
Yeah. And probably then probably won't do it.
And the consistency comes into play and it's just a domino.
Ryan Thomas (16:04)
Yeah. So the W prime number is another one that comes into important factor here with the critical power testing.
It gives us an idea of how big that battery is, how big your anaerobic or glycolytic energy system is, how many times can you dip above critical power and sustain it and go harder and harder and harder.
So 30/15s are a good example.
I imagine that someone like yourself has got a good high VO2 capacity or someone who's got a big W prime number, they can go much harder in those 30/15s than someone who's got a lower peak five-minute power relative to their critical power.
They might only be doing it 110%, where you could probably do 130%.
So very different.
And that's where RPE, maximal efforts, knowing what those peak powers are, what that W prime is.
W prime isn't 100% accurate, but it gives us an idea on how big that tank is and we can track it and we can see what's actually happening.
Cam Nicholls (16:59)
Yeah.
Ryan Thomas (17:00)
Yeah. As a coach, the data isn't always 100% accurate.
It gives us really good guidelines on where we go and how we track what's happening, what sort of prescriptions we set for maximal efforts and VO2 efforts and threshold efforts and what's actually appropriate for that rider.
Because one size fits all isn't always the best.
Cam Nicholls (17:20)
It goes well and truly beyond estimated FTP, essentially what you're saying there.
So if people are out there listening, they're like, yeah, I wouldn't mind, you know, looking at my peak power graph, at least as a first step.
Would they be best to jump onto TrainingPeaks for this?
Ryan Thomas (17:35)
Yes.
Cam Nicholls (17:35)
And just import some historical data?
Ryan Thomas (17:37)
Yeah. You can look at it on Strava. You can see that on Strava.
Cam Nicholls (17:40)
Okay.
Ryan Thomas (17:40)
And look at it and have a think, like, have a look at the curve and say, well, this looks pretty flat actually.
Maybe I haven't done a five-second sprint.
Or think about, no, I've never done a five-second sprint on fresh legs or a 10-second sprint on fresh legs.
So maybe that curve isn't accurate.
Maybe I need to go and do that or I need to retest that and see what's happening.
Cam Nicholls (17:59)
Get to know yourself a little bit better.
Ryan Thomas (18:00)
Yeah. And more often than not, honestly, the first thing that people are going to think is actually no, I've never done a sprint on fresh legs.
I don't actually know what my peak power is.
I've never done a sprint.
More often than not, that's the area that people don't know.
Interesting.
All right. Well, thanks very much for your time, Ryan.
No worries.
Cam Nicholls (18:21)
A lot of meat on the bone there for people to digest. And we'll catch everyone in the next podcast.
Flere episoder fra "Road Cycling Academy Podcast"



Gå ikke glip af nogen episoder af “Road Cycling Academy Podcast” - abonnér på podcasten med gratisapp GetPodcast.








