Wicked Is Overrated (So We Fixed It)

Send us Fan MailThis week on Broadway Besties, we're making a confession that might get us banned from the Gershwin Theatre: we think Wicked is overrated.Before the pitchforks come out, hear us out. Mark and Carson take on the impossible challenge of completely recasting and reimagining one of Broadway's biggest blockbusters. From dream Elphabas and Fieros to directors, designers, and even songs we'd tweak, nothing is safe.Would a fresh cast breathe new life into Oz? Are there Broadway stars who would've been better fits all along? And is Wicked still the untouchable masterpiece many claim it is?We're risking our Broadway credibility and having a lot of fun doing it.Grab your broomstick, prepare your angry comments, and join us as we ask the question:If Wicked opened tomorrow, who should actually be in it? 🎭💚

Send us Fan MailThis week on Broadway Besties, Mark and Carson sit down with the incredibly talented Casey Garvin for a conversation that is funny, inspiring, heartfelt, and completely unforgettable.Known for his charisma, talent, and undeniable charm, Casey opens up about his journey, the challenges he has faced, and the experiences that have shaped both the performer and the person he is today. From life on and around the stage to the lessons learned along the way, Casey shares a side of himself that audiences don't always get to see.This episode is packed with laughter, honesty, Broadway stories, and moments that will leave you feeling inspired. Whether you're a theater lover or simply someone who appreciates a great story, Casey proves that the most compelling performances often happen offstage.Join us for an unforgettable conversation with one of Broadway's brightest personalities.

Send us Fan MailThis week on Broadway Besties, Mark and Carson are diving headfirst into Broadway's biggest night: the 2026 Tony Awards!From the jaw-dropping performances and emotional acceptance speeches to the shocking snubs, surprise wins, and a few moments that left us scratching our heads, nothing is off limits.We break down Pink's debut as host, discuss whether Schmigadoon! deserved its Best Musical win, celebrate the incredible success of Ragtime, The Lost Boys, and Death of a Salesman, and share our thoughts on the performances, the fashion, and the moments everyone will be talking about all week.Did the voters get it right? Which winners thrilled us? Which decisions left us frustrated? And what moments will be remembered long after the curtain came down?Whether you watched every second of the broadcast or you're just catching up on Broadway's biggest headlines, we've got you covered with plenty of laughs, strong opinions, and a whole lot of theater love.Grab your Playbill and join us for our annual Tony Awards deep dive as we discuss the good, the bad, and yes... the ugly.

Send us Fan MailThis week on Broadway Besties, we are diving headfirst into the 2026 Tony Award nominations, the surprises, the shockers, the chaos, and of course…the snubs. From shows and performers we cannot believe were left out to the nominations that have Broadway fans completely divided, we break down everything you need to know before theater’s biggest night. We debate who deserved more love, who may have been overhyped, and which nominations could completely change the Tony race moving forward. Plus, our hottest takes, passionate rants, and the moments that made us scream at our phones when the nominations dropped. If you love Broadway drama, awards season madness, and unfiltered theater opinions, this is the episode for you.

Send us Fan MailThis week on Broadway Besties, Mark makes a bold (and possibly regrettable) decision… he hands the reins over to Carson. And from that moment on, it’s chaos, comedy, and just a little bit of fear. 😳Carson takes us deep behind the curtain, spilling the kind of Broadway secrets you definitely don’t hear about at the stage door. From backstage madness to the things performers really deal with, this is Broadway like you’ve never heard it before.Mark? Still not recovered.Carson? Fully in control. (Which should concern everyone.)If you love Broadway and live for the drama behind it… this episode is a must. 🎭

Send us Fan MailThis week on Broadway Besties, Mark and Carson take on the ultimate theater lover debate… recasting some of Broadway’s most iconic shows. From Next to Normal to Les Misérables to Rent, nothing is off limits as they dream up their ideal casts, make some bold choices, and probably spark a little controversy along the way. Expect strong opinions, unexpected picks, and a lot of “wait… actually that works” moments. The real question is… did they get it right, or are they about to be completely canceled by theater fans?

Send us Fan MailThis week on Broadway Besties, Mark and Carson sit down with the incredibly talented Preston Taylor for a conversation that’s equal parts inspiring, hilarious, and unapologetically real. From his journey into the world of theater to the moments that shaped him as a performer, Preston pulls back the curtain on what it really takes to make it in Broadway and beyond.Expect behind-the-scenes stories, honest talk about the highs and lows of the industry, and a few laugh-out-loud moments you won’t see coming. Plus, Preston shares his dream roles, hot takes on theater today, and what’s next for him as he continues to rise.Whether you're a die-hard theater fan or just love a good story, this is an episode you won’t want to miss.

Send us Fan MailBroadway Besties welcomes Carson Twitchell as an official host this week, and the chaos begins instantly. Mark tests Carson with controversial Broadway takes, dream role debates, and some truly bizarre Mark logic that only this podcast could produce. By the time Mark reveals his own dream role, Carson’s reaction says it all. Welcome to Broadway Besties.

Send us Fan MailIt’s a brand new chapter for Broadway Besties. This week, Mark introduces listeners to Carson Twitchell, a passionate Broadway superfan, sharp opinion-holder, and the newest voice joining the show as co-host. From the shows that shaped him to the performers he worships (and the ones he definitely does not), Carson doesn’t hold back. The two dive into favorite musicals, controversial takes, dream revivals, and the hot opinions that will either unite fans or start a full-blown theater war. Plus, Mark and Carson discover where they’re perfectly in sync and where they completely clash. It’s funny, honest, a little chaotic, and the perfect kickoff to a fresh era of Broadway Besties.

Send us Fan MailThis week on Broadway Besties, we’re spilling our hottest Broadway opinions with zero filter. The shows we swear are overrated. The performances that deserve more love. The casting choices we still can’t understand. And yes, we’re ready to defend every take. Grab your Playbill and buckle up, because friendships may be tested and theater fans may gasp. It’s hot takes, big laughs, and pure Broadway chaos.