Almost Cast: The Broadway What-Ifs

Send us a textThis week on Broadway Besties, Amy is MIA, but Mark is here to boop things up with a one-on-one interview with the talented Christian Probst! Currently rocking the stage in Boop the Musical, Christian is a Yale grad who’s starred in some of Mark’s absolute favorite shows—and let’s just say, Mark tried really hard to find something wrong with him, but guess what? He couldn’t! (Yes, you heard that right—zero flaws. We’re all jealous.) From his Broadway journey to his hilarious behind-the-scenes stories, Christian brings all the charm, wit, and talent you could ever ask for. Get ready for a conversation full of laughs, Broadway tea, and maybe a little envy from Mark’s end!

Send us a textEver wonder what Broadway history could have looked like? In this week’s episode, Mark and Amy spill the tea on all the what-ifs and almosts—diving into the stars who turned down some of the most iconic roles in musical theatre history. 😱From powerhouse performers who almost defied gravity to legends who passed on parts that later won Tonys, we reimagine what these shows would have been like with a totally different cast. Who said no? Why did they pass? And would the roles have had the same magic?Get ready for a whirlwind of behind-the-scenes buzz, wild speculation, and our signature bestie banter as we ask the ultimate question: Would Broadway ever be the same? 🎤✨

Send us a textThis week on Broadway Besties, we’re flipping the script and putting you, our Besties, front and center! We opened up the stage for your burning questions, and you certainly delivered. From behind-the-scenes stories about how we fell head over heels for musical theater, to our personal favorite show-stopping numbers, this episode is brimming with all the bits and pieces you’ve been dying to know.We reminisce about our earliest Broadway influences—like stumbling across original cast albums in our parents’ vinyl collection—and share the moments that made us realize we absolutely had to be part of the magic of the stage. You’ll also hear plenty of juicy off-stage mishaps that taught us the tried-and-true motto: “The show must go on!”But that’s not all: In true Broadway Besties fashion, we’re leaving you with a curated playlist of the must-download show tunes that capture the spirit of this episode. Expect powerhouse ballads, toe-tapping ensemble numbers, and a few hidden gems that will have you belting out tunes all week long.So if you’re ready to laugh, learn a little more about our journeys, and fall even deeper in love with Broadway, then don’t miss this special Q&A episode! And don’t forget to grab those new favorite songs we’re recommending. Prepare your playlists—because once you hear them, you’ll be hitting “repeat” faster than you can say, “Places, please!”

Send us a textThis week on Broadway Besties, we are thrilled to welcome the one and only Andy Karl! Now dazzling audiences as the Duke in Moulin Rouge, Andy takes us on a journey through his incredible career, from Rocky to Groundhog Day to his unforgettable turns on Broadway.We dive into what drew him to Moulin Rouge, his thoughts on playing such a deliciously villainous role, and some behind-the-scenes moments you won’t hear anywhere else. And let’s just say—one of Andy’s stories had Mark on the verge of hurling. No spoilers, but you need to hear this one for yourself.Laughter, nostalgia, and plenty of Broadway magic—this episode has it all! Listen now wherever you get your podcasts!

Send us a textThis week on Broadway Besties, Amy and Mark dive into the exciting world of Broadway musicals making their way to the big (and small) screen! Of course, we can’t talk about stage-to-screen adaptations without mentioning Wicked: Part Two—because, let’s be real, we need to know how they’ll handle As Long As You’re Mine and No Good Deed! But that’s just the beginning.They also discuss Little Shop of Horrors and what we can expect from the upcoming adaptation of the cult classic. Plus, what other shows are making the leap to Hollywood? Listen in as they break it all down and, of course, throw in their own wishlist of musicals that absolutely need to get the cinematic treatment (looking at you, Ragtime).Tune in for all the Broadway-to-Hollywood buzz, hot takes, and a few dream castings along the way!

Send us a textIt’s our one-year anniversary, and this episode is so incredibly special! We’re taking a stroll down memory lane, reminiscing on the wild ride that has been Broadway Besties. From big fights (yes, we went there) to huge successes, we’re spilling it all.We are beyond grateful for the love and support you’ve given us—because of YOU, our videos have racked up over 500 million views on Instagram, we’ve grown to over 200K followers, and our podcast has become the ultimate gift.And if year one was this incredible, we can’t even imagine what year two has in store! We have so many exciting things planned, and we cannot wait to keep growing, laughing, and celebrating Broadway with all of you. Cheers to another year, besties! 🥂✨

Send us a textIn the thrilling conclusion of our two-part interview, Salisha Thomas returns to Broadway Besties with a massive announcement that’s sure to set the theater world abuzz! We dive deeper into her Broadway journey, from Beautiful to Once Upon a One More Time, while dishing out more of our unfiltered takes on life in the spotlight. Don’t miss the moment we’ve all been waiting for—and find out what Salisha’s next big move means for her fans, Broadway lovers, and beyond!

Send us a textThis week on Broadway Besties, we welcome the fabulous Salisha Thomas for part one of our two-part episode! Salisha shares behind-the-scenes gems from her time in Beautiful and the sparkling musical Once Upon a One More Time. We also serve up our unfiltered thoughts on all things Broadway—but is the most shocking tea spilled in this episode or the next? You’ll have to listen in to find out! Tune in for plenty of laughs, insider stories, and a sneak peek into the glamorous (and sometimes dramatic) world behind the curtain. Be sure to catch this first installment, and get ready for the big reveal in part two!

Send us a text  This week, Broadway Besties is thrilled to welcome the one and only *Seth Rudetsky*! A true Broadway legend, Seth embodies everything we love about the Great White Way: passion, talent, and a boundless love for the theater. Join us as we dive into Seth's incredible career, from his work as a pianist, writer, and producer to his unparalleled storytelling as the host of *Seth’s Big Fat Broadway* and *Stars in the House*. Get ready for behind-the-scenes anecdotes, hilarious Broadway stories, and Seth's take on the state of modern musical theater. Plus, we'll put Seth to the test with some rapid-fire Broadway trivia—spoiler alert: he’s probably unbeatable. Whether you’re a seasoned theater aficionado or just dipping your toes into Broadway fandom, this episode is packed with laughs, inspiration, and everything that makes Broadway sparkle.  You won't want to miss it!

Send us a textThis week on Broadway Besties, we’re taking a magical journey to the land of Oz with a deep dive into all things Wicked: The Movie! From casting excitement to behind-the-scenes buzz, we discuss every detail we know so far about the highly anticipated film. Plus, we have some wickedly fun surprises in store to keep you spellbound. Whether you’re Team Elphaba or Team Glinda, this is an episode no fan of Oz—or Broadway—will want to miss!