We Are Not Saved podcast

What is Our Hamas? (Or Existential Risk Surprise)

0:00
14:31
15 Sekunden vorwärts
15 Sekunden vorwärts

I.

While listening to a recent podcast discussing the events of 10/7 I heard something that really stuck with me. The guest on the podcast explained how Israel had spent the vast majority of their planning and espionage resources on Hezbollah and Iran. This is why, when the time came, they had the brilliant pager and walkie-talkie attack already prepped. Additionally, they had a clear plan for invading southern Lebanon and for striking Iran.

By contrast, they spent very little of their planning and espionage resources on Hamas. The border was lightly defended, mostly relying on fancy and ultimately fallible electronic warnings. And they further assumed that Hamas had been "bought off"—that they were too addicted to the money coming in to do anything radical. This assumption ran so deeply that they dismissed the Jericho Wall document, which, in retrospect, laid out Hamas' entire plan. As such, they were completely surprised by 10/7. And even after the smoke cleared they had no real plan for invading Gaza. This led to a few weeks of delays while they come up with one, and even then they were forced to make up a lot of it as they went along.

This lesson felt like a metaphor for our own approach to large-scale risk. What is our Hezbollah? And what is our Hamas? What risks are getting a lot of attention, and what risks are being ignored?

It's easy to name our "Hezbollah". AI is currently completely dominating our discussion of risk, particularly existential risk. Arguably it's sucking up all the air in the room. In pointing this out, I'm not saying that's inappropriate. Hezbollah was a genuine risk to Israel, but even so it was Hamas who irrevocably pierced the Israeli psyche. And this brings me to my point. It's harder to name our "Hamas", but this identification may be equally important. And I'm willing to wager that when the history of 21st-century disasters is written, just like with Israel, our "Hamas" will end up being more important than our "Hezbollah". 

To be clear, this is my read on the subject. I don't have a crystal ball. Nevertheless, many people sense that civilization is reaching a point of critical fragility. Let's say you're one of them and you think something catastrophic (but not necessarily total extinction) is likely to happen before 2100—say in the next 75 years. Options for what might happen include nuclear war, an intentional pandemic, a gigantic financial crisis, etc. Now imagine that you're pretty pessimistic (I am) and that you place the chances of something like this happening at greater than 50%. Well then if your AI P(doom) is less than 25% then you should be willing to wager that "when the history of 21st-century disasters is written" something else will end up being more important than AI. Obviously these numbers are very crude, but I think you get the point: our doom may come from a direction we should be paying more attention to.

So, what is our "Hamas"? What do we risk being blindsided by while all of our attention is focused on AI?

 

Weitere Episoden von „We Are Not Saved“