Theory of Change podcast

Why Republicans turned on USAID

0:00
1:01:40
15 Sekunden vorwärts
15 Sekunden vorwärts
When former USAID Administrator Andrew Natsios looks at the recent dismantling of the agency he once led, he sees both a national security crisis and a bitter irony. 

While Natsios believes U.S. foreign aid was due for a major overhaul, he blames a combination of pressures from outside the agency for undermining America’s commitment to long-term development. It was not the agency’s own failings that left it vulnerable, but a series of “clashes” between development and other power structures inside the U.S. government.

Speaking on Devex’s Theory of Change podcast, he argued that the growth of the federal “counterbureaucracy” — oversight entities such as the Office of Management and Budget and rigid Federal Acquisition Regulations — paralyzed the agency long before it was formally disassembled. By forcing development officers to produce short-term quantifiable outputs and spend money rapidly, Washington made genuine, multiyear institution building nearly impossible.

“What they’re asking us to do is two things which are diametrically opposed,” Natsios argued. 

By demanding instant statistical proof of success while berating the agency for not offloading programs to partner governments, the counterbureaucracy trapped the U.S. Agency for International Development in an impossible double bind, Natsios said. The Republican former politician led the agency from 2001 to 2006, during the George W. Bush administration.

His forthcoming book, “Guns Are Not Enough: Foreign Aid in the National Interest,” provides an intellectual framework for understanding how the U.S. development bureaucracy worked — and why it often didn’t.

Natsios rejected the idea that Elon Musk’s dismantling of USAID through the Department of Government Efficiency was about government effectiveness or balancing the budget. Instead, he sees it as another example of backlashes that tend to follow socioeconomic crises in American history.

“All of those previous events in American history were accompanied by massive isolationist, anti-immigrant, ultranationalist, protectionist, high tariff trends in American politics,” he said.

He also shared his own theory for why U.S. foreign aid efforts struggle to garner public support from Americans — and his own experience accompanying the conservative media commentator Rush Limbaugh on an eye-opening trip to Afghanistan.

Looking ahead, Natsios insisted that piecemeal fixes under the U.S. State Department will fail. Instead, he called for the creation of a cabinet-level, independent department that unifies the U.S. International Development Finance Corporation, the Millennium Challenge Corporation, and global health programs into a single operational agency. 

Natsios sees Cold War-era breakthroughs such as the Green Revolution and South Korea's economic transformation as proof that America’s development work succeeded precisely when its mission directors had operational autonomy and field-level authority.

Weitere Episoden von „Theory of Change“