eCommerce Podcast podcast

Why the 30% Email Revenue Rule Is Wrong

0:00
45:00
15 Sekunden vorwärts
15 Sekunden vorwärts

Email and SMS agency founder Alex Moulart has spent years watching ecommerce brands chase a single number, 30% of revenue from email, and he's come to believe it's mostly a figure platforms report rather than a target anyone should actually aim for.

Summary

Alex Moulart runs email and SMS marketing for DTC ecommerce brands through his agency, AMM. In this conversation with Matt Edmundson, he unpicks where the "email should be 30% of revenue" benchmark actually comes from and why it rarely reflects what's really happening in a business. Alex isn't a developer, but over the past year he's used AI tools, API connections, and the Klaviyo and Omnisend MCPs to build his own forecasting dashboards, ones that calculate each brand's own historical, seasonally adjusted benchmark instead of a generic industry figure. He walks through the four metric groups he actually tracks, explains how flat revenue-share targets can damage list health without anyone noticing, and shares a surprising segmentation finding about how long a new subscriber stays interested.

Key points and timestamps:

  • 07:55 Where the 30% email revenue benchmark actually came from
  • 14:42 Building a forecasting engine to find a brand's real benchmark
  • 18:48 The four metric groups worth tracking instead
  • 24:28 Why the first 30 days matter more than anyone expects

Where the 30% Email Revenue Benchmark Actually Came From

Alex traces his whole line of thinking back to one question, why has the ecommerce industry settled on 30% as the figure every brand's email revenue share should hit, when every brand's situation, list age, paid spend, and seasonality are completely different.

"One of the biggest assumptions is that email revenue share should always be 30% of total store revenue." - Alex Moulart

He suggests the number has stuck around partly because it's round and because it's high enough that most accounts an agency audits won't be hitting it, which makes it an easy opening pitch. Matt pushes back with his own experience running Klaviyo reporting for his stores, admitting he doesn't fully trust the attributed revenue figure but has never really questioned it, as long as the measurement method stays consistent so trends are visible.

Building a Forecasting Engine to Find a Brand's Real Benchmark

Rather than discard revenue share altogether, Alex argues every brand should calculate its own benchmark from its own past performance, seasonally adjusted, rather than measuring itself against a flat industry figure.

"I'm not a developer, so I might have the framework in my mind, but it would be very hard for me to build it. Now we can very easily build these dashboards." - Alex Moulart

Using AI tools alongside the Klaviyo MCP, the Omnisend MCP, and direct API connections, he's built dashboards that track a brand's revenue share over several years rather than the usual 12-month window, so seasonal swings become visible. He gives one client as an example, consistent sending, consistent segmentation, but revenue share that moves up and down depending on how much the brand is spending on paid acquisition that month. Chasing a flat 30% target through that cycle, he says, risks burning out high-value segments and creating deliverability problems that wouldn't otherwise exist.

The Four Metric Groups Worth Tracking Instead

Asked what he actually looks at beyond revenue share, Alex sets out four groups of metrics he uses with clients.

"These four groups are the biggest ones you need to understand what's going on in your email." - Alex Moulart
  • Engagement - open rate and click rate. Open rate is a directional indicator at best; click rate is the one he relies on, partly because smaller brands generate more click data than conversion data.
  • Quality and revenue - conversion rate and revenue per recipient, the two indicators that show whether engagement is actually turning into sales.
  • Negative metrics - unsubscribe rate, bounce rate, and spam complaint rate. These tend to stay stable unless something's gone wrong, so he mostly just watches for spikes.
  • Total revenue share - email's overall share of store revenue, broken down further into campaign revenue share and flow revenue share when something needs chasing down.

He also flags that flows are harder to diagnose than campaigns, since one flow can underperform badly while every other flow and every campaign looks fine.

Why the First 30 Days Matter More Than Anyone Expects

Alex's segmentation work has mostly relied on activity signals, clicks, site visits, and the like. Building his own dashboards turned up a result he didn't expect.

"The first 30 days are really the most important indicator of whether they'll make a purchase or not." - Alex Moulart

Across the brands he looked at, most people who go on to buy make that first purchase within 30 days of joining the list. He describes it as a kind of shiny object syndrome, where new subscribers are most excited about a brand right when they discover it, and that window matters more than he'd previously built into his segmentation. His takeaway for brands isn't to give up on subscribers who don't convert in that window, but to be more aggressive with new joiners early on, then shift into a longer-term relationship-building approach once that initial excitement has settled.

Alex also talks through his approach to send frequency (he aims for around three emails a week per recipient), how he tests optimal send days using flow data rather than campaign data, and his view that AI dashboards work best when kept separate from the AI doing the analysis, since a script that excludes renewal revenue by design is safer than asking an AI to remember to exclude it every time.

Today's Guest

Alex Moulart is the Owner, Founder, and Strategist at AMM (Alex Moulart Email Marketing), an email and SMS marketing agency for DTC ecommerce brands built around Klaviyo.


About The eCommerce Podcast

The eCommerce Podcast helps Digital Davids, the small-to-mid-size ecommerce founders growing, scaling, and preparing to exit their businesses, learn from experts and founders who've done it already. Hosted by Matt Edmundson, it's released every Thursday.


Episode link: https://www.ecommerce-podcast.com/email-marketing-benchmarks-30-percent-rule

Weitere Episoden von „eCommerce Podcast“