
Chris talks with Jonathan Geltner about the best (but still flawed) adaptation of The Hobbit.
Get ready for...your greatest adventure!
Among other things, we discuss:
1:32 — The 1977 NBC broadcast
2:31 — Childhood memories of the cartoon
5:48 — Rankin/Bass as directors
5:58 — Rankin's "no additions" philosophy
6:15 — Top Craft & the Studio Ghibli connection
7:39 — Music & the folk singer-songwriter style
8:11 — Critical reception & Hugo nomination
8:36 — What the adaptation kept vs. omitted
9:00 — Songs as background vs. foreground
12:10 — "Greatest Adventure" as anti-escapist message
20:01 — Fantasy's cultural status in the 1970s
21:59 — The Hobbit's cohesion vs. "episodic" label
25:57 — Bilbo's shifting narrative voice in Mirkwood
27:57 — Mirkwood: the weakest section
32:01 — Omitting Beorn & the Arkenstone's consequences
41:07 — Character designs: what works, what doesn't
46:54 — The Wood Elves' unusual look
51:59 — Star Wars, fantasy, and mainstream credibility
55:29 — Tolkien's "long ago in the quiet of the world"
1:00:53 — Oral storytelling tradition vs. film immersion
1:01:44 — One swap: what would you put back?
1:06:30 — Mental visualization & imaginative experience
To read Jonathan's Substack, click here: https://jonathangeltner.substack.com/
To read my (far less illustrious) Substack, click here: https://pipkinsmiscellany.substack.com/
To buy Jonathan's first book, click here: https://slantbooks.org/books/absolute-music/
To email me, click [email protected]
Weitere Episoden von „The Inklings Variety Hour“



Verpasse keine Episode von “The Inklings Variety Hour” und abonniere ihn in der kostenlosen GetPodcast App.








