Differentiate or Die: Secrets of Silicon Valley podcast

Differentiate or Die: Category creation?

0:00
8:16
15 Sekunden vorwärts
15 Sekunden vorwärts

Key takeaways

  • Name the problem, not the category: market analysts name categories.
  • Educate the market on why the problem is urgent, and shape the buying criteria in your favor.
  • Lead with the business problem, not the product: buyer-in, not product-out.
  • Solve the budget problem by connecting to multiple funded executive initiatives and showing a pragmatic path to the promised land.

8:16

Creating a category is not for the faint of heart.

Over the past 20 years, Firebrick has been at ground-zero of the formation of multiple B2B tech categories: CRM/MA, SaaS, Big Data, CX, DevOps, Edge and more. Positioning veterans Bob Wright and Bob Macdonald share their insights on category creation, including:

  • The #1 challenge of creating a new category
  • How to decide whether to create a category or extend an existing one
  • The top 3 reasons we’ve seen category creators fail

Also available in this series, 3 Keys to run successful positioning, Not for the faint of heart, Symptoms you have a positioning problem, Positioning vs. Branding: Clearing up the confusion, B2B Positioning, CEO or CMO agenda?, Is your positioning winning or losing?, Stop the geek speak, Setting the foundation for successful positioning, B2B Positioning with and agency or in-house, When positioning expires, and The best product rarely wins.

Read the transcript

Bob McDonald: Hi, this is Bob McDonald, and welcome to Differentiate or Die, the Firebrick Consulting podcast series that focuses on the keys to great positioning. On this edition, Firebrick founder Bob Wright and I are going to be talking about the strategy of creating a new category. Bob, we hear this all the time.

Bob Wright: All the time I’m getting calls from B2B tech execs: “We want to create a new category.” It’s a common conversation in Silicon Valley. The good news is that category leaders enjoy superior valuations. The bad news is that it’s really, really difficult to create a new category.

Bob McDonald: And costly, and it takes time, right?

Bob Wright: Absolutely. Probably the number one issue is that there’s no funded initiative for your new category. As a result, tech companies are forced to try to steal budget from other funded initiatives, if you will.

Bob McDonald: So it’s going to be costly, it’s going to take time, and there are no funded initiatives that lead to sales right now. Those are a lot of things that make it tougher. At what point does it make sense for a company to say, okay, we understand all of that, but it’s time for us to create a new category?

Name the problem, not the category

Bob Wright: There’s a very specific, successful strategy for new category creators. Number one, it requires clearly naming the problem. What is the new executive-level business problem that requires a new category of software? Getting clarity on the problem is job one — not naming the category.

Bob McDonald: That’s a great point.

Bob Wright: I see it all the time: an inordinate amount of concern among tech execs about naming the category. I think that’s a fruitless conversation. It’s a waste of time. Tech companies don’t name categories — market analysts do. Your job as a category creator is to drive traction and revenue in a new category, so you can build a case that Gartner, Forrester or one of the other analysts should pick it up as a new category. So job number one is to name the problem: own a new executive-level problem that builds the case for a new category of solution.

Educate the market and shape the buying criteria

Bob McDonald: What are the other elements?

Bob Wright: Second, you have to educate the market on why this is a strategic, urgent issue. It’s not enough to name the problem: the convergence of these new market dynamics has created the new XYZ problem.

Bob McDonald: But it can’t be a “good enough is okay” problem.

Bob Wright: That’s correct. It’s an education process. Number one, educating the market that there is a problem: “Oh yes, you’re right — these are symptoms of an issue we call the XYZ problem.” And second, creating a sense of urgency: this problem is only going to get worse — in other words, you will lose your job. The third thing is defining what you have to do to solve the problem: shaping and influencing the buying criteria in the new category.

Bob McDonald: And let’s make a distinction here. Buying criteria is not a feature list for a product. It’s not about the product; it’s about the framework within which a product gets created.

Bob Wright: That is correct. I think the cardinal sin most tech companies commit is that it’s all about them. I was in product marketing; I spent all my time working on MRDs and with the development team to build the product, so the first thing you want to talk about is the product. That’s absolutely the wrong thing to do. You want to lead with the business problem, build a case for why you need this new set of capabilities, and then introduce your company.

Bob McDonald: So in a sense, these are the characteristics that need to be addressed to solve the problem, which eventually gets to the product, rather than starting with the product.

Bob Wright: That’s correct. It’s a customer-in, buyer-in approach to positioning, versus a product-out approach.

Finding budget for a new category

Bob McDonald: Okay, let’s say we’ve done this correctly. We’ve named the problem, articulated it, and made the case for it. We’ve even come up with the characteristics the solution should have, and of course we have the product that meets those characteristics. How do we go about finding the budget — the money to start having customers buy the product?

Bob Wright: One of the biggest problems with creating a new category is that there is no budget for that category of software. What we always do with positioning is identify the problem, build a case for why you need a new category, and identify the characteristics required to solve that new problem. Then we attach it to multiple funded initiatives. One of the most powerful positioning techniques is connecting your product and solution to a multi-headed value proposition, where you can say: not only do we solve this new, big, hairy, urgent problem for you, but, Mr. and Ms. Executive, of your top ten funded executive initiatives, if you invest in this solution, we’ll automatically make an impact on six of the ten.

Bob McDonald: Providing that roadmap is a very important part of the positioning process when you’re creating a new category.

Bob Wright: That’s correct. Part of it is not only connecting to funded initiatives, but also taking companies on a journey — beginning with the state they’re in right now and showing them the promised land. The companies that are separating from the pack and creating new categories don’t answer the question of how it works. The questions they answer in their positioning are: why do you matter? Why is this new category required now? How can you uniquely solve this problem? And how do you make me a hero? Your life is hell — how can you uniquely solve it? Take me to the promised land.

Bob McDonald: And show them a pragmatic progression for getting there, rather than a leap that seems too far.

Bob Wright: That’s correct. Typically, if you can build a case that adopting the solution leverages the investment the company has already made in its existing IT infrastructure and processes, it smooths the way for a new category.

Bob McDonald: You’ve been listening to Bob Wright, founder of Firebrick, talking about the strategy for creating a new category.

The post Differentiate or Die: Category creation? appeared first on Firebrick Consulting.

Weitere Episoden von „Differentiate or Die: Secrets of Silicon Valley“