077 - The "My Truth" mindset

"You have your truth. I have my truth." It's a phrase we've all heard. But can we actually have two completely different truths and both be right? In this episode, Fathers Andy Vogel and Andy Beerman unpack the idea of relativism, why it has become so influential in our culture, and what happens when we start treating morality as something we get to define for ourselves. From everyday relationships to some of the most fundamental questions of right and wrong, where does the idea of "your truth" ultimately lead us? And perhaps most importantly, how do we stand firm in the truth without becoming arrogant in the process? Because truth isn't something we create. It's something we discover. And as Jesus tells us, He is the way, the truth, and the life. Join us for Episode 77 of Catholicism Unwrapped!

What if the problem isn't that the Bible doesn't make sense, but that we're approaching it with the wrong assumptions? This week, the Fathers discuss biblical scholarship, the miracles of Jesus, and why some Catholics have found their faith challenged by what they learned about Scripture. Can we take the Bible seriously as a historical text while also believing that God really acts in history? And what does it mean to read Scripture with both human and divine authorship in mind? The Fathers are unpacking all of it in Episode 76 of Catholicism Unwrapped.

Why would someone walk 75 miles just to reach a church? For centuries, pilgrims have traveled the Camino de Santiago, journeying across Spain toward the cathedral housing the remains of St. James the Greater. But what draws people to this ancient pilgrimage, and why has it become so popular in a world where we can get almost anywhere faster than ever? In this episode of Catholicism Unwrapped, Father Andy Vogel shares his experience walking the Camino, from the unexpected challenges along the way to the remarkable people he met and the destination that awaited them all. We use his experiences to explore the history of pilgrimage, the beauty of sacred architecture, and what happens when we step away from the noise of everyday life long enough to make room for something more. You might be surprised by who makes the journey, what they discover along the way, and what a walk across Spain can teach us about the journey we're all on.   Join us for the full conversation.

What’s the difference between therapy and spiritual direction? And when it comes to healing, can one take the place of the other? In this episode of Catholicism Unwrapped, Fr. Andy Vogel and Fr. Andrew Beerman sit down with Joseph Lundsten, a licensed professional clinical counselor, to explore the relationship between psychological and spiritual healing. Together, they discuss the distinct roles of therapy and spiritual direction, the importance of understanding the human person, and why psychological healing and the life of grace are not interchangeable. They also explore scrupulosity, the danger of identifying too closely with our struggles, and how our experiences can shape the way we understand God. Plus, Joseph shares his journey into the Catholic Church and the profound impact of the Mass, the Eucharist, and the Sacrament of Reconciliation on his conversion. Healing takes many forms. How do we recognize what we need, and where do we turn?   Contact Joseph:  Joseph Lundsten, LPCC Axios Integrative Therapy https://www.axios-therapy.com/  

Are Catholics and Protestants really all that different? We agree on a lot: Jesus Christ, the Trinity, Scripture, and many fundamental Christian teachings. But there are also important differences in what Catholics and Protestants believe about the Church, the Eucharist, salvation, Scripture, Tradition, and authority. So what do those differences actually mean? In Episode 073, Fr. Andy the Greater and Fr. Andy the Lesser unpack some of the most common questions they hear: • Why can’t Catholics receive Communion at a Protestant church? • What makes the Catholic Mass different from a Protestant worship service? • What do Catholics mean by “the fullness of truth”? • What are sola fide and sola scriptura? • Can a Catholic marry a Protestant? • Can Catholic parents send their children to a Protestant school? • And if Catholics and Protestants disagree, can we still work and pray together? It’s a conversation about both the differences and the things we share with our Protestant brothers and sisters.

What would it be like to worship alongside hundreds of thousands of Catholics from every corner of the world? In this episode of Catholicism Unwrapped, Fr. Andy Vogel and Fr. Andy Beerman talk about their experiences at World Youth Day; from crowded trains and outdoor confessions to sleeping in fields, meeting Catholics from around the world, and celebrating Mass with an enormous crowd. But beneath the stories is something much bigger: the experience of discovering just how universal the Catholic Church really is. The Andys share what World Youth Day has taught them about faith, the priesthood, evangelization, and the incredible reality that Catholics separated by language, culture, and continents can gather together and worship the same Christ. And if you've ever wondered whether World Youth Day is worth the trip to Seoul, South Korea, they have a pretty strong answer.

What if you wanted to become Catholic… but had absolutely no idea where to start? Do you just show up at a parish? Do you have to take classes? What if you're already baptized? What if you're not sure you're ready to commit? And why does the Catholic Church even have a process for this in the first place? If you've ever found yourself asking, “What would actually happen if I became Catholic?”, this episode is for you. And maybe the first step isn't becoming Catholic. Maybe it's simply asking the question.

The Society of St. Pius X has once again made headlines after the ordination of four bishops without papal approval, resulting in automatic excommunication. What led to this moment? Why is the approval of the Pope necessary to ordain bishops? What is the difference between loving Catholic tradition and separating oneself from the Church? Fr. Andy Vogel and Fr. Andy Beerman unpack the history of the SSPX, explain the Church's teaching on schism and papal authority, discuss the status of the Latin Mass, and answer common questions about whether Catholics who attend SSPX chapels are themselves excommunicated. Most importantly, they reflect on Christ's call to unity and how Catholics should respond with both truth and charity.

Across the Catholic Church, many young Catholics, and many younger priests, are embracing reverence, beauty, and tradition in new ways. But why is this happening? In this episode, Fr. Andy Vogel and Fr. Andy Beerman explore the cultural shifts behind this growing movement. They discuss why so many young people are drawn to beauty and reverence, the role of the Traditional Latin Mass, what Vatican II actually taught, and how Catholics of different generations can better understand one another. Whether you're curious about the renewed interest in tradition or simply wondering what younger Catholics are searching for, this conversation offers historical context, pastoral insight, and practical wisdom for building unity in the Church. Topics include: • Why younger Catholics are embracing tradition • Beauty as a path to evangelization • The role of reverence in the Mass • Vatican II: what changed and what didn't • Building bridges across generations in the Church

As Fr. Andy Beerman celebrates 30 years of priesthood, he sits down with Fr. Andy Vogel to reflect on the people, moments, and graces that have shaped his vocation. Together they revisit ordination day, share humorous family memories, and recount moving encounters with God's mercy through the sacraments, anointing the sick, and the ministry of presence. Along the way, Fr. Beerman offers wisdom gained from three decades of serving Christ and His Church. Join us for an encouraging conversation about the beauty of the priesthood and the countless ways God continues to work through ordinary men who answer His call.