Understanding Congress podcast

Are Elections Fueling Polarization in the House of Representatives? (with Andrew B. Hall)

0:00
26:16
15 Sekunden vorwärts
15 Sekunden vorwärts

The subject of this episode is, “Are elections fueling polarization in the House of Representatives?”

Polarization in Congress is a well-documented fact of life. This is particularly true on high salience issues, such as immigration and abortion. Yet the tendency of legislators to reflexively oppose policy ideas offered by the other party has bled into other, more prosaic issues. For example, in late 2021 an infrastructure bill became a bone of political contention. Republicans who voted for it were denounced by their colleagues. Nevermind the fact that the legislation might actually do good for these legislators’ constituents.

Why are there so many hard left and hard right members of our national legislature? To help us think through this issue, my guest is Andrew B. Hall, a political scientist at Stanford University. Dr. Hall has published many articles on elections and representation and is the author of Who Wants to Run?: How the Devaluing of Political Office Drives Polarization (Chicago, 2019).

Kevin Kosar:

Welcome to Understanding Congress, a podcast about the first branch of government. Congress is a notoriously complex institution and few Americans think well of it, but Congress is essential to our Republic. It’s a place where our pluralistic society is supposed to work out its differences and come to agreement about what our laws should be. And that is why we are here to discuss our national legislature and to think about ways to upgrade it so it can better serve our nation.

I'm your host, Kevin Kosar, and I'm a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, a think tank in Washington DC.

Andy, welcome to the podcast.

Andrew Hall:

Excited to be here. Thank you.

Kevin Kosar:

If I had a dollar given to me every time somebody said, “Congress is polarized because Americans are polarized,” I'd have enough bucks to take a really good vacation. The idea that America has become the land of red states and blue states, with right wing rural folks and left wing city folks, has become pretty popular. You see references to it in the press all the time. So that prompts the question—we have a polarized Congress: are voters the reason we have a polarized Congress?

Andrew Hall:

It's a very reasonable question. I don't think it has nothing to do with it. I do think it's true that some Americans have become quite polarized. Obviously, we see it play out with things like the rural-urban divide that you're talking about. But I think that there's a really important fallacy that a lot of people don't always think through when they think about Congress polarizing, which is that there's absolutely no guarantee that any change or non-change in people's opinions, will map into what congressional candidates or members of Congress say or do, because there's this intermediate step which is really important—who actually decides to stand up and run for Congress? If the people who decide to run are just systematically different from what the voters at large want, then unfortunately, what people want or what they think or how they think or how polarized they are may not have any reflection in what options they're actually presented to vote on.

So—to get back to your question itself—I think it's of course true that people are polarizing to some degree. I think it's vastly overstated. And when you look into evidence on most salient policy issues, it turns out...

Weitere Episoden von „Understanding Congress“