Stop Trying to Change the People You Love
Have you ever tried so hard to help someone you love make better decisions that you nearly destroyed your relationship in the process? Have you offered advice, explained your concerns, pointed out mistakes, and wondered why the person you love just won’t listen? We see someone we love making decisions that we believe are hurting them. Maybe they’re irresponsible with money, neglecting their health, staying in an unhealthy relationship, wasting their potential, or making the same mistakes over and over. We can see how much better their life could be if they would just change a few things.And because we love them, we tell them. We explain. We advise. We encourage. We remind. And when nothing changes, we explain it again, perhaps more emphatically this time. After all, we only want what’s best for them.What if our efforts are damaging our relationships with them?When Love Starts Feeling Like CriticismMost of us have been on both sides of this. We’ve offered advice because we genuinely wanted to help someone avoid pain, disappointment, or regret. And we’ve been on the receiving end of advice that made us feel inadequate, judged, or as though we could never quite measure up to someone else’s expectations.Our intentions may be loving, but intentions aren’t always what other people experience. We think we’re saying, “I love you so much that I want you to have a better life.” But what they may be hearing is, “You’re not good enough the way you are.”Think about that for a moment.How would you feel if every time you spent time with someone you loved, they found something about you that needed improvement? Would you look forward to seeing them? Would you confide in them? Would you feel safe sharing your struggles, failures, and fears? Or would you begin limiting your time with them?I wonder how many marriages, friendships, and family relationships have been damaged, not because people stopped loving one another, but because one person never stopped trying to change the other.Sometimes our desire to help someone become a better person looks more like criticism and judgment than love.Here’s something learned... It’s not my job to change another person. It’s not yours, either.We can influence people. We can share our experiences, offer wisdom when it’s welcomed, demonstrate better choices, and encourage those we love. But we cannot make someone think differently, believe differently, want differently, or behave differently. At least not in a way that produces genuine, lasting transformation.We might pressure someone into changing their behavior temporarily. We might push them to do what we want them to do just to keep the peace. But compliance is usually temporary. It’s not the same as transformation.The kind of change that lasts begins in the heart, and only God can change a heart.In Ezekiel 36:26, God promises: “I will give you a new heart and put a new spirit in you.”Notice who does the changing. God doesn’t tell us to criticize people until they improve. He doesn’t ask us to manage other people’s decisions or assume responsibility for their transformation. He tells us what He can do.And when God changes someone’s heart, their desires can change. Their thinking can change. Their priorities can change. Their behavior can change. Not because someone pressured them into becoming different, but because they’re becoming different from the inside out. That’s the kind of transformation no amount of unsolicited advice can accomplish.What Do People See When They Look at Us?This is a question I’ve been asking myself. When people spend time with me, what do they experience? Do they feel loved, encouraged, accepted, and hopeful? Or do they leave feeling criticized, judged, inadequate, or disappointing?More importantly, when people look at us, do they see the love of Jesus, or do they see everything we think is wrong with them?Jesus said: “By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you love one another.” — John 13:35He didn’t say people would recognize His followers by how effectively they corrected others. He said they would recognize us by our love.That doesn’t mean we should ignore destructive behavior, tolerate abuse, or remain silent when someone is putting themselves or others in danger. There are times when love requires us to speak difficult truths, establish boundaries, or intervene to protect someone. But there’s a difference between speaking the truth in love and continually expressing our disappointment in someone else.We can tell the truth without humiliating someone. We can disagree without condemning. We can set boundaries without withholding love. And we can love people without approving of everything they do.Sometimes the greatest expression of love is listening without offering advice. Sometimes it’s helping without delivering a lecture. And sometimes it’s praying for someone and trusting God to do what we cannot.Our Example Is More Powerful Than Our AdviceThink about the people who have had the greatest positive influence on your life. Were they the people who repeatedly told you everything you needed to change? Or were they the people who believed in you, encouraged you, demonstrated living a good life, and loved you even when you made mistakes? I suspect that for many of us, it was the latter.There’s something powerful about being around someone who lives with peace, kindness, generosity, integrity, and joy. We notice. We may not say anything, but we notice. And sometimes we begin to want what they have. That’s influence.Our lives are constantly communicating something to the people around us, whether we realize it or not. Our words, attitudes, behavior, and actions tell people what matters to us. They reveal what we believe. And for those of us who claim to follow Jesus, they either reinforce or contradict what we say about Him.Galatians 5:22–23 describes the evidence of the Holy Spirit in our lives as love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. Imagine how different our relationships might become if we spent as much time cultivating those qualities in ourselves as we spend trying to correct the shortcomings we see in others.Perhaps the most powerful way to influence someone to change is to allow God to change us first.The Freedom of Letting God Be GodI love what Paul wrote in 1 Corinthians 3:6: “I planted the seed, Apollos watered it, but God has been making it grow.”What a beautiful reminder of where our responsibility ends and God’s begins. We can plant seeds of truth. We can water them with kindness, encouragement, prayer, and the example of a life lived according to God’s Word. But we cannot make those seeds grow. That’s God’s work.And there’s tremendous freedom in accepting that. We don’t have to win every argument. We don’t have to convince everyone that our way is better. We don’t have to take responsibility for the choices other adults make. [Stop and re-read that last sentence.] We can release the exhausting burden of trying to manage someone else’s life.And when we do, we may discover that our relationships become more peaceful, more authentic, and more loving. The people we love may become more willing to listen because they no longer feel they’re constantly being corrected. They may begin to share their struggles because they trust that we’ll respond with compassion rather than criticism. And perhaps, through the way we live and love, they’ll begin to see something in us that draws them closer to Jesus.What If We Changed the Question?The next time you’re tempted to correct someone you love, consider asking yourself a few questions.Did they ask for my advice? Am I speaking because this person truly needs my help, or because their choices make me uncomfortable? Am I trying to help them, or am I trying to get them to live according to my expectations? Will my words make this person feel loved, or inadequate?And perhaps the most important question of all: Will what I’m about to s… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit rhondasciortino.substack.com