Achieving reliable service in corrupt electricity sectors (lessons from Lebanon)
Last week I teased my interview with Muzna and Neil about tackling corruption in the Lebanese electricity sector. They wrote the report about it (together with Ali Ahmad and Marc Ayoub). Last week you got the gist, but now, you can hear - or read - the whole interview! Find out more about what achieving reliable electricity meant for the people involved, about the intricacies of the political settlement and about how poor governance and poor uptake of renewable energy capacity hang together. (You can also listen to this podcast on Spotify, Apple, Stitcher or wherever you get your podcasts.)TranscriptToday I’m taking you to Lebanon, to a story about how to do good in messy, murky circumstances. Here to tell the story are Muzna al-Masri and Neil McCulloch. They recently co-authored a report about a town in the Bekaa Valley, in the east of the country, a couple of stone throws away from Syria. The town is called Zahle, and it has 24-hour electricity, which is unfortunately unique in Lebanon. Responsible for the service is EDZ – short for Electricité de Zahle. They got a concession to operate in the town from the national utility, which is EDL, the Electricité de Liban. So, acronyms out of the way, if you’re curious about how they did it and what we might learn from it, welcome to the Social Life of Energy.NeilSo the backgrounds of the research project is a research program by SOAS, the University of London, on anti-corruption evidence. And what they were interested to, to do was to try and understand why anti-corruption programs around the world have been so unsuccessful.Neil And their idea was that they've often failed because they have this sort of cookie cutter approach to anti-corruption, they have a common idea of the things you have to do to tackle corruption. And what they've pointed out and they've now accumulated a lot of evidence for this is that you really have to understand the nature of the underlying political settlement in order for to be able to tackle corruption in an effective way. Because countries are different. And the ways in which politics are work are different. And so they've done a whole set of studies, in particular in the electricity sector, looking at various types of reforms in Bangladesh, in Nigeria, and also our own study in Lebanon, to see how progress is possible within a different context. So our study looks at corruption in the electricity sector in Lebanon, which is infamous, as we all know, but explicitly how it was possible in the city was actually in its surroundings, to provide a reasonably good quality functional electricity service in an environment in a broader environment, which was very dysfunctional. How was that feasible in that in that political context?Marten Okay. Great, thanks. And Muzna can you speak a little bit more about what's going on in Lebanon, for those who don't know?MuznaBasically, in Lebanon electricity problem has been ongoing for many decades. There are constant electricity cuts in the city of Beirut, at a minimum would not have electricity three hours a day outside of Beirut, it's 12 to 14 hours a day. The corruption in the sector is huge. It is responsible for a large part of the national debt. And as a result there are a lot of private generators that are covering that kind of need in energy and but also causing a lot of air pollution and forcing most residents to pay huge electricity bills, both national one and kind of for private generators. But there is one bright example, which is the EDZ the electricity of Zahle, which has managed to generate electricity 24 hour electricity, with excellent collection rates, with excellent quality of service. That is a huge contrast with the National situation. And at the same time has captured a lot of people's imagination. So how can EDZ do it? And if we can do it in one setting, can’t we all do that? We've actually been hearing this kind of question, can I do that in this refugee camp? Can we do that in Hamra? So in a way, our study answers this kind of global question on corruption, but also attempts to answer to the Lebanese people. Is it doable elsewhere?MartenOkay. So what is your most important finding or message that you've concluded from the research? NeilUm, I mean, the most important message, to my mind is the one that mostly just mentioned, which is that this is doable. But, reformers within Lebanon and reformers within of the international community have been banging their head against the brick wall of electricity reform in Lebanon for decades, exactly as Muzna says, and have mostly failed. And yet one city has managed to succeed. So the real question is, how, how is this possible? So the main message I take away from it is that if you have a really good understanding of how the local politics actually functions, it is possible to negotiate a solution, it is possible to make progress. However, what our study shows, which is a little bit uncomfortable, is that this is not a story of some heroic reformer doing all the right things against all the odds, it's a much messier, much more murky story than you might like to believe. Because EDZ has succeeded in part because of the failure of the Lebanese state. And it succeeded in part at the expense of the Lebanese state. So there's a downside to the story as well as an upside.MuznaYeah, if I can continue on this, I think the main message for me is that in a country that has that amount of corruption, there is no way to come up with an arrangement that improves the quality of service for people without making concessions and sort of feeding the beast if you say, so you have to kind of pay some to the people who are responsible for the bad quality of service to start with. But then there is a way of minimizing these kinds of concessions you're making, by leveraging [political support].Neil And I think that's been one of the remarkable things of the story of Zahle is the way in which EDZ has managed to mobilize the community. They've funded sports clubs, they found a funded religious organizations, they've got the entire community around them campaigning and championing for them as a success. And then that is strengthening the political authority of EDZ to be able to battle the centre, which could have shut it down, which could have made what they were doing impossible, but they were so popular. And they knew that they could get people out in the streets to support them, that they allowed it to continue. So there's a very clever politicking going on there about achieving the outcome, but also exactly as Muzna said, in order to be able to come to, shall we say, compromises with those in the centre who might block it, you need to make you need it to make a profit, you need to make a surplus. And the way in which EDZ achieved that was I think, very clever. And it was the exact opposite of all of the international advice, the international advices make everything transparent. EDZ managed to make everything not transparent, and thereby managed to make a significant profit, which they could then plough back into investment into the quality of service and also into reaching settlements with the people who might oppose them.Marten Okay, so there was the puzzle at the start with like, how does EDZ do it? And I'm hearing two answers. One is community support. And the other one is making things less transparent. Maybe Muzna, you want to elaborate on that?Muzna I think the puzzle is more complex than that. I think the community support, if I may elaborate on that is not about just leveraging support. So we could like, as we did research, we kept on like discovering one layer after another of that kind of relationship. At first, I understood it as a straightforward sponsorship from EDZ to the community to get their support. But then, and we understand it, like, I understood it as clientelistic ties, and there is this kind of linkages of clientelism being n… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit sociallifeofenergy.substack.com