In this episode, we explore the chilling story of the Jenny Jones murder case, one of the most infamous and controversial incidents linked to the talk show world. Jenny Jones, a popular daytime talk show host, was known for her candid discussions and often sensational topics. But in 1995, the show took a dark turn when a guest named Scott Amedure appeared on her program to discuss his secret crush on his friend, Jonathan Schmitz. The episode was supposed to be lighthearted, but it ended in tragedy when, just days later, Schmitz murdered Amedure. What followed was a media frenzy, a highly publicized trial, and a nationwide debate on the responsibility of talk shows and television producers in shaping the actions of their guests.
The murder raised difficult questions about the ethics of television programming. Amedure, who was openly gay, had confessed his feelings for Schmitz during the taping, unaware of Schmitz’s discomfort. The show, which was meant to be playful, ultimately highlighted the damaging effects of exploiting sensitive topics for entertainment purposes. Jenny Jones herself became embroiled in a legal battle, with some holding her and the producers accountable for creating a toxic environment that led to Amedure’s death. In this episode, we’ll break down the events leading up to the murder and examine the role of talk shows in perpetuating harmful stereotypes.
We’ll also dive into the courtroom drama that followed the murder. The case became one of the first to challenge the legal implications of TV shows manipulating vulnerable individuals for the sake of ratings. Schmitz was initially convicted of second-degree murder, but his defense argued that he was so emotionally distraught from the television appearance that he had temporarily lost control. The case sparked debates about the responsibility of the media and whether they were responsible for creating an environment that encouraged such extreme actions. Join us as we dissect the trial and the aftermath that impacted both the victims’ families and the television industry as a whole.
This episode also touches on the broader cultural context of the 1990s talk show era, a time when sensationalism dominated the airwaves. Programs like Jerry Springer and Maury Povich were known for their shocking and sometimes exploitative content, pushing boundaries and feeding into the public’s voyeuristic appetite for conflict. The Jenny Jones case stands out as a turning point in how these types of shows were perceived, especially as concerns over privacy, consent, and exploitation began to rise.
Finally, we’ll reflect on how the Jenny Jones murder case continues to serve as a cautionary tale about the dangers of reality television and sensationalism. While many talk shows have shifted their format or faced criticism in the years since, the legacy of the Amedure murder reminds us that the quest for ratings should never come at the cost of people’s lives. Tune in for a deep dive into one of the darkest chapters in the history of daytime TV.
Talk2TheHand is an independent throwback podcast run by husband and wife, Jimmy and Beth. Obsessed with 90s nostalgia and 90s celebrities, we'll rewind the years and take you back to the greatest era of our lives.
New episodes bursting with nostalgia of the 90s released on Tuesdays.
Please subscribe to our podcast and we'll keep you gooey in 1990s love.
Find us on Twitter @talk2thehandpod or email us at [email protected] or [email protected]
More episodes from "Talk2TheHand 90s"
Don't miss an episode of “Talk2TheHand 90s” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.
