Surrogate Stories: Three Journeys, No Sugarcoating
A note for listeners: this episode includes frank discussion of pregnancy loss, a selective reduction, and the death of an infant.
What does surrogacy look like across ten years, three journeys, and outcomes nobody plans for?
This episode is part of the Surrogate Stories, where we hand the mic to the women who make this whole thing possible. These are their journeys, their stories, in their own voices. Eloise Drane sits down with surrogates and lets them tell it start to finish: why they said yes, what carrying for another family really asked of them, and what they carried home afterward.
This week, our surrogate is Jessica, a three-time gestational surrogate and mother of four whose first journey began about ten years ago, before much of the regulation that exists today. She was introduced to surrogacy through family, met her first intended parents within an hour of the first phone call, and said yes before she fully understood what she was agreeing to.
This conversation covers a first journey that took five transfers, a pregnancy the clinic misread, a decision that was not hers to make, and a delivery she drove herself to while in labor. It covers what happened to that relationship afterward, and what she learned years later about that family. Her second journey was, in her words, the way a surrogacy journey should go. Her third brought her back into the industry through a job interview that turned out to be something else, an agency she walked away from, and twin girls born early in a hospital that did not yet have her paperwork. It also brought a loss she is still working through.
Jessica does not tidy any of it up. If you are considering becoming a surrogate and want the version nobody puts in a brochure, this is the episode to listen to before you take the next step.
"I don’t sugarcoat things. It’s not who I am." -- Jessica
What You’ll Learn
How she was introduced to surrogacy and why the first yes came so fast
What the process looked like a decade ago compared to today
Why her first journey took five transfers to reach a pregnancy
The pregnancy her clinic misidentified, and how it was eventually found
What her contract said about the number of transfers she had agreed to
How it felt to agree to something she did not want, and why she agreed
Guest Bio
Jessica is a three-time gestational surrogate and mother of four who began her first journey roughly ten years ago and has since carried for three different families across two countries. Her journeys have included repeated failed transfers, decisions she did not want to make, relationships that ended badly and relationships that lasted, and loss. She speaks about all of it without softening it, because she believes the sanitized version of surrogacy does prospective surrogates no favors.
This episode is for women who are considering becoming a surrogate and want to hear what can go wrong, why the safeguards exist, and what she would do differently.
Episode Resources
Family Inceptions: familyinceptions.com
Fertility Café: thefertilitycafe.com
Related Episodes
When Third-Party Goes Wrong
https://thefertilitycafe.com/podcast/ep-45-when-third-party-goes-wrong/
The Dark Side of Surrogacy & Egg Donation
https://thefertilitycafe.com/podcast/ep-68-dark-side-of-surrogacy-egg-donation/
Thinking About Becoming a Surrogate?
If you’re thinking about becoming a surrogate and want to talk with a team that’s been doing this for over two decades, apply at https://familyinceptionssurrogacy.eggdonorconnect.com/surrogateprescreen?utm_source=FertilityCafe&utm_campaign=SurrogateStories
Stay Connected
Instagram https://www.instagram.com/fertilitycafe
Facebook ht...
Chapters
(00:00:00) - Intro: The Surrogate Series and Jessica's Story(00:01:09) - Jessica's Own Pregnancies(00:02:20) - How Jessica Became a Surrogate(00:05:15) - Family Reactions to Surrogacy(00:08:00) - First Journey: Meeting Intended Parents and Screening(00:09:52) - First Journey: Failed Transfers and Ectopic Scare(00:12:06) - First Journey: Retained Tissue and More Transfers(00:14:10) - Getting Pregnant With Triplets(00:16:28) - The Reduction Decision and Its Emotional Toll(00:20:19) - Autonomy, Compensation, and Surrogate Mindset(00:22:23) - First Journey Pregnancy and Boundaries With IPs(00:24:52) - First Journey Delivery and Aftermath(00:28:57) - Fallout and Disconnect After First Journey(00:30:36) - Deciding on a Second Journey(00:33:57) - Second Journey: Pregnancy and Delivery(00:36:00) - Staying in Touch and Tragic News(00:38:28) - Chance Encounter With First Intended Father(00:41:17) - Processing Guilt and the Boys' Future(00:43:40) - Considering a Third Journey and a Shady Agency(00:48:06) - Walking Away and Being Pulled Back In(00:51:36) - Setting Up the Third Journey Safely(00:54:10) - Canada Fertility Clinic and Lax Regulations(00:57:00) - Third Journey: Transfer and Twin Pregnancy(00:59:37) - Building a Close Relationship With Third Journey Parents(01:01:36) - Hardest Pregnancy: Twins at 40(01:04:13) - Early Delivery Due to Elevated Blood Pressure(01:08:54) - NICU, Parentage Paperwork, and Early Concerns(01:11:01) - Noticing Disconnect With Intended Parents(01:15:29) - Pumping Conflict and Shift in Relationship(01:17:28) - Parents Leave Early Against Advice(01:20:49) - The Devastating Phone Call(01:23:00) - Grief, Anger, and Blame(01:26:44) - Separating From the Intended Parents(01:28:54) - Final Reflections and Advice for Future Surrogates