You Have to Be Pretty Smart to Play Dumb
Recently, I have been examining my own subconscious blockers. The fear of my own success seems to come up a lot for me. What happens when I get the thing I want? I’m like a dog with a bone. The pursuit of what I desire drives me into unbridled insanity, but once I arrive at the desired destination, I don’t know what to do with myself. My dreams are so big, I feel as if I’m not allowed to have them. I’ve seen what happens to successful women. Everybody loves an ingénue, but the one thing they love even more is taking a promising young woman and dismembering her down to the bone once she reaches the top of the mountain. You are not allowed to look out at the view for too long because, when the light hits your face, it illuminates your every flaw, and society will always make you pay for being something other than what they thought you were. I look at the systematic takedown of successful women over the past decade. Often, their greatest crime seems to be that they dared to be more than just one thing. You are not allowed to be pretty and smart, or young and successful, or strong and kind. You can’t like fashion and sports. You can’t be funny and complex, or gentle and brave.Taylor Swift, Megan Fox, Serena Williams, Jennifer Lawrence, Anne Hathaway, Sydney Sweeney, Kim Kardashian, Amber Heard, Blake Lively, Kamala Harris, Lena Dunham, Greta Thunberg, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Alex Cooper. The list goes on and on, but the story is always the same. The women who get the harshest scrutiny all share traits society claims to value: beauty, ambition, sexuality, confidence, visibility, intelligence, and success. But like the curated box of chocolates that sits on your grandma’s 1970s coffee table, you are only allowed to have as much as they deem acceptable.The truth is that women are encouraged to pursue all of these things right up until they become “too much”. Too powerful, too outspoken, too sexual, too ambitious, too emotional, too visible, or too difficult to control. So we box up our egos and put them away in our cedar-lined closets like an old winter coat. The cure-all remedy to the threatening shadow that our success seems to cast on the world is to never allow anyone to know just how smart we are. Turns out you have to be pretty smart to act dumb. When we act like a broken baby bird or a clueless bimbo, our success is suddenly something that has happened in spite of who we are and not because of it, and this seems to be one of the few ways to remain palatable to society.We quickly learn that being underestimated can sometimes be more useful than being recognized. Paris Hilton is a pioneer of this perspective. Her self-control and unwavering suppression of any need for credit is a master class that should be studied. For over a decade, she altered the sound of her own voice and allowed herself to be the butt of every late-night joke while silently building a $400 million empire. Society allowed her to succeed because they had no idea she was succeeding.There is still something socially uncomfortable about a woman who openly wants a lot. Women are encouraged to be successful, but often only if that success appears accidental. We celebrate ambition in theory but tend to prefer women who stumble into greatness rather than pursue it relentlessly.Every time I see a woman make her way to the top of her respective field, I begin to hold my breath, wondering if they are doing the same. How long will the world allow her to be there, before she falls from grace? Why do we build people up just to kick them back down? Humans are masochistic cannibals, hell-bent on destruction.These thoughts seem to be woven meticulously through my fears. My fear of failing and my fear of not being loved are at constant odds. In order to succeed, you must be okay with failing. Once you succeed, you must be okay with not being loved. How can my anxiety-prone skeleton come to terms with this fucked-up nightmare? Society is my sleep paralysis demon, so I sit and bed rot into the wee hours of the night, refusing to come face-to-face with my fears.“If people knew how smart you are, they would be very afraid of you.”One of the kindest things an ex has ever said to me, though in retrospect I’m not sure it was a compliment…I discussed this very sentiment with my dad over a fried chicken sandwich last week as we talked about the impending venture capital meeting I had for a project I’m working on. He asked if I would ever acknowledge this work publicly, and I said most likely not because it felt dangerous to be seen in this light.“I don’t think society will ever allow a woman to be pretty and smart. I’d rather just live a double life where people see me as one thing, and I know myself to be something very different and infinitely more complex.”He didn’t pause for even a moment before saying;“I think that’s pretty smart.”Even a 60-year-old man knows that beauty opens doors while simultaneously creating assumptions about what should be behind them.Successful women always become cultural projection screens, where the conversation shifts from their work to their likability, bodies, ambition, sexuality, or perceived flaws, and I don’t know if my skin will ever become thick and weathered enough to take this. I pretend to be brave with unwavering confidence, but on the inside I am a gentle glass doll, one wrong move away from shattering at all times.So what the hell are we supposed to do about it?I wish I had a profound answer. I wish I could tell you that after years of introspection, therapy, meditation, journaling, and aggressively overthinking in the shower, I have arrived at some enlightened conclusion. However I’m writing this piece because I’m hoping that one of YOU will have the answer.Unfortunately, for now, all I’ve got is this:Society doesn’t actually need to drag every woman back down the mountain because most of us start climbing with a parachute strapped to our backs. Ready to jump and make ourselves small as soon as we sense we have overstayed our welcome. We learn to soften our opinions, disguise our ambition, and laugh off our accomplishments, before anyone asks us to because we’ve seen what happens to the women who don’t.I’ve spent so much time worrying about whether the world will allow me to be pretty and smart that I’ve never stopped to consider whether I’m willing to allow it myself. That’s the cost of being fully seen, not everyone will like what they find.Perhaps the women I’ve spent years studying aren’t fearless at all, they are just willing to be misunderstood. I don’t know if I’ve reached that point yet and I’m not sure how you get there. I still find myself stuffing pieces of my personality into neat little boxes and praying nobody notices what’s missing. Maybe the goal isn’t to convince the world that women can be beautiful and intelligent. Maybe the goal is to stop pretending we’re not.Till next time, AMEThe Unreliable Narrator by Allie Evans is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to The Unreliable Narrator by Allie Evans at alliemarieevans.substack.com/subscribe