WHAT THE HELL DID WE WATCH?

Toby and Jeff share the yuletide spirit while talking through the holiday slasher classic SILENT NIGHT DEADLY NIGHT while Jeff pounds Nutcracker Ale. They explore the filmographies of Will Hare, Lilyan Chauvin, Robert Brian Wilson and the rest of the cast while geeking out over 80s toys and fashion, are traumatized by weird Christmas carols and decorations, talk about Utah, bad cops and killer Santas. As a bonus, Jeff confronts his fear of old people and Nuns. Join them for a very special WHAT THE HELL DID WE WATCH CHRISTMAS as TOBY AND JEFF RUIN CHRISTMAS!

Hear Toby get grossed out by a giant pimple while he and Jeff talk about the 80s, rock and roll, Crystal Bernard, playmates, powertools and leather clad rockabilly serial killers during this week's episode featuring SLUMBER PARTY MASSACRE 2.

This week Toby and Jeff talk about potato chips, the cons of shock therapy, Toby's aversion to needles, prostitution and body image as they take a bite out of the 1975 exploitation/horror film CRIMINALLY INSANE aka CRAZY FAT ETHEL in all of it's sleaze soaked glory... which they enjoyed much more than they probably should.

Toby and Jeff talk about the past Holiday, slasher movies, Mormonism, gender norms in film, killers in the woods, and "Creepy Craig" while they dig into the 1981 cult classic DON'T GO IN THE WOODS ALONE in this unintentionally marathon length episode.

Pilot episode where Toby and Jeff wax intellectually (or not so intellectually) about the sasquatch movie NIGHT OF THE DEMON.