SHOT OF NOSTALGIA #8.6: THE WEDNESDAY NIGHT WARS | AEW DYNAMITE vs. NXT | FEBRUARY 5 TO MARCH 11, 2020 | MOXLEY DETHRONES JERICHO, OMEGA & HANGMAN STEAL REVOLUTION, GARGANO BETRAYS CIAMPA & THE LAST NORMAL WEDNESDAY
It's time for the 6th episode of Season 8 of SHOT OF NOSTALGIA and we're continuing our journey through the WEDNESDAY NIGHT WARS between AEW DYNAMITE and NXT. We're now entering February 2020, with AEW coming off a January that saw the company sweep the Wednesday night ratings, secure its television future with WarnerMedia and begin finding a much stronger creative direction after a difficult December. ACEFIELD RETRO is jumping back into the DELOREAN for February 5 through March 11, 2020, as we revisit six consecutive Wednesdays, AEW's Revolution pay per view in Chicago and NXT TakeOver: Portland. Both promotions are delivering some of their strongest wrestling since the competition began, with major championship changes, increasingly personal rivalries and two important events that will help define the early months of 2020. But what makes this stretch especially fascinating is that we're watching the final weeks of wrestling television as everyone knew it before the COVID-19 pandemic completely changes the industry. Over on TNT, AEW is building toward Revolution with several of its biggest stories finally reaching their breaking points. Jon Moxley continues fighting through Chris Jericho's Inner Circle, defeating Ortiz, Santana and Jeff Cobb before finally dethroning Jericho on February 29 to become the second AEW World Champion. Kenny Omega and Hangman Page successfully defend the AEW World Tag Team Championships against SCU and the Lucha Brothers before facing the Young Bucks at Revolution in a match that becomes one of the most celebrated tag team encounters in wrestling history. Cody endures MJF's humiliating ten lashes, survives Wardlow inside a steel cage and finally gets his opportunity for revenge, only for MJF to steal the victory with his diamond ring. Nyla Rose defeats Riho to capture the AEW Women's World Championship, Kenny Omega and PAC deliver an outstanding thirty minute Iron Man match, Orange Cassidy makes his AEW singles debut against PAC and Death Triangle emerges as a new force within the company. We're examining how these matches and rivalries helped AEW establish a more consistent identity, why Revolution became such an important event for the young promotion and how Tony Khan's increasingly focused creative direction was beginning to pay off. Behind the scenes, we're also looking at Revolution's commercial success, AEW's growing confidence following its WarnerMedia extension, the competition for available talent and the company's preparations for Blood and Guts as March begins. Meanwhile, NXT is heading into TakeOver: Portland with the Undisputed ERA's championship dominance beginning to unravel and several of the Black and Gold brand's most important rivalries approaching major turning points. Keith Lee successfully defends the NXT North American Championship against Dominik Dijakovic in an incredible heavyweight encounter, Finn Bálor defeats Johnny Gargano and Dakota Kai defeats Tegan Nox in a violent street fight with help from the debuting Raquel González. Matt Riddle and Pete Dunne complete their unlikely rise as the BroserWeights by defeating Bobby Fish and Kyle O'Reilly to capture the NXT Tag Team Championships, while Adam Cole retains the NXT Championship against Tommaso Ciampa after Gargano shocks everyone by betraying his former partner. Rhea Ripley successfully defends against Bianca Belair before Charlotte Flair attacks her and accepts the challenge for WrestleMania, bringing one of WWE's biggest main roster stars directly into NXT's championship picture. In the weeks following Portland, Jordan Devlin defends the Cruiserweight Championship against Lio Rush, the Velveteen Dream continues his rivalry with Roderick Strong and the women's division begins qualifying for a planned ladder match at TakeOver: Tampa. We're examining whether Portland belongs among the strongest TakeOver events of the era, how WWE was positioning NXT heading into WrestleMania and what Charlotte's involvement revealed about the company's evolving approach to its third brand. Outside the Wednesday night competition, we're also revisiting Goldberg defeating Bray Wyatt for the Universal Championship at Super ShowDown, the continued rise of Tessa Blanchard in Impact, Marty Scurll's expanded responsibilities in Ring of Honor and the wider wrestling industry's increasingly competitive talent market. And the ratings continue telling an interesting story as AEW maintains its Wednesday night advantage, although NXT is beginning to narrow the gap compared with January. On February 5, Dynamite draws 928,000 viewers against NXT's 770,000, before the competition tightens considerably on February 12 when AEW attracts 817,000 against WWE's 757,000, a difference of only 60,000 viewers. Following TakeOver: Portland, NXT improves to 794,000 viewers on February 19, but Dynamite still wins with 893,000, while the February 26 go home show for Revolution draws 865,000 against NXT's 717,000. Across those four Wednesdays, AEW averages 875,750 viewers compared with NXT's 759,500, giving Dynamite an advantage of 116,250 viewers per episode and extending its winning streak to nine consecutive Wednesdays in 2020. But while AEW wins every February head to head battle, its average audience actually declines from January as NXT's improves, suggesting the competition is becoming closer despite the weekly results. We're comparing those numbers with Raw and SmackDown, examining whether acclaimed events like TakeOver: Portland and Revolution actually translate into sustained television growth and looking at the different business realities facing WWE and AEW. As we reach March 11, we're also examining how the rapidly developing coronavirus crisis is about to make traditional ratings comparisons considerably more complicated. More than anything, Episode 6 is about two wrestling companies hitting an important creative stride just as the entire industry is approaching an unprecedented disruption. AEW delivers Revolution, crowns Jon Moxley as its new World Champion and produces an extraordinary tag team championship match that demonstrates how effective its long term storytelling can become, while NXT answers with TakeOver: Portland, another outstanding showcase for the Black and Gold era built around Keith Lee, Finn Bálor, the BroserWeights and the latest chapter of Gargano and Ciampa's complicated history. AEW is continuing to win the television competition, but NXT is showing why its roster and TakeOver formula remain among the most respected in professional wrestling. We're also looking at how WWE's WrestleMania plans, its controversial decision to put the Universal Championship on Goldberg and the wider wrestling landscape were developing before everything changed. By March 11, AEW is preparing for Blood and Guts, NXT is building toward TakeOver: Tampa and WWE is still planning WrestleMania 36 as a major stadium event, with nobody fully prepared for the shutdowns and empty arena wrestling that will follow. This is the dividing line between the opening chapter of the Wednesday Night Wars and the completely different competition that emerges during the pandemic, making these six weeks one of the most fascinating periods we've revisited so far. Don't forget to grab your weekly Shot of Nostalgia to continue FLASHBACK FRIDAY ON THE TAVERN. As always, tip your bartenders & learn from the past!