QA64 - Listener Questions, Episode 64
In this Meaningful Money Q&A, Pete Matthew and Roger Weeks answer listener questions on UK personal finance, pensions and investing. They discuss why spending on small things can feel difficult, managing your own finances in retirement, and whether a 5% pension withdrawal rate with guardrails could work. They also explore State Pension tax and moving private pensions into ISAs, plus investing, buying a first home and repaying student loans. Finally, they consider how to balance saving for a home and a pension when starting again after divorce. Shownotes: https://meaningfulmoney.tv/QA64 02:18 Question 1 Hi Pete and Roger, As always, thank you for all your great content. I hope you realise just how much you've helped so many people. The gift of sorting out your finances isn't just the practical benefit, but the peace of mind that comes with doing so, so thank you. I'd love to hear your thoughts about why spending money on small things is so difficult. I'm 31, and am fortunate to have most things in place with my finances. For large purchases like holidays, cars etc I plan and budget appropriately, and don't mind spending generously on these. But I feel a disproportionate amount of stress about not wasting money on more trivial things. I worry about the rising cost of fruit in the supermarket. I buy in bulk to save pennies on basic items. My old Airpods are half-broken, but the right ear just about works okay, and so I can't bring myself to spend the £200 to replace them. My rational brain knows all of this is unnecessary. I know I could just spend the money and not have to think about these things. I hear of similar stories from people in retirement struggling to pivot to decumulation. Why is this, and how can we think about things differently to take a more rational approach to more 'low-level' spending? All the best, James 11:03 Question 2 Hi Pete and Roger, I'm in my early 30's and genuinely enjoy all aspects of personal finance. I'm the sort of person who is comfortable with spreadsheets and so tend to model a lot of my finances this way. Over many years of listening to the podcast I've gained an appreciation for the scenarios and situations where professional advice can be invaluable. At the same time, I really appreciate that Pete has built Meaningful Money around the idea that you can do this stuff for yourself, provided you're willing to put in the time and effort. I wanted to know your thoughts on how you think this translates into retirement. For those that genuinely enjoy managing their own finances do you think there are meaningful risks with continuing this self managed approach into retirement? For example, managing a large pension pot in drawdown and planning withdrawal strategies may become more difficult in the later years depending on health. Do either of you intend to manage your finances independently in retirement? I'd be really interested to understand your own thought processes. Thanks for everything you do and keep up the great work. Zak 18:14 Question 3 Hi Pete and Roger, Thankyou both for creating this excellent podcast which has been instrumental in improving my financial knowledge and getting me to what I now consider to be financially independent. The Meaningful Money Podcast is the podcast that I look out for first each week, and consume as soon as it is available. There are not many podcasts that are uniquely tailored to UK listeners in this space, so you provide an invaluable resource to listeners like me, which is much appreciated. I aim to retire in March 2027 (at the end of the current tax tear), when I will be 57 years old. My question is around safe withdrawal rates. Most people are aware of the 4% rule, which has the premise that retirees can withdraw 4% of their portfolio on retirement, increase by inflation each year, and be more or less certain to not run out of money over a 30 year period (based on historical data). The downside of the 4% rule is that it often leaves a significant amount of money on the table on death. I would like to increase my starting rate to 5%, but build in some simple guardrails to counter sequence of return risk, should the initial market performance prove to be a problem in the early years. My proposed guardrails are as follows: - No inflationary increase in down years (when portfolio value is down on prior year balance) - Inflationary increase to be calculated using CPI not RPI (which is typically lower and be more applicable to my circumstances due to mortgage having been paid in full) - Inflation increase capped at 5% (so do not increase beyond 5% in years of high inflation) - Reduce withdrawal amount by 10% in years where portfolio reduces by > 20% (in that year only). In following year the withdrawal amount returns to previous amount (unless portfolio balance falls by another 20%) - Full state pension will be available at age 67, so can reduce drawdown by state pension amount at that time (this will reduce my drawdown from retirement pot to approx 4.4%, based on current pension amounts) - No inflationary increases after age 75 due to expected slow-go/no-go years - Retirement pot will be invested on a 60/40 basis, using mainly low cost passive global tracker funds, and contain a minimum of 2 years of cash in the 40 portion to use to counter bad sequence of returns in early years, if needed. I have put the above scenario through a couple of the readily available AI tools, and they have indicated that my plan has a very high probability of success. I understand that you cannot give financial advice on the podcast but would love to get your views on how I am approaching this, and whether this approach is consistent with how you have seen this undertaken in the real world by your clients. Thanks again for the excellent podcast, and I look forward to hearing your thoughts on this. Colin 25:23 Question 4 Hi Pete and Roger, I have been a loyal listener of your podcast for over five years and look forward to every new episode. I am writing with a question on behalf of my parents. Both my mother (70) and father (73) receive the full state pension alongside very small private pensions. I recall the government mentioning that if the state pension exceeds the personal tax allowance—which is expected in the 27/28 tax year—it would not be taxed if it were an individual's only source of income. However, I have been unable to find official guidance on this. Do you know if this is correct? If so, would it be a good idea for my parents to withdraw their remaining private pensions this tax year (£12,000 for my father and £25,000 for my mother) and move the funds into an ISA to avoid future tax? Their current withdrawal requirement is approximately £5,000 per year combined for holidays and emergencies, meaning these funds would likely last another seven to eight years. After that, they will rely solely on the state pension. They also own their home and have the option to downsize in the future if necessary. Thank you for your thoughts. Kind regards, Louise 30:43 Question 5 Hi Roger and Pete, I've been listening to the podcast for just under a year now on my way to work, and I think I've finally caught up with every episode. Sadly, I've never ventured onto your YouTube channel for fear that both of you might be far too dashingly good-looking for me ever to concentrate on what you're saying. Your podcast never fails to make me chuckle, although I'm not entirely sure what that says about my character at the ripe old age of 22. As the Simon & Garfunkel of the financial world, I was hoping you could share your thoughts on whether I'm heading in the right direction financially. I have been working for just under a year after graduating from university with a degree that has absolutely nothing to do with my current job. I'm still living at home, which means no rent, no bills, and free food. The plan is to move out in around 18 months once I've completed the professional qualification for my job. The downside is that I'm earning close to minimum wage. I recently cashed in the Premium Bonds I've had since birth because I felt the money could be working harder. I used £16,000 to fill my Stocks & Shares ISA with accumulating global equity index funds and invested around the same amount into a GIA with the same investment strategy. My parents also contribute £4,000 each year into my Lifetime ISA. My current plan is to invest £1,000 into the GIA each month, cover my spending, and put anything left over into a high-interest savings account as my emergency fund, while also retaining a few Premium Bonds for the love of the game. At the end of each tax year, I plan to bed and ISA as much of the GIA as possible, rinse and repeat, and pray I don't end up with a capital gains tax bill. I also have a SIPP that my parents started for me. It's currently invested 80% in equity ETFs and 20% in bonds, although I'm planning to switch it to 100% equities given my age. I've also changed my workplace pension from the default fund into a global equity index fund, but I'm only making the minimum contributions at the moment. So, my questions are: - Does my overall approach seem sensible? - Should I prioritise increasing my workplace pension contributions through salary sacrifice, contribute more to my SIPP, or continue investing into my GIA? - I don't really like the idea of renting—I know that's a controversial opinion—but my goal is to buy my first home as soon as possible. If I buy in around 18 months' time, I'll probably only have around £16,000 in my Lifetime ISA. Can I use both my Stocks & Shares ISA and my Lifetime ISA towards my house purchase, or is it one or the other? - Finally, my student loan. My parents have offered to pay it off as part of their estate planning to reduce a future inheritance tax bill, but we're unsure whether that's actually the best financial decision. I'd love to hear your thoughts—not advice—on whether that seems sensible. Sorry for the long email, but I know/hope you love these deep down. Thank you for brightening up my drive to work every morning. With the kindest regards, Sean 39:15 Question 6 Hello Pete and Roger, I love both Meaningful Money and Bank of Dad podcasts. I've learnt so much in the last year since I found you, thank you for all you do! Like so many people, I find myself mid 40's, recently divorced. Anyone who's gone through this knows the impact of breaking up finances and starting again. I'm now saving for my first solo ownership house from £zero, desperate to save enough for a deposit by the time I'm 50 , So I can clear the mortgage before retirement. On the side I'm trying to contribute as much as I can to pension as I know that clock is ticking too. As more people will find themselves in that situation than ever, any focus on starting again with a shorter timeline to save, in future shows would be belting! Thanks all! Jonny --- Meaningful Digest Newsletter, signup at: https://meaningfulmoney.tv/signup